My silly query for the day!: I religiously eat 6/... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

20,320 members38,060 posts

My silly query for the day!

Rosbud profile image
55 Replies

I religiously eat 6/8 prunes daily and my OH has just asked me why and what are they supposed to do for me , was it this site I read it on that they are good for my osteoporosis, please tell me I’m not going loopy in my old age , thanks for your help xxx

Written by
Rosbud profile image
Rosbud
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
55 Replies
Songbird69 profile image
Songbird69

I have friends who do this to keep their bones strong. I keep meaning to do it myself! So you are definitely not loopy!! 🤣

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to Songbird69

Thank you, do doubt myself sometimes x

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

It is said they are good for preventing osteoporosis - not so good for keeping pred weight down though!!! Bit carby ...

But backed up by study evidence:

newswire.ca/news-releases/a....

And another comment about the fact that they can even reverse loss of bone density - in mice and with 25% of their diet being prunes ...

scientificamerican.com/arti...

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to PMRpro

Thank you so much , will read both of these again and hopefully take in all of it xx

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Rosbud

Give it to himself to read!

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to PMRpro

I will , definitely x

Marijo1951 profile image
Marijo1951

I started to do the same after reading research that showed that a few prunes per day can prevent bone loss in older women, as PMRpro mentions. This is the study that influenced me: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/269...

I should add that this was after I decided not to take allendronic acid or other bisphosphonates, but thought I should do something towards maintaining bone health.

YuliK profile image
YuliK

Four prunes (32 grams) contain 2 grams of fiber and about 7% of your daily requirements for vitamin A and potassium (5). Prunes also contain sorbitol, a type of sugar alcohol that your body poorly digests. It helps alleviate constipation by drawing water into the intestines, spurring a bowel movement .

Well those prunes must certainly keep your bowels moving. 👍

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to YuliK

Haven’t noticed them helping but do notice i miss A couple of days !

YuliK profile image
YuliK in reply to Rosbud

A couple of days is too long. Boots the Chemist sell natural fibre tablets called senokot. ( non chemical)Worth checking them out.

As we get older, out bodies are inclined to be less active in that area, and it’s important to be a regular visitor to the bathroom.

senokot.com/laxatives/senok...

YuliK. 😷

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to YuliK

Thanks , have lactulose from Dr if and when I need it x

Constance13 profile image
Constance13

I agree with the other comments - also very good for keeping constipation at bay. I cook them and drink the water - having added two teaspoons of olive oil.

Also delicious as a desert with custard.💥

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to Constance13

Oh I love them with rice pudding x

Longtimer profile image
Longtimer in reply to Rosbud

Remember that at school!...

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to Longtimer

Yes , I was A dinner lady for A while and the little darlings had it once A week x

Longtimer profile image
Longtimer

Then we must be loopy together!....have often read 6 prunes a day to help with osteoporosis.....so they go on my breakfast....

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS

Yes, boron, also found in other fruits and vegetables, and even coffee. Prunes supposed to be particularly beneficial.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS

This is interesting:

ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/B...

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to HeronNS

Thanks , I’ll catch up

On this later x

Mstiles profile image
Mstiles

Could they be a problem if you’re trying to keep sugar levels down?

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to Mstiles

Devil and the deep blue sea !

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to Rosbud

Eat some protein at the same time you have something sweet, or really any carbs. This is supposed to help level out any sugar spike.

Rosbud profile image
Rosbud in reply to HeronNS

Thank you for this , I’ve lost 21lbs and do try to keep sweet treats down but will remember this tip x

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to Rosbud

Well, it's not like a prune is "empty" calories. :)

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to HeronNS

I understand that there is a link between excess sugar in the blood and ability to break down and absorb the protein molecule. Apparently the free sugar molecules wrap the free protein molecules preventing the protein getting to the muscle and simply passing through the gut. The net effect is that however much protein you consume you won't get the benefit if the sugar level is too high. Maybe someone with more knowledge can correct or confirm this please.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to cycli

I had elevated blood sugar in my early days on pred and my daughter, a dietitian, told me to eat protein when I ate carbs. I also cut out most "white" carbs, but not things like root vegetables, and sweet things have always been a treat not a habit for me anyway. My blood sugar came down but did not become really normal until pred dose was lower, forget exactly where, might have been when I got to about 5 mg,

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to HeronNS

interesting. I might start a thread on this as it interests me and is so relevant to our condition given the inducement to sweet things and diabetes through prednisolone absorption.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to cycli

I don't know off the top of my head - but I would suspect that it is probably only a potential problem for diabetics since insulin promotes protein anabolism.

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to PMRpro

that's the issue though, I don't know. It's a problem downline potentially and affects however we try to eat healthy wholesome food. Essentially we are flushing the goodness we should be enjoying straight down the pan. I don't like that thought.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to cycli

It is the sort of claim I would expect to see on rather less scientific sources - so I'd like some references.

HanaleiBa profile image
HanaleiBa

So many benefits! They are considered a top superfood in terms of antioxidants, polyphenols, and fiber (food for your gut bacteria.) Seriously, they are ranked in the top of scientific studies in those areas.

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to HanaleiBa

Try cherries then if you want a top super food. Fresh ripe cherries top every prunus fruit for me.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to cycli

You do know this thread is six months old?

I believe the dried fruits like prunes have much higher amount of boron and raisins, presumably because the drying concentrates all the nutrients. You'd need to eat a lot of cherries to get the same amount as in a few prunes or raisins.

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to HeronNS

yes, but you replied. If relevant then still now . i'm still learning so useful to read back sometimes. Never know enough Heron.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to cycli

Only because I got an alert that you had replied to me. ;) No one else in this thread will and as the prune stuff was really someone elses's topic.... Still, nice to chat with you! :) And I agree, some of the older threads are really interesting. One time I was able to go back to possibly my first post on a different forum, and discovered it was such an informative thread it covered nearly everything I would need to know for the rest of my PMR journey! Wish I'd printed it out.

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to HeronNS

we live and learn :-) how are you getting on with exercises?

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to cycli

Studies have shown that prunes help against loss of bone density. Not so for cherries unfortunately ;)

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to PMRpro

just bought some to refill our stores. Dog snaffled them off the table..now in naughty corner. have to buy some more. Waiting for the end result now 😰

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to PMRpro

I'll just have to eat the appropriate volume of cherries then, tough choice :-)

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to cycli

Umm, it'll be pounds of cherries every day to get the same amount of boron. It was actually hard to find a figure for cherries. Best I could do:

greenfacts.org/en/boron/too...

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to HeronNS

brilliant. Thank you Heron. Wow. that's quite a packet for prunes. In my yoghurt now

Pr0jection profile image
Pr0jection

I've eaten Lidl's prunes for the last 10 years. I was eating 4 a day but they're rather small, so I now have one massive one each morning. Having read your comments I will up this to 2 massive ones each morning and then book my place at the small room!!!

Croft9232 profile image
Croft9232

I gently stew a whole bag and keep them in the fridge in a container and have 3/4 with my Greek Yogurt to take my Pred. I needed something a couple of years ago to aid constipation from my meds. Pleased to say they help, plus so Yummy,,!My Rhemie was really pleased with my Dexa Scan said it was better than for my age (66 ).

Margaret.

Dambusters profile image
Dambusters

I don't manage to get on site every day but saw this query and am so glad I did.I read what others had to say in response

I shall try the prunes. I don't take Alendronic Acid - had side effects.

My father believed in a banana every morning and 4 dates with crackers for his supper and looked after himself into his 90s.

Although it was never diagnosed I think he probably had PMR. He was told he had rheumatism. I'm not sure his diet helped but it might have done.

YuliK profile image
YuliK in reply to Dambusters

Dambusters Hi there

Same with my Dad. He was only 60 when he was diagnosed with RA, but looking back today, I’m sure it was PMR.

He was in hospital for nearly a year, as he couldn’t walk or use his arms etc. All the symptoms of PMR.

He wasn’t given cortisone, but “indomethacin “ and aspirin.

That was in the mid to late 50s.

LogansNan profile image
LogansNan

That French woman who never gets fat has 2 prunes several times a week with her breakfast as part of her "personal wellness programme". When I have porridge, I emulate her.

Kath567 profile image
Kath567

My mom started eating prunes everyday awhile back for her osteoporosis. I wasn’t sure how I would handle them though. 6-8 sounds like a lot. I think anyone trying it should introduce them slowly in case they react to the sorbitol especially with any pre existing GI problems. I will give one a try to start and see if I tolerate them. Thanks for the information.

Jane424 profile image
Jane424

good for constipation

What a most excellent thread! I love prunes and dried apricots but limit both because of their comparatively high sugar content. However, I’ve just stewed some prunes to have with my morning porridge. Yum!

cycli profile image
cycli in reply to

if you have the normal dried apricots they use sulphur in the process I was told. Try and get Hunza natural apricots dried . Smaller and brown. Much better.

YuliK profile image
YuliK

FYI...

Leaving prunes to soak overnight in a cup of hot water and drinking the water in the morning, is opening the bowels very quickly.

( without the olive oil Constance 😉)

Constance13 profile image
Constance13 in reply to YuliK

It's good for the bones too. I think???😂

YuliK profile image
YuliK in reply to Constance13

What is good Constance, the prunes or the olive oil. ?

👍🌹

Constance13 profile image
Constance13 in reply to YuliK

Both!

seamaid profile image
seamaid

I think I may have to start to eat some prunes, as I am intolerant to dairy ( other than a hard cheese - cheddar ) I am on the usual medication to try to protect my bones but would be nice to perhaps cut back on so much meds . :-(

You may also like...

Silly question of the day

Query Re First Few Days: Prednisolone :Edited

down to the years of misdiagnosis)? Thank you all again for your very kind advice. Edited to...

The Lighter Side: That (silly) Book Website - Thank You! And.. about my new 'Badge' here.. ;-)

Dear All Just a very quick note to thank those of You Lot who have kindly ordered my book - 'Write...

It’s me in my silly hat I promised

mew to add pictures Brace your self. Well I hope it makes you Laugh. Please feel free.

'You are being silly!'