Osteopenia - should I persuade my GP not to presc... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

21,317 members40,425 posts

Osteopenia - should I persuade my GP not to prescribe AA?

katzma profile image
14 Replies

Just got my DEXA scan results back via the NHS app. and seeing my GP on Monday to discuss the osteopenia diagnosis. T scores are: AP Spine -1.7; Femoral Leg -1.5; Total Hip -1.2.

2 months on, my PMR pain and stiffness is thankfully at bay on 12.5mg of prednisolone. but I'm hating the side effects, and fearful of adding yet more medication, given that I have been blessed with excellent health prior to this. 

Finally beginning to feel human again for at least part of the day so Im determined to try anything that will help heal naturally. I’m back to walking every day and have just started using the Pilates for osteoporosis video on the UK NHS website. Also planning to mix in some yoga sessions for osteopenia which are available on YouTube.

I came across this video this morning  via a Google search :  Osteoporosis - There IS Something You Can Do. An Interview With Sara Meeks (P.T., M.S., G.C.S., K.Y.T).

Makes total sense to me, hence my question… do I really need to take the recommended  Risedronate 35mg weekly? Thankfully my GP does listen!

Written by
katzma profile image
katzma
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
14 Replies
DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer

Please discuss -you probably don’t need it -see this - osteopenia doesn’t necessarily progress to osteoporosis

From guidelines --

6) We recommend the use of bone protection when initiating steroids for PMR to prevent the complications of osteoporosis .

Individuals with high fracture risk, e.g. aged over 65 years or prior fragility fracture􏰀

Bisphosphonate with calcium and vitamin D supplementation

DEXA not required.

Other individuals􏰀

Calcium and vitamin D supplementation when starting steroid therapy.􏰀

DEXA scan recommended􏰀

A bone-sparing agent may be indicated if T-scoreis 􏰁1.5 or lower..

Individuals requiring higher initial steroid dose􏰀

Bisphosphonate with calcium and vitamin D supplementation (because higher cumulative dose of steroids is likely) 

Depending on your circumstances, and how agreeable GP is , you probably only need VitD/calcium supplement

Some seem to pick & choose what they following from guidelines!

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

Those t-scores wouldn't normally trigger use of a bisphosphonate - they are the same as mine were 13 years ago when I started pred and my GP agreed with me that that didn't need AA so I wouldn't start it unless regular dexascans showed I needed it. I've had 4 dexas, still OK and still no AA. The local osteoporosis guru who used to be n at me to take AA now just says to keep doing what I'm doing.

I think a good dose of vit D is important - I take 4000 IU a day, plenty of calcium in my diet and walk as much as I can manage which isn't that far, about a mile or so.

katzma profile image
katzma in reply toPMRpro

Your similar results experience is really encouraging and hopefully will help win the case against the more meds discussion! I will also ask about increasing the calcium and vit D supplements .

Many thanks for your invaluable input to everyone's endless questions😊

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply tokatzma

Not more combined supplements though - too much calcium can be bad, I always took separate vit D.

Poshdog profile image
Poshdog in reply toPMRpro

sInce having blood test revealing high cholesterol and recommended statins, I have stopped taking extra calcium, doubled up on vit D and refused statins. Hopefully makes some sense!

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toPoshdog

My cholesterol has also risen since Actemra - having had 2 bad experiences with statins my rheumy offered Ezetimibe. We'll see - it can also cause muscle aches and pains!!!!! But I doubt I would know ...

PS - why less calcium?

Poshdog profile image
Poshdog in reply toPMRpro

Think I get enough through diet and hate taking

katzma profile image
katzma in reply toPMRpro

Because of the high cholesterol risk? Mine is around 4 I think at the moment

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply tokatzma

There seems to be a lot of dispute as to whether calcium supplements raise or lower cholesterol levels! Seems to raise HDL and possibly slight decrease LDL but the studies seem a bit varied in quality.

autumnlass profile image
autumnlass

Hello Katzma

Was interested in your DXA scan results.. I had mine about a month ago.

My results showed that my lumbar spine has a T score of -1.0: Hips have a T score of -1.1 : Left Femur -1.2 Right Femur -1.0.

I’m told I’m in the osteopaenic range still and have been taking Risendronate 35 mgms weekly with no ill effect and AdCal every evening.

Love walking and try to to 5 - 7k steps daily.

However in 1995 and 2003 had 2 fractured ankles and put on AA as was osteopaenic. Horrible! I put up with it for too long!

Good Luck with your fitness schedule. 🍀

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toautumnlass

hopkinsmedicine.org/health/....

A T score of -1 to +1 is considered normal bone density.

A T score of -1 to -2.5 indicates osteopenia (low bone density).

A T score of -2.5 or lower is bone density low enough to be categorized as osteoporosis.

If they are classing your results as osteopenia that requires medication I have to say I am appalled. Anything better than -1.6 is considered to only require calcium and vit D. Particularly questionable since the vast majority of fractures occur in bones with normal bone density!

autumnlass profile image
autumnlass in reply toPMRpro

Thank you PMRpro - on reading the members katzma’s post I followed up my letter from the DEXA scan department which prompted me to write to the forum with my results.

These results were similar to the one I had taken in 2019, and my GP suggested Alendronic Acid which I refused. Prior to that in 2016 the results were better.

I reluctantly began Risendronate in April ‘21, 9 months after diagnosis in July ‘20 as my GP was a bit cross!

Nothing has changed much - no better, no worse. 🧐

katzma profile image
katzma in reply toautumnlass

Hi autumn lass and thanks for your input. So sorry that you ended up with the fractures and good to hear that you are ok with Risendronate - but I still want to hold off taking it if I can. Hopefully the yoga/pilates will improve balance and I'm super careful when walking... who knows what's lurking under the lovely leaves!

autumnlass profile image
autumnlass

Good for you! I’m sure it’ll work for you too! 🍀

My paternal family history has one of one of bony problems. Grandmother father and sister had/have kypho-scoliosis of the spine and elder sister has osteoporosis which has now affected her breathing sometimes. I’ve luckily escaped that! As you say what’s lurking under the lovely autumn leaves! 🤣🍁🍂🍃

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Alendronic Acid, Fosamax...To take or not to take was my question.

So, you’ve been diagnosed with PMR and/or GCA and your doctor has prescribed something for your...
Insight329 profile image

Am I being stupid?

Your expert opinions would be appreciated. I started 15mg pred in Dec 2016 after being diagnosed...
Urtica profile image

Shout out to my GP

I am so sorry for those of you who do not have a positive experience with your GP, since the start...

osteoporosis diagnosis

Hello I was diagnosed with PMR and GCA in November 2018 and have been slowly tapering my prednisone...
Fishponds50 profile image

Osteoporosis

Hi Have had a bone scan this morning and it showed osteoporosis in my right femur and osteopenia in...
Mitziecat profile image

Moderation team

SophieMB profile image
SophieMBPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.