B12 balance: I read Clive Alive’s... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

31,804 members22,934 posts

B12 balance

Alfabeta profile image
11 Replies

I read Clive Alive’s Response yesterday where he listed b12 symptims one of which was the inability to stand on one foot with ones eyes closed.

I tried doing this on both legs and yep! I could not do it at all.

1. Why is this so?

and

2. Why doesn’t the NHS use this method to diagnose b12 deficiency- it would save a lot of money!

(For the humorous 2 is said with levity - I say this as poor old Clive got into problems last week with a Jaffa cake reference.

Written by
Alfabeta profile image
Alfabeta
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
clivealive profile image
clivealiveForum Support

Hi Alfabeta in 1968 I had a "Schilling" test during which I had to drink some radioactive B12 (which made me glow in the dark) but was inconclusive for P.A.

Four years later I had another "Schilling" test and when I went to my doctor for the results she said that I only had two years to live.

I said "I can't stand this any more" and she replied "you have P.A. then"

Simples :)

And I've always thought it was the second Schilling test that confirmed it. Silly me!

Alfabeta profile image
Alfabeta in reply to clivealive

Very funny! But why can’t I stand on one leg with my eyes closed?

clivealive profile image
clivealiveForum Support in reply to Alfabeta

I don't have the foggiest eye dear Alfabeta I guess it's just one of those things.

Have a good day.

Alfabeta profile image
Alfabeta in reply to clivealive

U2

fbirder profile image
fbirder

It doesn’t use that test for a B12 deficiency because there are far too many other possible reasons for it.

Your balance system uses three inputs to work properly: your eyes tell the brain if it looks as if you’re moving, and how; your inner ear tells he brain if you’re moving, and how; your body (especially the legs) know what position they’re in to a fine degree.

The system seems to be able to work OK if one of those inputs gets switched off. So you can walk quite happily with your eyes shut.

But severe neuropathy switches off the signals from the position monitors in your lower legs. You can still walk reasonably with your eyes open. But when you shut them, suddenly the brain is relying totally on the input from the inner ear - and that’s just not good enough.

The most common symptom is a tendency to fall over when washing your hair in the shower, especially if you tilt your head back.

A neurologist will do several checks on your balance.

Stand, feet together, eyes closed, and he will gently shove your shoulders from behind. Normal people sway a fraction then recover. I have to take a step forward.

I can’t stand on one leg for toffee and when he asked me to walk toe-to-toe without looking down I can’t even do one step. The funniest was when he asked me to hop on one leg. I almost fell on the three students observing. Lots of terrified squealing as my large body fell towards them. Luckily I was expecting it.

So I fail all of those tests. But my neuropathy isn’t caused by B12. Indeed, a B12 deficiency isn’t he most common cause of those symptoms (diabetes or leprosy, depending on which bit of the world you’re in).

If you have other symptoms of neuropathy (pins and needles in toes is the most common) then ask to see a neurologist.

Alfabeta profile image
Alfabeta in reply to fbirder

Thank you very much. I learn new things about my condition all the time on this site - yet I haven’t learnt a thing from my GP surgery apart from either denial of my symptoms or statements which are way off the mark.

I don’t, as yet, have pins and needles. In fact, most of the symptoms described on the site do not fit my experience which is why I believe I have b12 deficiency without PA. It is the reason, I think, why my GP surgery does not understand my illness - they have just assumed that, because my b12 level was so low, that I had to have PA.

My diet was verging on vegan and my doctor put me on recurring prescriptions for omaprezole which I was taking on and off for about 15 years - it seems reasonable to assume that this caused my deficiency and, hopefully, after three years of symptoms, I am beginning to get better as my symptoms are reducing in strength and frequency.

At least I hope so.

Thank you for taking the time to explain.

fbirder profile image
fbirder in reply to Alfabeta

The symptoms of a B12 deficiency are the symptoms of Pernicious Anaemia. PA is just one of many possible causes of a deficiency. But yours is almost certainly caused by diet and omeprazole.

If you don’t have pins and needles or numbness then you probably don’t have neuropathy. Some people just don’t have a good sense of balance.

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator in reply to fbirder

my main memory of testing balance with my eyes closed in the early days was actually standing there aware that I just didn't know by instinct how to move my feet with my eyes closed and having to think the whole process through in a way that I really shouldn't have needed to think it through.

My balance problems seemed mainly to come from not getting enough feed-back from the souls of my feet - so I initially thought I was condemned to a life of wearing trainers that gave a larger area of feeling - but things are now much better as I can feel things with my feet. In fact in many respects I get the opposite with trainers - no longer have the awareness of exactly what is going on that I have with bare feet ... so the cats are well advised to give me a wide birth when I've got the trainers on.

wedgewood profile image
wedgewood

Definitely the Omeprazole helped to cause your B12 deficiency Your diet verging on vegan would have also been a cause . B12 injections would help you no end , if you are still taking Omeprazole ,with of course B9 in the shape of tablets ,or plenty of vegs with folate . Best wishes .

PJDJ_08 profile image
PJDJ_08

Well Alfabeta please add me to that wobble list! I read this post with a smile and a really? Then I attempted to try it out! 😂

Started with eyes opened balancing on one leg, closed eyes... Timber....

Repeated with other leg... Ditto!

I will be asking people all day now to try this out to see if its just a b12 thing!

Thanks for sharing and thanks to clivealive

Alfabeta profile image
Alfabeta

You’re welcome - I asked my partner to try it and she could do it easily.

Read FBirders response - it explains the reason in great detail.

You may also like...

Physical Therapy for Balance

taping my foot on a water bottle and 2 sit/stand ones. I can’t believe how much the b12 deficiency...

Horrible off balance feeling

arranged for me to have a blood test which showed my B12 was low so another blood test was arranged...

B12 deficiency and liver stores of B12

that sound like B12 deficiency but my blood results show that I have about 2 years of B12 in my...

B12

positive IFAB test and have since been on B12 injections my next one is due in feb .but today i...

Balance giddy

worse when my eyes are shut but I get it laying down and sitting not just on standing. This morning...