dialysis : I have to decide between HD and PD... - Kidney Disease

Kidney Disease

13,208 members5,338 posts

dialysis

Struppp profile image
7 Replies

I have to decide between HD and PD as my kidney function is falling fast and I need help in choosing. I need to travel to Europe frequently for family commitments. I would be very grateful for any advice and experiences you can give me..Also delivery of dialysis fluid to Europe Many thanks

Written by
Struppp profile image
Struppp
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
7 Replies
Badger2024 profile image
Badger2024

kidney.org/kidney-topics/tr...

Have a read of this from The National Kidney Foundation. Lots of things to consider

Badger2024 profile image
Badger2024

the first link I sent from the National Kidney Foundation was about travelling when on dialysis. This one is about helping you choose between HD and PD but not necessarily for people who are regularly travelling

kidney.org/kidney-topics/ch...

Talmidcacham profile image
Talmidcacham

I have been on HD for almost a year. It is a life-changer.

I have raised the possibility of PD - My nephrologist has agreed that this is a path worth exploring.

At face value - this made a lot of sense - but the niggling thought in the back of my mind was why this was not presented to me as an equal possible option in dealing with my kidney shutdown. Went looking for the downside - asked the surgeon, my Nephrologist, my GP - consensus from all that nowadays both HD and PD get the job done.

PD seems to be draining on the body - gives you more freedom along with many other benefits. One year on after transitioning to PD, I might be singing a different tune when the unintended consequences ( of which I have not been able to identify) manifest themselves

In reseaching PD - I would highly recommend

youtube.com/@kidneykeeping/...

Talmidcacham profile image
Talmidcacham in reply toTalmidcacham

sorry PD seems to be less draining on the body

Pkd1958 profile image
Pkd1958

I have to say I felt so much better on PD. Just imagine removing 2-3 days waste in 3.5 hours on HD vs 1 days waste in 8 hours( overnight). Its just so much more gentle on you body regardless to being at home or traveling

Darlenia profile image
Darlenia

This is an excellent site for explaining the various types of dialysis: lifeoptions.org/living-with... and it incorporates a personal planning tool for yourself which, depending on your answers and interests, decides the best one for you. The PD cycler is smaller and easier to transport than the HD cycler. (Some on PD don't bother using a cycler at all.) The HD cycler can also be transported but it's larger. My husband, who was on in-center HD at the time, quickly decided on PD on the recommendation of his transplant center. Because he's a diabetic, the vessels are at greater risk of calcification and the centers didn't want him accessing his blood stream and risking the arteries for transplant. So there are lots of considerations. Thankfully, he did get his transplant. If you can, try to get on the transplant list if possible. The ideal thing is to skip dialysis all together.

MToQ profile image
MToQ

I highly recommend PD. Definitely gentler on your body. Easier to travel. You can do it manually if you want to break down your exchanges throughout the day or with your machine overnight. Usually you can bring dialysis supplies on a plane as luggage free of charge. But check the carrier/s you fly with most. Also, no fluid restrictions on PD. No need to count every possible liquid entering your body like HD.

It should be possible to order supplies for Europe. You will need to check with the supplier, I had Baxter, and make sure to prep well ahead of time. Often it takes time to set up. Many months.

The one thing with PD is that you need to make sure you follow all the instructions EVERY TIME. No skipping. Keep a print out and check off as you go. Even if you think you know all the steps by heart. Even after a year, two or more years. Make sure you mask up, wash up, glove up every single time and the environment is relatively clean. That will keep the infections away. If you don't think you can be that diligent, then you might want to consider HD.

Every infection will reduce the function you have left of your kidney.

And get on the transplant list!

Good luck!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Dialysis Options

In preparation for dialysis which I hope will not happen, I need to make a decision about center or...
Frankie24 profile image

dialysis , Help !!

hello , I'm 28 years old and was just put on dialysis , I'm scared Idont know to feel I'm...

dialysis

I am 76 years old and still not on a deceased kidney list. I have a team at Penn Med, and the team...
Lee75glom profile image

Surviving Dialysis

Don't mean to scare anyone. But I saw this statistics on a website and wonder what are some reasons...

Pre Dialysis and scared!!

Hi! I was diagnosed with Kidney Disease in 2008 and just recently progressed to End Stage Renal...
Nikki41775 profile image

Moderation team

See all
PattyM_NKF profile image
PattyM_NKFModerator
DorisL_NKF profile image
DorisL_NKFModerator

Top community tags

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.