Is the vaccination protocol the wrong way round? - NRAS

NRAS

37,837 members46,820 posts

Is the vaccination protocol the wrong way round?

Brushwork profile image
8 Replies

Just a thought really... possibly a crazy one.

Since the virus is spread mostly by the most active in society i.e. the young, those in the 18 - 40 group and secondary school kids maybe - should they get the vaccine quickly. If they had immunity wouldn't it automatically protect the rest of society and get the economy moving more quickly? This along with all key workers.

Would love to hear your thoughts on this?

Written by
Brushwork profile image
Brushwork
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
8 Replies
happytulip profile image
happytulip

Just because they are vaccinated won't necessarily mean that they will stop spreading it to others. I think it would give a false sense of security. Would they still socially distance and use hand sanitizer after they've been vaccinated.

The elderly and clinically vulnerable are most at risk so I think it sensible to protect them first.

Brushwork profile image
Brushwork in reply tohappytulip

They can't spread it if they don't have it and are immune, it passes through the airways mostly.It was just a thought and there are very clever people who develop protocols so they must be right - but sometimes the instinct is to protect rather than defend.

happytulip profile image
happytulip in reply toBrushwork

Yes, but they can still spread it if they touch a contaminated surface and then take it into someone elses environment. That's what I was meaning to put across.

They may be protected but can still put others at risk.

Ontwowheels profile image
Ontwowheels

I see your point, but the vaccine is only about 50% effective after the first dose and needs the second dose 3 weeks later to increase immunity and protect. So it can still be caught and spread in that 3 week period.

helixhelix profile image
helixhelix

I also feel that those with most social contact should be protected early in the process - so taxi drivers, supermarket cashiers, teachers etc should be next in line after the medical workers and then the over 80’s.

I am retired so able to restrict social contacts, and have managed so far so can wait another few months.

Lolabridge profile image
Lolabridge

Good point! But I think they are worried about the oldies and CEV like us clogging up the NHS beds and putting it under strain more than anything else. And let’s face it, if we get ill most of us will need a lot of high dependency care. ☹️

oldtimer profile image
oldtimer

We don't know yet whether people who have been vaccinated against Covid might pick up virus aerosols from someone infected and carry them for a short while to pass them onto someone else. Please, if you've had the vaccination continue wearing your mask to reduce this possibility until we know.

There is an argument for protecting workers and contributors to the economy (tending to be the younger people) before the elderly - but this would require a very high level of people to be vaccinated - over 90% - before others would benefit from the reduction in transmission. The elderly would have, therefore, to 'shield' for that length of time. It's the same argument as herd immunity and it just doesn't work in practice.

Sarahg62 profile image
Sarahg62

Funnily enough, we had that discussion the other day. Seems like a pretty sensible option to us. 🤷‍♀️

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Have I made the wrong decision?

I have a chronic bladder condition and suffer with urinary tract infections from time to time....
wishbone profile image

Saying the wrong words?

Hello everyone, I'm currently on Methotrexate and steroids for RA, thankfully thell pain has...
Stowe profile image

Today is the day :-)

Morning you lovely people I'm having my first rituximab infusion this morning .Im really banking...
Fifi2 profile image

There is nothing wrong with me

There is nothing wrong with me I'm as healthy as can be. I have arthritis in both knees, And when I...
Matalow profile image

Rocking all round the garden........

Morning all,i hope you all slept well. I was down here at about 1.30am. I fell asleep by about 10am...
sylvi profile image

Moderation team

See all
Nicola-NRAS profile image
Nicola-NRASAdministrator
Donagh-NRAS profile image
Donagh-NRASAdministrator
karenf-NRAS profile image
karenf-NRASAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.