Vitamin B12 status in health and dise... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

32,623 members23,985 posts

Vitamin B12 status in health and disease: a critical review. Diagnosis of deficiency and insufficiency – clinical and laboratory pitfalls

WiscGuy profile image
14 Replies

This is an extraordinary thorough review of B12 deficiency and B12 insufficiency, with an actual description of the difference, including severity of symptoms.

One interesting factoid is quoted here:

"In 1900, Russell noted characteristics of B12 deficiency that are overlooked with surprising frequency today: “some of the most typical cases presented no anemia throughout the course, others only late in the disease, while in other cases anemia was an obtrusive symptom … and preceded the nervous symptoms by many months” [Citation7]."

So this particular piece of information goes back to 1900, but still hasn't filtered down to most clinicians.

This is an insanely thorough review (266 references). Yet, when it comes to treatment, eg, injections every other day until no further improvement, the source cited is NICE.

Also, it appears that the most effective diagnostic tool for clinicians is the one suggested in "The Many Faces of Cobalamin Vitamin B12 Deficiency": if no other reasonable explanation of neurological symptoms is apparent, then make a detailed listing of symptoms, including an estimate of severity, and inject B12 every other day, checking after two or three months for any symptom improvement. Improvement validates diagnosis.

In my view, restoration of loss of balance, loss of sensation, etc should be the treatment goal, and there is no reason to reduce frequency of injections from every other day until those and other functions are restored, because there is no evidence that those functions cannot be restored with adequate treatment, and there is no harm in continuing treatment.

tandfonline.com/doi/full/10...

Written by
WiscGuy profile image
WiscGuy
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
14 Replies
Technoid profile image
Technoid

Added to the collection, thanks 👍

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan

😊 Thanks

jade_s profile image
jade_s

Since 1900! Very interesting. Thanks for the link!

Orchard33 profile image
Orchard33

Another precious nugget of info. Thanks.

Wheat profile image
Wheat

thanks for link re. Information.

Cherylclaire profile image
CherylclaireForum Support

I agree.

The aim is surely to regain all that you can and then keep it. No medical professional should be satisfied with a frequency that demands cyclical deterioration from their patient. Especially not where the treatment itself is well-documented as being harmless.

Why is far more concern evident re a recovering patient having high B12, than a patient with low B12 having difficulty walking into the surgery ? It does not make sense at all.

Thanks for that, WiscGuy - I'll have a read.

WiscGuy profile image
WiscGuy in reply toCherylclaire

"Why is far more concern evident re a recovering patient having high B12, than a patient with low B12 having difficulty walking into the surgery ? "

My guess is that doctors are used to using toxic substances to treat patients, and are used to balancing benefits with harmful effects. An example is treating bipolar disorder with lithium: there is very little room for error in obtaining control of the disorder, because just a little bit higher concentration of lithium damages internal organs. It is known that high serum B12 levels in a patient who is not supplementing B12 can indicate specific cancers, etc. Of course, the problem with this analogy is that lithium is toxic, and B12 is not, and while high levels of B12 can indicate other disorders, high levels of B12 do not cause disorders. It's just one more example of the amazing level of ignorance regarding B12 in the medical profession.

bookish profile image
bookish in reply toWiscGuy

You can't help but wonder if those with high serum B12 levels and cancers etc ever have a test of homocysteine or MMA to try to see whether their other conditions are caused by/contributed to by functional B12/folate deficiency.

WiscGuy profile image
WiscGuy in reply tobookish

It's amazing to start searching the medical databases (via Google Scholar, a research database search engine) and discover the range of disorders in which B12 is implicated.

Cherylclaire profile image
CherylclaireForum Support in reply tobookish

Lets hope so.

Luckily for me, the first GP ensured bowel cancer was not the cause of my symptoms; I was put on a 2-wk pathway early on.

The second GP found B12 deficiency, then later when I was unresponsive to treatment and getting worse, functional B12 deficiency was found by an MMA test. That allowed far more frequent injections.

The trouble with an MMA test is that it is very difficult to access from primary care - even for an experienced and determined GP - which inevitably then means delay. A wait for a secondary care appointment can take months, unless it is on a 2-wk pathway. Further, MMA tests are not available from every local laboratory - which is a concern if NICE are advising its use as a confirmatory test where B12 deficiency suspected, but serum B12 not (yet) below range. The advice is sound - but accessibility could prove problematic.

Alongside ferritin, folate, vitamin D and thyroid, my liver function was checked regularly. At least until the start of Covid.

tomdickharry profile image
tomdickharry

I read that abstract, and - please correct me if I've got it wrong - it appears to discredit any and all forms of supplementation, including injections.

Budsa profile image
Budsa in reply totomdickharry

I have just re-read it and can't see how you could come to that conclusion. It is more about the inadequacy of available tests and their misinterpretation.

tomdickharry profile image
tomdickharry in reply toBudsa

I can't find it either. I think I got the wrong article somehow but can't even find that. Please excuse my old brain.

brenanddave profile image
brenanddave

I agree! I am now on daily inj which has helped to control the burning pain that was moving nearly constantly around to different areas of my skin. It was becoming unbearable. Also as I am currently on a cruise for two weeks and doing a lot more activity snorkeling longer walks etc I have upped them to two injections during this time. It is helping me energy wise to have a reasonable amount of normality. I will go back to daily when I get home. Thanks for the info!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Excess Folic Acid and Vitamin B12 Deficiency: Clinical Implications?

This is a very recent paper. Some of the areas covered are well-known. Such as not treating B12...
helvella profile image

A clinical picture of a B12 deficiency and PA explained.........

Hopefully the following will be of interest to newbies on the sight and give a little insight of...
Jillymo profile image

Vitamin B12 deficiency from the perspective of a practicing hematologist

I feel this article contains many bits of information that often pop up on this forum, and explains...
WiscGuy profile image

Mayo Clinic studies B12 def, are very interesting!!

Check these studies out! I printed a few copies for my medical practice Abstract Although...

Psychiatric symptoms of B12 deficiency

This is an abstract: the abstract is in English, while the article is written in French. The...
WiscGuy profile image