Hydroxy v methylcobalmin.... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

31,973 members23,121 posts

Hydroxy v methylcobalmin....

WorkingProgress profile image
6 Replies

This is where I need a good degree of clarification. Is it possible for some people not to convert hydroxy into useable methyl and adeno because of some sort disfunctioning pathway? Therefore making methyl work better for them or is it a case of which gets into the cells more easily for that individual. Or is there zero difference if both have been administered IM or SUBQ(either method is good) imo.

Thanks all

Written by
WorkingProgress profile image
WorkingProgress
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
6 Replies
fbirder profile image
fbirder

No.

Hydroxocobalamin isn't converted to methylcobalamin.

Whenever B12 of any type enters the cell it is converted to cob(II)alamin, be it hydroxo, methyl, cyano, or adenosyl. This process is carried out by the same enzyme MMACHC.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

WorkingProgress profile image
WorkingProgress in reply to fbirder

Got it .... so it's just about personal preferences then, which one the individual tolerates the best. Correct?

WorkingProgress profile image
WorkingProgress in reply to fbirder

Also why do people on forums keep saying if you SI methyl you need to take adenosyl too? Surely this is false too from what you are saying? Thanks again.

fbirder profile image
fbirder in reply to WorkingProgress

Yes, it's total codswallop. Somebody wrote that on Wikipedia and it's spread all over the interwebs, even though it's been corrected.

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator in reply to WorkingProgress

There is at least one reported medical case of a patient who couldn't convert methyl to adenosyl - not really sure how it worked from a biochemical perspective - but it is extremely rare - insisting on both adenosyl and methyl is definitely erring on the cautious side.

BrecklandRanger profile image
BrecklandRanger

I take hydroxy, and it seems to help re typical B12 issues.

You may also like...

NHS v Medichecks blood results?

I recently ordered some Medichecks blood tests & paid to have the blood taken at my local NHS...

Side effects of b12 methylcobalmin 1000 mcg subligual

10 KG in 6 months.Today I have stopped taking both methyl and folic , Can someone please advise me...

Hydroxy change to methyl - thoughts?

continue with the hydroxy. The B12d charity suggested the hydroxy but if the methyl will work as...

MTHFR - Why do people take Hydroxy?

body? but it seems everyone still prefers I.M Hydroxy but im curious as to why :) EDIT : just found

Different Types of Methyl B12?

the Methyl B12.  I found another pharmacy in Michigan that creates methyl so I thought I was good....