Switching from Levo to NDT : Advice please... I'm... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

136,962 members160,559 posts

Switching from Levo to NDT

Wishingwell profile image
32 Replies

Advice please... I'm on a very high dose of Levo and want to switch to NDT - as my Levo is high if I follow STTM protocol I believe I will become hypo very quickly.

I don't know whether to lower Levo and add one grain split into 2 doses or stop Levo but take more than one grain? If anyone has had experience of switching from very high dose Levo to NDT please can you pm me ? Thanks

Written by
Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
32 Replies
jade_s profile image
jade_s

The way my doc had me do this a few years ago was to drop small amounts of levo and add in equivalent amounts of NDT. I think she had me swap 1/2 grain for 25 mcg T4 every 7-14 days. You could go for a whole grain but the extra T3 could be difficult to handle at first, thus the suggestion to start with 1/2 grain. I did quite OK on this and didn't really notice any side-effects except for some shaking in my hands (which comes back any time I go on T3). Good luck!

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to jade_s

Thank you 👍

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to jade_s

Just working out the maths so in your case your doc was equating 1 grain to 50mcg t4?

Was that being cautious ? Or was that about right allowing for the t3?

jade_s profile image
jade_s in reply to Wishingwell

Yes your maths look to be right. I have no idea if that equivalency is cautious or not - I have read about various different conversions...

i think i read on this forum some people saying 1 grain = 100mcg T4 but I personally think 1 grain is much less than 100 T4. The math wouldn't work out anyway. Since NDT has 38 mcg T4, the remaining T3 in that 1 grain would give a potency of 7x that of T4, to get up to 100 T4.

That is, 1 grain = 38 T4 + (9 T3)*(7) =~ 100 T4. I doubt T3 is 7x as powerful as T4.

A more reasonable conversion IMO is

1 grain = 38 T4 +(9 T3)*(3) =~ 65 mcg T4

The real problem is that no one knows how the T3 will affect them, so it's quite possible to need a totally different dose of NDT compared to Levo, even if one knew the exact potency of T3 compared to T4 and could compute the exact equivalencies. So I would see these more as starting guidelines. STTM says to raise to 2 to 3 grains and then test after 6 weeks - you could swap over until you get to e.g. 3 grains, drop the remaining levo, and see how it goes.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to jade_s

The manufacturers tend to suggest 1 grain as replacement of 100 micrograms of levothyroxine. I interpret that as a cautious calculation intended to avoid anyone overdosing if they switch over at that rate.

(This also means anyone switching BACK to levothyroxine had better be careful!)

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to helvella

Thanks that's good to know - so I think then I can drop 100 and add 1 grain relatively safely if it's a cautious calculation - I'm on such a high dose of Levo this is really the only way for me to switch. Thank you !! 👍

jade_s profile image
jade_s in reply to Wishingwell

good luck :)

I44T39 profile image
I44T39 in reply to Wishingwell

What dose are you on? I'm very confused with the grain to mg thing, never heard the dose to be in grains..

My boyfriend takes 100mg of levothyroxine per day, he wants to change to dessicated thyroid but we have no help from the GP or the specialist none of them seem to know what they are talking about!! Tony isn't any better since taking the levo for the past about 16 months, in fact he is much worse.. Continually looses weight, 1 and 1/2 stone in 10 months, maybe 2 now as he hates weighing himself.. Doctors just say can't understand why you still feel ill your levels are fine etc.. When Tony asked for dessicated thyroid they'd never heard if it and said definitely couldn't prescribe it.. I've found so wine on here that gets erfa thyroid from a reputable chemist in Andorra and they sell it without prescription, she says its legit and she has used it for a long time.. What dosage should Tony start off with and should he start off gradually introducing erfa taking erfa and levo and gradually reducing levo..??

I'm at my wits end with all this, his ill health and getting no medical help can someone please help.. Any help and advice greatly appreciated, thank you..

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to I44T39

If your partner is on 100mcg Levo that's roughly equivalent to 1 grain I say roughly as it isn't easy to directly compare but if he is losing weight it does t sound like hypo have a look at the list of symptoms of both hypo and hyper. Good luck.

jade_s profile image
jade_s in reply to helvella

Ah OK, I was wondering where those numbers came from. thanks :)

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to jade_s

From here, for example:

getrealthyroid.com/the-real...

jade_s profile image
jade_s in reply to helvella

I wish there was an "unlike" button ;)

So insane, no one who takes 3 grains was previously on 300 mcg T4, nor likely would have been able to tolerate such a dose. Such a shame too that this comes from RLC labs!

Frustratedmum profile image
Frustratedmum

About to do the same myself and I have asked for advice too! I currently take a high dose of Levo but I remember reading start with 1 grain for 2 weeks before slowly increasing. I'm just waiting for some confirmation. Good luck with the switch!

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to Frustratedmum

Pm

I44T39 profile image
I44T39 in reply to Frustratedmum

I don't understand what a grain dose is.. He's on 125mg levothyroxine per day..

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to I44T39

A grain is a traditional unit of weight. It is between 60 and 65 milligrams.

He will be on 125 micrograms of levothyroxine. (Not milligrams.)

Desiccated thyroid is produced in tablets of one grain (and in some makes, multiples of that). They sometimes say 60 mg, sometimes 65 mg, sometimes one grain. All are very much the same thing.

Desiccated thyroid is manufactured and dosed by weight of dried thyroid powder contained - NOT by the thyroid hormone contained.

Levothyroxine is by weight of actual thyroid hormnone contained.

It is absolutely vital that you understand this and do some reading before making any changes.

Frustratedmum profile image
Frustratedmum

Just found this!!

tpauk.com/main/article/how-...

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator

As far as I know when switching from levo to NDT you can do a straight swop-over, i.e. 100mcg of levo is roughly equivalent to 1 grain of NDT.

If all your clinical symptoms resolve you remain on the dose but if symptoms start you increase dose by 1/2 grain every two weeks until you are symptom free. (I prefer increasing by 1/4 when you feel you are nearing your optimum dose). If pulse or temp increase too much, reduce to the previous dose.

(I am not medically qualified - have had undiagnosed/unmedicated hypothyroidism but am now well on T3 only). I also tried other alternatives.

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to shaws

Thank you.

Ruthi profile image
Ruthi

I would beware of switching directly. I did that and went hyper very quickly. I wasn't converting and so I got a huge rush of T3 which was great for a day or so, and then everything started to jitter.

The gradual approach is going to be a lot safer. Hopefully you won't need a huge dose of NDT and if you go gradually you can fine tune much more easily.

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to Ruthi

So to avoid that presumably you could reduce by 100 mcg Levo and add in one grain and see how you go? Split in two doses ?

Ruthi profile image
Ruthi in reply to Wishingwell

That seems the most sensible. Then if you feel yourself going hyper you can replace the next 100 with less NDT. It took me about a year to work out my optimal dose. And some winters I increase slightly.

I don't split my dose. Tried it, made no difference, and too easy to forget the second dose.

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to Ruthi

Ok thank you I think I will do that as if I try to stop Levo and start on 1 grain I know I will crash.

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to Ruthi

Thanks for your support back when I started NDT having just read about winter - it's freezing - and wondering whether I could do with a tweak reading your post has reminded me. Btw I've been doing great on NDT over Levo - switched over by weaning off Levo thank you! 👍

I44T39 profile image
I44T39 in reply to Ruthi

What are the symptoms of a hypo or going hyper?

Ruthi profile image
Ruthi in reply to I44T39

There are over 300 symptoms associated with hypo, probably as many for hyper! There's a fairly comprehensive list on the ThyroidUK website IIRC,

Glynisrose profile image
Glynisrose

Try dropping the levo altogether for a couple of days then start on a low dose of NDT it works! I felt amazing even on a low dose.

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell

I can't do that - I'm on a very high dose Levo so if I do what you have suggested it's highly likely I will crash. But thank you for taking the time to reply to me.

Jillkh profile image
Jillkh

I was on 175 mg of Levo I stopped that and the next day started on 150 of Thyrogold. I had no problem switching this but then made the mistake of increasing too quickly.

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell in reply to Jillkh

How did you get on with that product after? I have considered that one and have emailed Tammy.

Jillkh profile image
Jillkh

I am still on it. Initially I got all sort of side effects, ( itching skin, aching joints, tunnel vision, palpitations) I think because I raised too fast or may have been a reaction to the NDT itself. But they have all subsided. I feel more energetic, I have a clearer brain. My anxiety and depression have got better, and I have started to lose weight. I think that it's a case of trial and error. Some people prefer WP or Amour and don't like Thyrogold. have you deceieded which one you will go with?

Wishingwell profile image
Wishingwell

I've got thiroyd ... Haven't started it yet but got as was cheap. Looked at naturethroid and thyrogold too ... Will prob get one of those but have to pay customs duty on both brands .. Think will try thyrogold as some people seem to do well on it.

You may also like...

Switching from ndt to Levo

Anyone on here switched from NDT to Levo and found it positive ? I'm interested in how it feels and...

Switching from levo to ndt symptoms

I've recently started switching from levo to ndt. I was on 275mcg levo and with advice from Clutter...

switching from levo to NDT troubles

i gave up and went back on levo thinking that it was doing more damage than good. After speaking to...

Switch from NDT to Levo, yes or no?

So I don't know if Levo will work for me, or not. I'm unemployed, so the raised price of NDT is...

Thinking of switching back to Levo from NDT

weeks ago, I finally settled on a dose of 1 grain of NDT and 25mcg of Levo. Finally things started...