To PA or not to PA: Dear All I would... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

32,669 members24,064 posts

To PA or not to PA

High_Valour profile image
11 Replies

Dear All

I would appreciate your advice. Unfortunately, I am using my phone and searching through previous Q&A is difficult so my apologies if this query has been raised previously.

My query is this - is it un/likely that a person will have PA if their total B12 is returning at 397 and indeed is usually in and around that range on previous tests.

I know that my B12 is low but I am trying to determine whether I can improve this by supplement (under tongue) or whether B12 injection is the only feasible way.

My symptoms are muscle and joint pain, depression, some nerve tingling in legs, low exercise threshhold, coldness, dry skin. My thyroid results are in range and i am classed as euthyroid. My D currently sits at 80nmol.

I have supplemented in the past and my active B12 was >300 which I understand is more likely to be a false high.

I must admit that the thought of self-injecting is a worrying one and I am conscious of causing myself damage. I have not as yet had an MMA or antibody test at Medichecks.

Many thanks

HV

Written by
High_Valour profile image
High_Valour
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
clivealive profile image
clivealiveForum Support

Hi High_Valour

Can you tell what your diet is like? Do you eat meet, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy produce as these are the "natural sources" of Vitamin B12

If you do include the above in your diet then it is likely that you may have an absorption problem with your digestive system.

If you do have an absorption problem then tablets etc will be unlikely to be of much benefit.

There are many causes of absorption problems including medications and other medical conditions. Are you affected by either of these.

Are you in the U.K?

I am not medically trained and I wish you well

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan

If you are able to absorb tablets and it reduces your symptoms that is great news.

You have to keep taking them.

If the tablets sprays ect are not reducing your symptoms then you probably are not absorbing them. As long as you know symptoms are caused by low b12.

You can have an absorbtion problem without PA for several reasons and need injections.

Or you could have PA a d aksi need injections for life.

Vegetarians often do well with daily b12 tablets as they can absorb them and its dietary.

Sone get a positive result from the INstrinsic antybody blood test si have PA .some will never know .

Go by your symptoms .

It is possible to have functional b12 deficiency with high b12 levels. Look that up.

At those levels some have no symptoms or benefit from tablets and function better with higher levels

I personally would try that first.

Any signs of bad symptoms start treating more aggressively with injections.

Theses are my views

Obviously ti be discussed with your doctor.

fbirder profile image
fbirder

No. An active B12 of more than 300 is not likely to be a 'false high' it is likely to be a true representation of your blood levels of B12 and shows that you have no problem absorbing the B12 from the supplements. In other words, you definitely do not have PA.

Start taking B12 supplements again. Low dose ones will almost certainly be fine, but high dose cyanocobalamin will be easier to find and less likely to cause unwanted side-effects than methylcobalamin.

Go and see your doctor about the tingling in your legs and ask to see a neurologist about it.

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator in reply tofbirder

fbirder - think you mean serum B12 rather than active B12 - 397 would be very high for an active B12 result.

fbirder profile image
fbirder in reply toGambit62

No. I meant Active B12, responding to...

I have supplemented in the past and my active B12 was >300 which I understand is more likely to be a false high.

High_Valour profile image
High_Valour

Many thanks for your replies.

My diet does include meat, fish, eggs and some dairy so in theory I should bet getting b12 from my diet. However, my digestion is not great with low HCL and possibly leaky gut.

I was curious to understand whether it was possible to have a b12 reading of 397 at all with PA. From what I have read, people appear to have total b12 readings in and around 100.

It may be the case that improved digestion is key here which in itself is a challenge as we age (48).

One final Q please, is it possible to absorb sublingual b12 under the tongue and this bypass the gut? - I assumed that this is why these lozenges were a preferred option. I have tried the better you b12 spray but it contains chromium which irritates my kidneys.

I must admit that the aspect of having b12 readings but having symptoms as the b12 is not in the cells (and working) confuses me.

Thanks

HV

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator in reply toHigh_Valour

the differences between sublingual and high dose oral absorption are minimal.

High dose oral and sublingual can be useful if you have an absorption problem. They by-pass the normal mechanism designed to absorb B12 and rely upon a much less efficient process called passive absorption which occurs along the whole gut - but averages 1% - however it can be higher than this and for some people it is much lower, meaning high dose oral isn't effective for them.

The normal range fr serum B12 is a difficult number to interpret. The range his huge when looking at the population in general. Levels tend to be more constant when looking at an individual over time but will vary by 20% because the test is only accurate to that margin. 300 is in the grey area but that doesn't mean it isn't the right level for you - serum B12 is more useful as a test if you see falling levels over time, which does indicate an absorption problem

Sleepybunny profile image
Sleepybunny

Hi,

I wrote a very detailed reply on another forum thread with links to symptoms lists, causes of b12 deficiency, info about tests for PA, B12 books, B12 websites, UK B12 documents, letters to GP about B12 deficiency and other B12 info which you might find helpful.

healthunlocked.com/pasoc/po...

From personal experience it is possible to have severe b12 deficiency with normal range serum B12.

I am not medically trained.

Showgem profile image
Showgem

From what I've read it is possible that you are absorbing b12 normally so that your levels are raised in the blood but for some reason your body isn't utilizing the b12 properly so you can still have deficiency symptoms. I believe treatment is the same, high dosage of b12 whether by injections or supplements.

Sweetcheeks832 profile image
Sweetcheeks832

You can have any level b12 and still have pa. The determination factor is the antibody.

So just increasing your b12 Isjust increasing your b12. If you have the antibody, you will still have pp a at 98 or 1298.

Now. I don't believe you are having absorption issues in the gut like you're thinking. Point being vitamin d is a fat soluable hormone. If you have troubles absorbing b12, you would also more than likely have low vitamin d. They go hand in hand.

An inadequate diet over a long period of time, can cause b12 deficiency regardless of antibody status.

Lastly, only way to find out is to have the antibody testing done. Then take it from there. But just because you're low b12 or near the threshold doesn't mean it's pa, and even minimal deficiency can cause neurological issues. Some people have naturally higher threshold for their body chemistry; in addition to how well they are maintaining their supporting vitamin cofactors.

Baby steps though. Testing first.

High_Valour profile image
High_Valour

Thanks all, much appreciated. I understand Medichecks have the PA antibody test so I will look into that to rule PA out.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

More B12 or not?

Hi all, I haven't posted for a while as I thought I was on the up! However, maintaining good health...
natcap1 profile image

Oral B12 - with food or not?

I usually inhabit the Thyroid UK community on HU - and have suggested to several people that they...
helvella profile image

Misdiagnosis? Fibromyalgia or PA?

I was diagnosed with fibromyalgia about 19 years ago, but I wonder whether it was a misdiagnosis. I...
Chickens44 profile image

To increase or not

my main current symptom of B12 deficiency is incontinence of urine. I inject myself and the problem...

B12 deficient or PA?

Hi All I was diagnosed as b12 deficient over 6 years ago and put on injections every 12 weeks. I...
Alfabeta profile image

Moderation team

See all
Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator
Foggyme profile image
FoggymeAdministrator
taka profile image
takaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.