Associations of fats and carbohydrate intake with... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

21,324 members40,434 posts

Associations of fats and carbohydrate intake with cardiovascular disease and mortality ....

Rimmy profile image
22 Replies

Given we hear lots of discussion on this forum regarding the multiple benefits of a low carb diet for people taking Pred - many may find this Lancet journal article (from the HU 'Healthy Eating' forum) of interest:

thelancet.com/journals/lanc...

Best wishes to all

Rimmy

Written by
Rimmy profile image
Rimmy
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
22 Replies
PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

Thank you! I'd heard of the study and its conclusions but hadn't seen the original stuff yet - which I find is always a good idea as the media have about as much idea of how to read conclusions as the neighbour's cat...

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toPMRpro

Now you're being unkind to cats.........

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toDorsetLady

Sorry ;-)

Retailmonkey profile image
Retailmonkey in reply toPMRpro

One of mine cannot read but is a better communicator than many people I know

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toRetailmonkey

I DID say my neighbour's cat! Not cat's in general...

Megams profile image
Megams in reply toDorsetLady

~Lovely pic of you Dorset Lady~

CT-5012 profile image
CT-5012

Thank you for the link Rimmy. Very interesting, agree with PMRpro re the media enough to make the cat laugh. 😹

piglette profile image
piglette

I noticed in the papers today they are saying cheeses, cream, butter .... is fine. Don't things change? It is eggs all over again. Having become a nutrition nerd it does seem that carbs are not so good while saturated fats are fine and are actually better than polyunsaturated fats.

Sandy1947 profile image
Sandy1947 in reply topiglette

Rheumy took me off statins when with PMR diagnosis. She said low fat, low carb diet. I was doing that but changed to more full fat. Haven't had cholesterol tested for 6 weeks. Am I hurting myself?

Your thoughts please.

Rimmy profile image
Rimmy in reply toSandy1947

I am no dietary expert but I have pretty generally stuck to a low carb diet since my diagnosis - especially as had to take high steroid doses and wanted to avoid weight gain. Lost 12kg in 6 months and stable - and have eaten full fat simultaneously - but not in HUGE quantities. I have always had slightly elevated cholesterol - but as has been discussed on this forum taking statins may not be a great idea anyway (PMR is cited as a possible 'side effect') and I have decided not to do that as there is also quite a lot of evidence to suggest diet does not actually impact cholesterol levels in the major way we have been led to believe. But I am no guru in this area so others may have more useful and in-depth info for you.

Best wishes

Sandy1947 profile image
Sandy1947 in reply toRimmy

Interesting comments. Thanks. I am thin, watch my diet but I am genetically predisposed to high cholesterol. Glad I'm off the statins!

piglette profile image
piglette in reply toSandy1947

Hi Sandy, I think we will see changes in attitude to low fat in the future. Apparently polyunsaturates are a no no, although monounsaturates are OK along with saturated fats. I am reading a fascinating book at the moment with lots of research links which really does seem to say that new research is relooking at reducing cholestoral etc. I think there is a lot of money in medicines and supplements which may skew things.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toSandy1947

One of the listed side effects of some statins is developing PMR. A low carb diet is often a good way of reducing cholesterol levels. And your body requires some fat - don't go mad with fat but using proper cheese instead of low fat cheese for example is unlikely to do a lot of harm.

Having cholesterol too low is just risky as too high - and most of the cholesterol in your blood is manufactured by your liver, not obtained from diet.

You say "genetically predisposed to high cholesterol" - how high?

Sandy1947 profile image
Sandy1947 in reply toPMRpro

Not sure now. I'll let you know after my blood work late September without statins. Thanks for your response.

Mary63 profile image
Mary63

There is a very interesting book on just this subject. 'Trick or Treat. How healthy eating is making you ill' by Barry Groves and someone else. Lots of research papers mentioned, so it's not just anecdotal guff. Says eat meat, fat butter cheese, and very few carbs. Since polyunsaturated fats have become the golden boys heart attacks and stroke incidence has rocketed.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toMary63

I suppose it depends how you define "healthy eating"

piglette profile image
piglette in reply toPMRpro

Healthy eating = chocolate and wine

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply topiglette

:-)

Plain chocolate...

piglette profile image
piglette in reply toPMRpro

I agree, no fruit and nut for me or those mountain pyramid bars.

66Mac profile image
66Mac in reply topiglette

Yes I'd prescribe to that . Ha ha

Sandradsn profile image
Sandradsn

I've lost nearly 2 stones cutting out bread ,biscuits and other nice treats.My GP is now concerned about this but I feel better for losing weight.I'm the 'correct' weight for my height but she's weighing me each time I see her.I'm on 2mg Pred now and she wants me off it.I've always gone by how I feel and have been reducing very slowly.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toSandradsn

"she wants me off it"

Very likely - but do PMR and your adrenal glands agree? They are first in the queue to express an opinion...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

PMR -Lancet Summary

The Lancet has a brief summary on PMR this week which may be of interest....
piglette profile image

Osteoporosis

This article was posted on the Bone Health forum:...
HeronNS profile image

Breaking News! A High Fibre Diet Is The Way To Go!!

It's official! The Lancet says a high fibre diet is the way to go!!! Phew!! We got to go with the...

Blood Sugar Monitors. Interesting Read

I know a number of us on the forum still report to Zoe and make use of some their other work and...
Bcol profile image

IL-6 AND PMR

I cannot find this article here and I found it very helpful in understanding our disease. Written...