Examining the Diagnosis and Treatment... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

32,669 members24,064 posts

Examining the Diagnosis and Treatment Experiences of People Living With Autoimmune Gastritis and Pernicious Anemia

helvella profile image
12 Replies

Publication date - yesterday.

I haven't read it all but it looked to be relevant and potentially of interest. And is open access.

Note that it specifically discusses patient disempowerment and patient forums.

Examining the Diagnosis and Treatment Experiences of People Living With Autoimmune Gastritis and Pernicious Anemia

Martine Cotton, BA, BHSc orcid.org/0000-0003-2040-0936 and Andrew McCaddon, MD orcid.org/0000-0001-8588-9061

doi.org/10.1177/23743735231...

Abstract

There is limited research evaluating the diagnosis and treatment of patients with autoimmune gastritis (AIG) and pernicious anemia (PA). We used a 2-phase data collection process to examine the literature and individual patient accounts. Phase one comprised a systematically conducted literature review focusing on diagnosis and treatment, relationships with healthcare practitioners and health-related quality of life (HRQOL). Phase two involved analysis of individual accounts via posts in online patient forums. We identified 6 main themes: the diagnosis journey, seeking treatment, patient-provider relationships, HRQOL, patient disempowerment, and the “expert patient.” Our findings confirm significant knowledge gaps concerning AIG/PA across the healthcare community. These have a cascading effect starting with delays in diagnosis and poor treatment protocols and often lead to complete withdrawal from care seeking. The establishment of standard consensus guidelines and improved clinical awareness should be urgently addressed. Interventions that better help patients understand their illness are also needed to improve psychological health. Without these changes disengagement from health systems, and poor health outcomes, will continue for this population group.

journals.sagepub.com/doi/10...

Written by
helvella profile image
helvella
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
12 Replies
deniseinmilden profile image
deniseinmilden

Thank you! Very interesting.All the best!

Technoid profile image
Technoid

A good read, thanks Helvella. Quite a fair take overall and I hope it helps to improve clinical practice.

Orchard33 profile image
Orchard33

Brilliant. The more research and the more evidence the better.

migi2z profile image
migi2z

Very good assessment of my experience certainly. Thank you for sharing it. Let's hope it leads to improvements.

Polaris profile image
Polaris

I think this may be the same Martine Cotton, Australian, who wrote this excellent article in ‘ Medium’, which I posted on here about five years ago :

martinecotton.medium.com/18...

I had to find it on line as I can’t seem to access my past posts !?

Treesong2023 profile image
Treesong2023

Great flag up Helvella -

Regarding.... Expert Patients and Online Forums ( Fora?)

I will delve into this doc between shifts as my trawl and processing of all sorts of stuff continues, so thank you.

But I do like a comment made in the Intro of the doc about how they looked at AIG and related diseases PA, B12 etc ...In 2 Phases, and in Phase2 they drew in information, reference data ..

extract here...

"...Phase two involved analysis of individual accounts via posts in online patient forums. We identified 6 main themes: the diagnosis journey, seeking treatment, patient-provider relationships, HRQOL, patient disempowerment, and the “expert patient.” Our findings confirm significant knowledge gaps concerning AIG/PA across the healthcare community..."

Great find for us Helvella. I am clapping you. 👏👏👏

EllaNore profile image
EllaNore

Excellent article helvella! Thank you so much for posting this. I think I'm going to send this to my doctors. Great job finding this!

As I look for information about B12 d and PA, all the information is in the UK. I can't find any United States information on it. They are so far behind and so lacking on this. I'm so grateful for the information the UK has and all the help I've gotten from all of you.

Dancers1 profile image
Dancers1

thank you

dot-dash profile image
dot-dash

Thanks for flagging this - I note it's co-funded by PAS as well, a significant effort to get all this in a published peer-reviewed article that will carry credibility with practitioners.

There is one slightly ambiguous item in the conclusion:

"The reliance of biomarkers rather than symptoms to manage treatment is a significant unmet need, possibly resolvable by a “patient-centered” approach to AIG/PA"

- which could suggest that reliable biomarkers are the unmet need, rather than treat the symptoms. It should be clear enough from the Discussion though.

helvella profile image
helvella in reply todot-dash

I missed the PAS funding! Thanks for pointing that out.

Pickle500 profile image
Pickle500

Excellent - this is so encouraging to see. It's the first of it's kind too.

I do get a more 'universal' sense that the pressure is heating up for the medical community to sort themselves out. We had the report in October that exposed the number of PA/B12D sufferers self medicating, now this that shows hard data on time to diagnosis, delays to diagnosis, and poor administration of B12D supplementation.

Since Netherlands offers 2 years of ongoing twice weekly injections, the UK and US are surely put to shame by this? Of course, there is still a risk that patients don't get diagnosed, due to medical ignorance/negligence, but if they do then they will get optimal ongoing treatment.

So why is the UK failing? And as the report states, it is not clear why medics are refusing treatment.

We have a battle on our hands, since Doctors are not trained in this stuff. So in effect, our illness undermines their profession. For medics, this is an enormous ego knock. How can they sleep well at night knowing that they don't know about this common and severe illness?

The problem lies in education. We are not getting Doctors to study nutritional science. And we are not believing patients who have symptoms because 'it's not possible'. Well, it is possible. You just don't know about it. Neither do most average people in the street.

Medical science has not progressed much in 50 years. So we should be lobbying against this somehow - putting pressure on them to fess up and admit their ignorance and change.

Surely the NHS runs to KPIs and metrics they need to hit? Why is diagnosis of B12 or PA not a key metric?

Again, culpability lies somewhere and, ultimately, with the government. So please would the health minister stand up?

Or should we get Matt Hancock back in to tell us to eat Broccoli? 😆

Technoid profile image
Technoid in reply toPickle500

found the Matt Hancock quote LOL

"“A vitamin B12 deficiency leads to a higher instance of dementia but can be prevented by eating broccoli”. "

neweconomics.org/2018/11/ta...

🤣🤣🤣

The article makes no remark on this atrocious statement which is just terrible.

and as for his:

"Making better choices by limiting alcohol, sugar, salt and fat”."

with regards to fat this is dietary advice stuck in the 1990s. History here : hsph.harvard.edu/magazine/m...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Paper: Receiving a Diagnosis of Pernicious Anemia: Exploring Experiences of Relationships With Health Professionals

I assume this has been posted before but I saw this for the first time today Seage, et al,...
jade_s profile image

New papers on PA

There are often new interesting papers on pernicious anemia. I will add them to this thread to keep...
jade_s profile image

Autoimmune gastritis Vs AMAG/PA

https://pernicious-anaemia-society.org/b12deficiencyandperniciousanaemia/ This first article...

Various B12D/PA resources

Admin Edit: This is not an official PAS post but it does contain many resources that may be of use...
jade_s profile image

Cordyceps and pernicious anemia

Hi all, I have been reading about the many health benefits of Cordyceps but i cannot find any...
ljmulledy profile image

Moderation team

See all
Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator
Foggyme profile image
FoggymeAdministrator
taka profile image
takaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.