Multiple covid vaccine doses and immune imprinting - MPN Voice

MPN Voice

10,445 members14,398 posts

Multiple covid vaccine doses and immune imprinting

Aldebaran25 profile image
4 Replies

I have been reading about immune imprinting (also known as original antigenic sin... what a term!) and antibody dependent enhancement in relation to covid vaccinations. Are any of you informed about this aspect of the immune response? These are quite complex mechanisms of the immune system whereby the immune response is sometimes so strongly primed against a particular "original" antigen epitope that it will keep responding with the production of antibodies to that specific epitope even when challenged with a different one. It is know to occur with the 'flu vaccine and for dengue fever vaccination. I read these two articles (below) and have been wondering about multiple covid doses. Any knowledge or opinions ?

So far there is no evidence of this process occurring with covid vaccines but I believe it is still a debated issue. Seems that RNA vaccines (Pfizer and Moderna) may be less likely to induce this.

nature.com/articles/d41586-...

sciencedirect.com/science/a...

Written by
Aldebaran25 profile image
Aldebaran25
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
4 Replies
Manouche profile image
Manouche

He’s certainly right ! « Hensley warns that just measuring antibody levels does not provide a full picture of a complex immune response »

EPguy profile image
EPguy

I hope to get any 4th vax with the Omicron signal in it, if this vax gets approved. It would seem reasonable that switching is better vs continuing even longer with the same vax , but as they say here, not much info.

There was an early SAfrica study indicating that Omicron infection protects against Delta, but not the reverse, so Omicron immunity via vax could be superior to earlier vaxes, if imprinting allows.

In the 1st reference:

<<the problem could also be circumvented in updated COVID-19 vaccines by removing the shared epitopes>>

I think his idea is if you have immunity to the earlier covids why not leave that out of your next vax and keep the next vax all new to the body.

But as Manouche says, immunity has many layers, and these are working well against the worst omicron outcomes.

Aldebaran25 profile image
Aldebaran25 in reply to EPguy

Yes, quite a conundrum at this stage. Of course all of this is because I am wondering whether to go for the fourth dose ( booked for next week) now or later on, like you suggest . Trouble is that I will be travelling soon and although omicron, now dominant, is certainly not as dangerous clinically as delta, I would still not like to get caught when away from home . Going for all out protection seems like a good idea but the doubt remains. The professionals in this do however offer a fourth dose and surely they are much more informed and aware of potential risks than we are, so I guess I should trust their judgement,

EPguy profile image
EPguy in reply to Aldebaran25

The experts have been clear that you should take the vax that is available to you rather wait for the one that isn't.

In the context in US, we don't have a general 4th dose yet. It's likely the trials of the omicron specific mRNA vaxes will be completed by March, and that may coincide with a US 4th dose recommendation. Even if the trials are good, they may not authorize, instead continue with the current ones. But the imprinting issue will be on their minds in this decision I expect.

You may also like...

Second COVID Vaccine Dose!

Received my second dose of the Moderna COVID vaccine on Saturday. Not much of a reaction. Felt...

3rd dose COVID vaccination for MPN patients

dose COVID vaccine. There is no current evidence that any particular type of vaccine (eg Pfizer or...

What is primary dose vs booster for COVID Vaccine?

about third primary covid vaccine dose vs a booster. I have had a Pfizer booster vaccine - does...

Covid immune response on hydroxyurea

latest bloodwork an antibody test that showed me as negative for immune response to Covid - and...

UPDATE TO OUR ADVICE RE: 3rd dose COVID vaccination for MPN patients

is because the Moderna vaccine is given as a booster dose, there is less of the vaccine in the vial...