Find out how fiction and medicine combine to make... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

21,317 members40,424 posts

Find out how fiction and medicine combine to make TV drama Doc Martin

32 Replies

PMRGCAuk is delighted to announce that Dr Martin Scurr will be joining us for afternoon tea at the University Women's Club in Mayfair on:

Saturday 23 November at 2.30pm to 5pm.

Dr Martin Scurr is medical adviser to TVs Doc Martin & will be talking about his experiences with advising on the filming, scripts and other things around the series as well as answering any questions you may have.

Tickets are £40 and all proceeds go towards PMRGCAuk.

For tickets email events@pmrgca.org.uk or go to: bit.ly/2OJlzHK

32 Replies
Dontwannabesick profile image
Dontwannabesick

I had a pleasant surprise when trying to explain my GCA to a retired actress friend of mine. It emerged that she still took on roleplaying work at a medical teaching institution and one of her roles was as a GCA sufferer.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

Can someone ask him how much he knew about PMR/GCA before it was featured? TAB done in the kitchen (and I don't care that Doc Martin was a former vascular surgeon!) and she was fine after a couple of doses of pred!!!

If only! ;) ;) ;)

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toPMRpro

I think we discussed this at the time it was aired - and decided it had to done & dusted in one episode. Unrealistic, but at least it highlighted the condition.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toDorsetLady

Yes - but just a touch of realism would have been nice!

jinasc profile image
jinasc in reply toDorsetLady

Sorry DL but this time, I cannot agree with your post............fairly rare as well.

In my book, either do it right or not at all.....................

Some of us had to pick up the pieces.

I would have liked him to come to the meeting following on after that programme was aired.

I had not seen it. I came home after that meeting tired and worried.

I then looked at his profile and oh I wished I had seen the programme myself and then looked him up before the meeting.

Guess what............

Dr Martin Scurr

MRCS MB BS FRCGP FRCP

Speciality: General Practice

Main Interests: Medical Ethics, Diagnostic medicine

Member is Retired

People forget it is 'play acting' and that chunks are just skipped over, the bit I could never forgive, was two doses and cured. There was and still no damn cause or cure.

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply tojinasc

Hi jinasc,

Not saying it was done correctly either (and as you know I have a vested interest as well as you) - but as I said in original post linked below it did highlight the disease - and it was/is a drama not a documentary.

Like any medical drama on TV the storyline invariably only lasts one episode and I think maybe most viewers realise that and it doesn’t necessarily reflect real life-

healthunlocked.com/pmrgcauk...

But as the adage goes “there is no such thing as bad publicity”

jinasc profile image
jinasc in reply toDorsetLady

😷

Still 💓 U, Freya from Hel.

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply tojinasc

Know you do!❤️ And I agree, but ‘tis the way of the world - everything done in soundbites!

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toDorsetLady

I don't know - how many people saw it and thought they had failed because they were weren't fine after a month or so?

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toPMRpro

Maybe - but our own doctors can do that! 😳

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply toPMRpro

I think there was a subsequent episode where Ruth is behaving irrationally and Doc Martin rescues her. Can't remember details, but wasn't she leaving town? I believe in the show this was in some way connected to her diagnosis. Or was it all part of the same episode?

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas in reply toHeronNS

This might appear twice... maybe I hit cancel the first time instead of reply...

In a much earlier season a Ruth was diagnosed by Martin with Sjögren’s syndrome.

In a very recent season her gas cooker/ oven (?) was leaking and she was suffering from carbon monoxide poisoning. ( it was Sussex out after several visors to her home developed headaches/ similar symptoms.)

It was a great relief to everyone, as it was originally thought it was Alzheimer’s .

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply toKellyInTexas

I just watched that episode (gas cooker leak) this week! I didn't know she'd had Sjogrens as well. Poor woman....

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas in reply toHeronNS

Yes, I just watched it this week as well.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply toKellyInTexas

I only discovered last week they'd been showing new episodes. Reruns had gone on so long I assumed the series was over. I quite liked the two new episodes I've seen. Doc Martin is showing glimmerings of humanity and Louisa seems a lot more feisty.

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas in reply toHeronNS

...something very liberating about nearing the 40th birthday for women! It was my favorite birthday.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply toKellyInTexas

Interesting. I did not do well in my 40s, very depressed. Had been a stay at home mother for too long. But I was okay when I got my job at the library. Retirement and PMR ended twenty reasonably happy years. I just coast along nowadays.

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas in reply toHeronNS

You are helping so much on here. I’m glad your mind is as sharp as a tack, even if your body isn’t always getting the memo.

I’m in rather desperate need of you ladies.

( I’m failing portions of my neuro cog exams...the short term memory areas. Cerebral Antiphospholipid syndrome)

I’m still working, but thankfully can somewhat manage to set my own hours but not always.

I’m 50. Still have a teen at home - last year of school before uni begins.

My doctors don’t know about when to take the oral tablets- the early morning dosing definitely stops my migraines. It’s also helping with the hallucinations and seizures.

I’m doing better.

Enjoy your new great grandchild! Enjoy coasting and helping others. It’s a true gift.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply toKellyInTexas

I had never heard of this disorder before. You do have a lot on your plate. It must be quite a balancing act taking care of different serious things and trying to make sure medications for each don't interact. Are you best friends with your pharmacist by now? :)

Longtimer profile image
Longtimer in reply toHeronNS

Good description...I coast along, then freewheel a bit, then grind to a halt, at the moment I`m parked up in the garage....waiting for the battery to recharge!....

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas in reply toPMRpro

Alright... curiosity has gotten the best of me. What is TAB?

( we are huge Doc Martin fans...my husband wants to visit port Issac.)

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply toKellyInTexas

temporal artery biopsy

Radancer profile image
Radancer in reply toKellyInTexas

Kelly I was just being a bit flippant but truth is that none of these guys has the answer and I truly hope that any pain you have now goes quickly believe me as I know how it feels.

Constance13 profile image
Constance13 in reply toRadancer

I doubt it!

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas

Yes... but does it work?

Radancer profile image
Radancer in reply toKellyInTexas

I am happy for you

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas in reply toRadancer

( I was totally joking about the snake oil... obviously i know snake oil to be a joke. Sorry...)

Radancer profile image
Radancer in reply toKellyInTexas

Kelly I was just being a bit flippant but truth is that none of these guys has the answer and I truly hope that any pain you have now goes quickly believe me as I know how it feels.

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas in reply toRadancer

A Thank you. It’s a tough racket for all of us. I’m just very happy have the opportunity to learn about steroids from such a well educated group of ladies/ members.

It’s late there for you... you night owl, you!

Radancer profile image
Radancer in reply toKellyInTexas

Pain does not respect the sleeping hours.

Radancer profile image
Radancer in reply toRadancer

I am fine at moment and watching CNN and the Trump saga which is more painfull than PMR.

KellyInTexas profile image
KellyInTexas in reply toRadancer

Nope. Time to binge watch a series! Thank goodness for modern technology!

Here’s wishing you better health.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Daily Mail Tuesday 19th

I've just read Martin Scurr in the Health Section of Tuesday's Daily Mail. It's the second article...
Estellemac profile image

New look for PMRGCAuk forum

Dear members of our PMRGCAuk forum. Over the next few days, the banner that you see at the top of...
Fran_Benson profile image
Partner

A Special Meeting in Truro

The Truro Support group normally meets monthly on the 2nd Monday at Truro Golf Club. However,...
Pollyanna16 profile image

PMR and GCA Research Hits the Road!

Ever wondered what research is going on in the world of PMR and GCA? Your UK national charity,...
Polywotsit profile image
PMRGCAuk team member

PMRGCAuk Charity Week 19th-25th June 2017

Hi everyone In support of the PMRGCAuk charity week, I am going to undertake a 10 mile walk in The...
LizMitchell profile image

Moderation team

SophieMB profile image
SophieMBPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.