Not a question, but please read Jeanette Winter... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

140,468 members165,269 posts

Not a question, but please read Jeanette Winterson's article on the menopause in the Review part of today's Guardian (Sat 12/04/2014).

GrittyReads profile image
3 Replies

It's not specifically about Thyroid, but it does repeatedly question the sense of the 'one size fits all' approach to treating women - particularly their hormonal changes and challenges - in the NHS. It targets the questionable nature of many 'big pharma' HRT products, and their dosage (over-generous, non-variable). In particular, it questions (several times) the accuracy or sensitivity of the 'normal' ranges for hormones, chemicals, vits and minerals, that are set in the UK, particularly for thyroid treatment. It also stresses the need for more careful checking of vitamins and minerals. eg when our ferritin is rock-bottom it's no good to keep telling us to eat more red meat!! Read it, tweet it, tweet her, write to the Guardian, tell all your friends. Like her or not JW is a good figurehead to get behind on this one, maybe we can rally round and achieve change.

Written by
GrittyReads profile image
GrittyReads
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
3 Replies

I was about to post an alert to this article too, so am glad to see you've beaten me to it. I think it's very important....and good to have someone so articulate publicly questioning mainstream medicine.

She has clearly faced the same problems with the medical profession as most of us on here, though it's unclear whether or not her thyroid was involved.

rimmer profile image
rimmer

Hi

I totally agree docs n specialist put tests results under one umbrella... but were not all the same.wants normal for one is not normal for everyone when will docs n specialists reconize this..especially if the symptoms say otherwise..

Winegum2 profile image
Winegum2

theguardian.com/books/2014/...

Is this the same article? It's from April, but I thought they may have re-run it.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Vitamins and minerals test results help?

Hello, I've just received my results from hair analysis test, I got this test due to symptoms I am...

letter for family and friends

LIVING WITH THYROID- A LETTER TO FAMILY AND FRIENDS "How do you explain to your family what you...

It's not all in your head.

Before and after of hashimotos hypothyroidism. My face says it all , yet my bloods said within...

Can someone help my sister?

Just looking for some opinions here. I've been on Levi 50mcgs since Nov last year after being told...

For info: Just had a big rant on government survey on women's health

UK Government are doing a consultation on women's health until 13 June (although in England only...