BCR at 14 years. Salvage RT w boost, ... - Prostate Cancer N...

Prostate Cancer Network

5,386 members3,426 posts

BCR at 14 years. Salvage RT w boost, dementia concerns

David1958 profile image
28 Replies

Hard to believe. After radical prostatectomy, I did my PSA test every year with non-detectable levels until a few months ago it shows up at 0.4. did it again, just to make sure there was no error in testing, and it is 0.4 again. Doctor did a PSMA PET and found a small spot on one pelvic lymph node. At the time of my RP in April 2011, I was Gleason 3 + 4, pT3a, with some extra capsular extension but no positive margins. They had problems on my right side, because of lots of scar tissue from a previous hernia surgery. Tested two to three lymph nodes which were clear at the time.

I am suffering some mild cognitive impairment, with genetic confirmation of frontal temporal neurodegeneration (which runs in my family). So I elected NOT TO DO anti androgen therapy, based on latest publications about blood-brain barrier neuro-inflammation.

Who would have thought this would have happened after nearly 14 years?! Currently going through 43 RT sessions which includes a boost.

Written by
David1958 profile image
David1958
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
28 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

That sucks! It's a f**king sneaky disease for sure!

DannyMan profile image
DannyMan in reply toTall_Allen

Allen, (just replied to the most recent reply I saw of yours):

I am Gleason 5/4 non metastatic.

On my last few IMRT sessions (full pelvic per SOC).

On Lupron - get second 3-month injection this Friday.

I thought (very early on here) I came across a study that basically said 18 months of ADT with full pelvic radiation was as or nearly effective as 24.

Is this accurate?

I obviously want to be on ADT for less time, but I also don’t want to make any dumb decision so close to a possible end of this…

Thx in advance …

Dan

gsun profile image
gsun in reply toDannyMan

As far as i have read, even 12 months is enough for your case. What I can glean, the longer you are on it, the longer the progression free survival. But that’s because you take it longer, not because it knocks out the cancer.Progression free survival would be even longer if you never stopped. In your case, being non metastatic, you could do shorter, IMO.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply toDannyMan

The SOC for those getting external beam radiation is 26 months of ADT.

prostatecancer.news/2022/01...

The POP-RT trial had excellent results with 2 years of ADT in high risk men:

prostatecancer.news/2021/08...

Spinel_Cutter profile image
Spinel_Cutter in reply toTall_Allen

Great articles, thank you. " patients getting varying doses of EBRT or high dose rate brachy boost therapy (BBT). They found that 18 months is better than 6 months for BBT, but is there a duration that is less than 18 months for BBT?"

How about my future which is 3 months of orgo+abi, to shrink the protate, then followed by x episodes of IMRT followed by Brachy?

I hope to be doing that test that predicts aggressiveness, and I hope that I can stop the ADT at 12 months...

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply toSpinel_Cutter

12 months for BBT. It hasn't been tried with abi, except when positive pelvic lymph nodes have been detected.

Spinel_Cutter profile image
Spinel_Cutter in reply toTall_Allen

Thanks. Interesting, I was pushed towards Lupron + IMRT but I wanted Org+Abi + IMRT + Brachy. Gleason 8 with small extraprostatic extension to the pelvic sling (~5mm) no + anything on PSMA-PET. I consulted with Alicia Morgans at Dana Farber and she said what I wanted made a lot of sense, so I've gone with that. I intend to do decipher and let that determine if I stay on the meds for 12, 18 or 24 months. I was very impressed with the addition of brachy to IMRT. Though the 5-year survival was about the same, the the + brachy flattened out to 12+ years, while the non-brachy continued down. Maybe I'm breaking now ground with brachy....

DannyMan profile image
DannyMan in reply toTall_Allen

thx!

Xavier10 profile image
Xavier10

I mean, in some ways I guess the f@@*ker was nice enough to wait 14 years. But yeah, that's a drag when the enemy you thought you had conquered years ago pops back up. Seems like it must be a fairly non aggressive variant though so maybe this radiation will knock it back another 14

stealthrider profile image
stealthrider

Sorry for your bad news, my father in law had biochemical recurrence at 10 yrs, NO PSMA PET at that time so they just radiated his prostate bed. Should have included pelvic lymph nodes as that is where is finally showed up. Good luck to you

allie2020 profile image
allie2020

That is a bum deal to have a recurrence after 14 years. I have to believe it is a weak version of PCa to take that long. I had my RP in 2018 and all undetectable. I saw my Urologist recently about an unrelated matter. I said, 'it's got to be rare to have a BCR after 7 years.' He replied, 'pretty rare.' I again said , 'it's got to be rare.' He replied again, 'pretty rare.' That's the best I could get out of him. Best of luck with the radiation.

tn12 profile image
tn12 in reply toallie2020

I don't get it

David1958 profile image
David1958 in reply totn12

He wanted to hear "real rare"!

PSAed profile image
PSAed in reply totn12

Neither did the Doc. 😀

allie2020 profile image
allie2020 in reply totn12

Very simple. I was hoping my Dr. would agree that is is rare but he would only characterize it as pretty rare. Hopefully, you understand the difference.

leach234 profile image
leach234

isn’t extracapsular extension the definition of positive margin? pT3a means it’s broken through the capsule so isn’t that a positive margin?

Gardenpests profile image
Gardenpests in reply toleach234

pT3a here with 4 years undetectable PSA.

From Johns Hopkins.

T3: The tumor has grown outside the prostate. It may have spread to the seminal vesicles.

T3a: The tumor has developed outside the prostate; however, it has not spread to the seminal vesicles.

T3b: The tumor has spread to the seminal vesicles.

Here is a wiki illustration of surgical margin.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resec...

leach234 profile image
leach234 in reply toGardenpests

That’s not my understanding. pT3a means it has escaped the prostate and the tumor is only on one side of the prostate. pT3b means it has escaped the prostate and you have tumors on both sides of the prostate.

David1958 profile image
David1958 in reply toleach234

I believe you are right. At the time in 2011, my urologist seem to emphasize extra capsular extension without positive margin, but yet I see pt3a there right there in the postoperative report. After all these years, the details are not quite as sharp in my memory

RJAMSG profile image
RJAMSG

Congrats on the 14 years of undetectable but sorry to hear about that spot. It would be interesting to me to see your PSA results over time, mostly boring I'm sure but I would like to see them. I guess since it is at .4 not considered "early salvage", I almost wonder if it wasn't some Gleason 3+3 that has been hanging around and just slowing growing in that spot since it took so long. Prayers for your health! God Bless Rob

drzaius profile image
drzaius

Very disheartening I’m sure David1958. If there’s a positive in this it’s that radiation has improved in those 14 years and is much more accurate and effective and thus less side effects. Wishing you Godspeed.

ManuteBol1 profile image
ManuteBol1

Hello. Sorry to hear you are having a recurrence after all of this time.

Do you happen to be aware as to what testing threshold your undetectable tests were using over all of that time? Were the readings <0.1? Or <0.02? Or something else?

David1958 profile image
David1958 in reply toManuteBol1

Every last one of them was non-detectable. And then 0.4, and things moved swiftly within one month

ManuteBol1 profile image
ManuteBol1 in reply toDavid1958

I get that they were undetectable, but what threshold was the test using over all of that time? A test being undetectable means it isn’t registering above the limit of sensitivity of that particular test’s assay.

Mgtd profile image
Mgtd

Friend just a couple of months ago after 20+ years showed a PSA rise.

David1958 profile image
David1958 in reply toMgtd

That is extremely rare.

Boacan profile image
Boacan

I am on a similar path as after 4+ years post RALP, and undetectable uPSA, the beast reappeared. My pathology was similar with pT3a and Gleason 3+4. PSA is .03 and repeat testing is .02 and so MO wants to monitor further before seeking PSMA scan to try and locate the “sneaky” SOB. I can only hope the it’s the non-aggressive variant and that salvage RT & ADT can put it back in the cage. Best wishes to all of us that are fighting this battle…

David1958 profile image
David1958

I am not doing the ADT because of the neurological considerations for me. My poor brain can't take more assault.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

PSA spiked

Hi, I am new at HealthUnlocked. PSA 29.4 and after biopsy (10 samples - 4 at 30% and 6 at 50%)...
Asianbites profile image

SBRT for favourable intermediate - interested to hear your experience

hi there, interested to hear from the intermediate favourable men who had SBRT for primary...
45RPM profile image

My decision on Radiotherapy -v- Prostatectomy

I hope this story might be useful to others. I'm based in the UK and had a PSA of 12.7 from a test...
MarkS profile image

My 12 month Journey on Active Surveillance

Hi all, I wanted to share some positive news in hope that it may help others in a similar...
JVARA profile image

End to active surviellance

I have been on active surveillance for eleven years. That has now ended. For the last couple of...

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.