Not allowed on 2 posts?: I had been... - Living with Asthma

Living with Asthma

3,593 members738 posts

Not allowed on 2 posts?

Pinky2017 profile image
1 Reply

I had been diagnosed with copd 5 yrs ago. Now the doctor says my lungs have been clear.i have asthma n emphazema for 20 yrs I still have COPD but not stage 4 as I had been told.i can go without O2 all day. A blessing .i would like to know if i have symptoms of just asthma n a not .copd.

Is it against your policy to be on 2 sites? Thankyou Ayne ruderman aka Pinky

Written by
Pinky2017 profile image
Pinky2017
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
1 Reply
Minushabens profile image
MinushabensAsthma Captain

Hi...I've seen your posts about being on different sites; I assume you mean specifically here on HealthUnlocked? You can be a member of as many as you like; I'm a member of 3 or 4. I'm not sure what the exact nature of the problem is, but I would contact HU technical support & ask them.

The general test to distinguish between COPD & asthma is reversibility (in simplistic terms anyway). Does your peak flow improve by more than about 10% when you take a bronchodilator (e.g. Ventolin)? If so, it's possible but obviously, a doctor is the best person to give you a clear answer to that question.

You may also like...

Could pet dander make asthma worse?

drip (lifelong) and acid reflux (10 yrs.). I was diagnosed with asthma in Aug. 2020 which I didn't...

New diagnosis. So tired.

I am newly diagnosed with asthma. Likely have had it most of my life. I am having pulmonary...

Has anyone been diagnosed with e-asthma?

think I have it. I have seen a lot of advertisements about e-asthma and am curious if anyone has...

Struggling with severe asthma and the opinions people have on my condition

who are going or have been through the same as me. So here goes, I have always had asthma ever...

If it's not one thing it's another

My asthma been acting up last 2 weeks I got admitted into the hospital tonight for it. They are...