An interesting read on PA: Hi guys! I... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

32,627 members23,989 posts

An interesting read on PA

brenanddave profile image
13 Replies

Hi guys! I came across this study and found it very interesting. Worth a read if you have a minute. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Written by
brenanddave profile image
brenanddave
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
13 Replies
Technoid profile image
Technoid

Thanks for the study. I spluttered my coffee all over the place at this line:

" Although current recommendations do not advise monitoring B12 levels in older adults, "

Right! Because why monitor something where the consequences of deficiency may include permanent neurological damage. That would be crazy! Much better to not bother checking until the situation is already not fully reversible! Great plan!👍

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan in reply toTechnoid

It's not on regular blood forms.I had many symptoms .

No b12 test

My first ever b12 test a little too late then not acted upon straight away.

2 week wait

I've written to the doctors and asked why not done with fbc.

Why not done at a younger age so an individual has their own baseline.of b12.

To be added to the district meeting agenda of groups of surgeries.

My daughter had a lumbar puncture and brain MRI before a serum b12 test

Not done in A and E ever .

Or ask gp to get it done.

Not done on health screens .

I'm My case would've been caught .

I persuaded the nurse for an iron check.

Cholesterol eas put on to test.

Vit D is tested more than b12 .

It's plain ridiculous it's not tested with other bloods done.

They tried to do the b12 level again on my 93yesr old mum as the district nurses want her off their books for 8 weekly b12 Injections .

jade_s profile image
jade_s in reply toNackapan

Baseline testing - 100% agree!!!! For all sorts of things too, not just B12 - thyroid, vit D, iron...

Then again, as you said - they need to act on it. I have labs from when I was 18 and before I had an unnecessary surgery, they did labs and iron was pitifully low. No action! Only found out years later when I requested hospital records. (B12 was not tested).

"My daughter had a lumbar puncture and brain MRI before a serum b12 test" - this just makes my head explode. Unbelievable.

Dr Carr in Sally Pacholok's documentary was like that too - he was paralyzed and incontinent and hadn't had a single B12 test, but plenty of other invasive tests.

First time I had B12 tested was at my sleep apnea study in the hospital, years after my first crash. Didn't get one again until I saw a holistic endo years later.

My (younger) GP now seems to do them regularly for all patients, thankfully, but still balked at me when B12 came back high and I still had symptoms.

brenanddave profile image
brenanddave in reply tojade_s

HiJade! I only realised when my doctors surgery gave me all my old paper records that Ihave been suffering with low b12 for years. They never told me. I always new something was wrong with my health physically and mentally. Brain fog and always tired etc. Now I appear to have loads of nerve damage. Its everywhere.

jade_s profile image
jade_s in reply tobrenanddave

That's even worse! I'm so sorry 😥

brenanddave profile image
brenanddave in reply tojade_s

No! It's the fact they are doing this with us all that's the worst thing right? x

brenanddave profile image
brenanddave in reply toNackapan

I have no idea why they have this attitude with b12! In NZ it is with all vitamins. Its like they think we have some sort of obsession with them. My lab tec after telling me it would cost me over $700 to get the vits I wanted to have checked that the reason for the cost is to stop us all just having them willy nilly. The only free one at present is b12.And that will be next I'd say. aaahhh I could not afford the tests so have no idea if I am short of other vits. This makes it so hard to get myself well. Like I have said!! It will be big pharmaceutical companies behind this.

brenanddave profile image
brenanddave in reply toTechnoid

Lol! I had the same reaction! It does make the system very transparent!!

Altcrew profile image
Altcrew in reply toTechnoid

I think now more surgeries are testing for b12 deficiencies more. They do at our surgery.

boisland profile image
boisland in reply toAltcrew

I think more B12 testing these days because MORE B12D people are educating themselves & the word is getting out there , hence pushing doctors to test & educate themselves.

brenanddave profile image
brenanddave

Yes!! I believe you are right!

Budsa profile image
Budsa

I got my first ever B12 test when I joined a new surgery. It was a standard part of their blood tests for new patients. My b12 came back as 140 ng/L (180-914). My doctor said this result was borderline and prescribed 30mcg, 3 times daily for 1 month, followed by an OTC multivitamin. As I had neurological symptoms and I eat a healthy balanced diet, I said that this conflicted with NICE advice. He said that if he treated me with the recommended IM injections he would have to do the same for 75% of his patients - a clear falsehood. He did do tests for h.pylori and coeliac disease, but then lost interest. I have been taking 1000mcg b12 orally for around 3 years. I have recently dropped down to 500mcg after my serum b12 suddenly increased to 860 ng/L. After 5 months my b12 is now down to 411. I am lucky that they seem to test it whatever else they are testing for.

brenanddave profile image
brenanddave in reply toBudsa

Well alI can say about the 75% comment is that they need to be treating more people for their b12 def Shocking treatment!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Interesting read

http://www.health-boundaries.com/fingernails-2/ please remove if not approved Admin [Admin edit to...
Justified profile image

An Interesting Survey

Dear All, I found this really helpful piece of work. Obviously, the Research Design was flawed,...
Narwhal10 profile image

An interesting day today

I decided to go online and look at my new gps website to try and pluck up the courage to make an...

Pa

Hi. I haven’t been on lately but I have a few questions. I’ve was diagnosed with Pernicious Anemia...
Mono21 profile image

PA

I'm trying to find out if I fall into the group of people, that are advised to be "shielded from...
Eric69 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Foggyme profile image
FoggymeAdministrator
Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator
taka profile image
takaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.