Interesting on the NHS questionnaire ... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

31,931 members23,068 posts

Interesting on the NHS questionnaire for depression

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator
6 Replies

bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b...

About 19.30 minutes into the episode he goes through the on-line questionnaire and pulls it apart - does it himself and comes out as moderately depressed - and points out that it focuses on the negative and doesn't look at any positives so is skewed ... and the punch line is that it was developed by a drug company who make anti-depressants.

Very interesting - as was the first program - in trying to expose what is going on with the pharmacy business.

Doubt it will get the questionnaire redrawn in the near future ... have hated it ever since I realised that a B12 deficient person was going to score high on it even if they weren't suffering from any of the mood related effects of B12 deficiency.

Written by
Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
6 Replies
helvella profile image
helvella

I have always been extremely sceptical of this approach because:

Anyone with a few brain cells could swing the results;

Repeated taking of these must induce some sort either doing the same every time, or changing for the sake of it, rather than "real" answers.

clivealive profile image
clivealiveForum Support

I got so depressed before my P.A. diagnosis 45 years ago that I was put on Valium, Librium and Tofranil all at the same time and yet apparently, a diet of raw liver three times a day would have sufficed :)

xyz011 profile image
xyz011 in reply to clivealive

Crazy notion!

ndodge profile image
ndodge in reply to clivealive

The thought of eating raw liver 3 times a day is so depressing!

clivealive profile image
clivealiveForum Support in reply to ndodge

Fortunately I was offered the alternative of injections of cyanocobalamin 1000mcg every four weeks for the rest of my life. I took it and I'm still "clivealive" at 75 :)

wedgewood profile image
wedgewood

Thanks for putting that up! Yes it's a most interesting programme . Showing us another way that doctors are manipulated by the pharmaceutical industry . That questionnaire is really shocking . Why do doctors accept and use it ?

You may also like...

Interesting summary of PA on nhs website

intrinsic factor and thus the ability to harvest b12 from food): \\"Pernicious anaemia is an...

Fatigue questionnaire

I'm reading through \\"The B12 Deficiency Survival Handbook.\\" Lots of information! Well done,...

getting tested for PA with NHS

been diagnosed with a severe iron deficiency and vitamin D deficiency and macrocytic anemia. I am...

B12 Deficiency - Depression?

anyone else with a Vitamin B12 Deficiency struggle with bouts of depression? Normally I'm a happy...

Depression and anxiety

know if anyone who has been deficent in b12 also suffered with anxiety and depression? I feel like...