Fat Eating, Fat Burning.: So, you've... - Low-Carb High-Fat...

Low-Carb High-Fat (LCHF)

2,844 members1,342 posts

Fat Eating, Fat Burning.

MikePollard profile image
14 Replies

So, you've cut out all white carbs and the diet is mainly fat and protein. But there's a snag - the weight loss has stalled!

The short answer is that you are eating too much fat.

There is the perception that so long as you have cut the carbs, then you can eat fat - as much as you like. This is wrong, as the fat you consume you will burn for energy, leaving stored body fat untouched.

The way to approach things from my perspective is to eat enough fat to achieve satiety and no more. Protein generally takes care of itself. Couple this with say 18 hour fasting and you've got it cracked.

Written by
MikePollard profile image
MikePollard
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
14 Replies
ShrubRose profile image
ShrubRose

Without meaning to be difficult, maybe our weight loss has stalled because we have lost enough. Maybe our brains have different ideas about a good destination from our bodies?

MikePollard profile image
MikePollard in reply toShrubRose

This is aimed specifically to those still significantly overweight and wondering why, despite adhering to LCHF.

The body certainly does have a set point regarding body composition, and when reached will let you know.

ShrubRose profile image
ShrubRose in reply toMikePollard

Fair enough. I wonder if even low carbers sometimes have unrealistic expectations though???

in reply toShrubRose

It is a good point, but weight is a poor measure as is BMI. I've been measuring my waist at my naval. A healthy level of fat (specifically visceral) will yield a waist no bigger than 50% of your height.

By this measure I have at least another inch to go despite a BMI of 23 and average build.

ShrubRose profile image
ShrubRose in reply to

Just measured. Then put my info into an online calculator. ‘YOU ARE A PEAR’ it told me. Yup. I know. Not sure I needed to be told that. Maybe just, ‘you are in a healthy range’ would have done.

Subtle_badger profile image
Subtle_badger in reply toMikePollard

"when reached will let you know"

Can you explain what you mean? I can't tell the difference between my weight loss stall at 78kg, where I still had a way to go and presumably was eating too much fat and now, where I am settled at the moment 10kg lighter. My body is not indicating either was a set point. Maybe I should be trying to shed another 10kg 🤔

Dave1000 profile image
Dave1000 in reply toSubtle_badger

I know absolutely nothing guys. But it occurs to me that your body will lose weight to some degree at the rate it needs to. If we all go back to the adage “It took me a while to get this Fat” is it unreasonable that it might take us a long time to lose it. Plateaus are normal and we are not on diets , we are changing the way we eat. If it worked for you so far Subtle_badger it will work again. Maybe you do need to moderate the amount of Fat but then again maybe all you need to do is be patient. Be Happy ❤️x

Subtle_badger profile image
Subtle_badger in reply toDave1000

I think you have the wrong end of the stick. I am at my goal weight. But there was no magical signal that let me know I was there. It is indistinguishable from a stall. If there is a magical signal, then I haven't had it yet, and this isn't my goal weight.

Midori profile image
Midori in reply toSubtle_badger

Hi Badger,

Don't know your age or height, but 78kg is not bad for a man of average height and build in his mid years. going another 10 kgs down may be too much.

I also don't know what exercise you take, but most of us are having problems getting enough of that, with the Covid restrictions.

Cheers, Midori

ShrubRose profile image
ShrubRose in reply toMidori

Badger’s a woman and has a fab body now. She cycles millions of miles.

Midori profile image
Midori in reply toShrubRose

Whoops! Sorry, Badger! I'm currently nearly 90 kgs, and 1.6 metres tall, so I need to lose more.

Loraine518 profile image
Loraine518

So how do you know what is too much fat, or whether LCHF just doesn't work for you? Also do you have to keep reducing fat as you lose weight to keep losing?

Shield-Maiden profile image
Shield-Maiden in reply toLoraine518

I have read that with LCHF Loraine, in order to keep losing fat...weight...'one' has to dial down the fat consumption.....

......it ought to be called Low Carb Healthy Fats, in my humble opinion.

And, in answer to the last question, I would say 'yes' (but other members may not agree).

Have a good week ☺

ShrubRose profile image
ShrubRose in reply toLoraine518

The idea with low carb is that your hormones can tell you when you are hungry or not, through the reduction of insulin. When your body has what it considers excess fat, it sends out not hungry signals through the hormone leptin. This rebalancing takes typically 3 months. Then you have to ask yourself every time you come to eat, am I actually hungry? Or do I just feel like eating something? And you have to be absolutely ruthless about only eating when you are actually hungry. In my view, how much fat you eat doesn’t matter as much as not eating when you aren’t hungry. Various low carb experts say that nuts and cheese and cream, while low carb, don’t tend to lead to weight loss in the way that meat does. This is because it’s easier to keep eating cheese when we aren’t that hungry, than to keep eating bolognaise on courgettes for example.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Eat fat to Burn fat?

I've just watched the latest from Low Carb Down Under (I recommend you subscribe) by Maria...
MikePollard profile image

Getting head around eating fat

Apologies firstly I have contacted help desk there appear to be some technical issues with my name...
Betsboop profile image

Weight loss slow- I don’t think I’m doing it right

Hi all, I started at 202lbs back on 18th March and cut out pasta, rice, cakes, biscuits, beer,...
Leefit419 profile image

J'Accuse: Nutritionists

An interesting if macabre statistic has emerged from countries hit hard by COVID-19: if you have...
TheAwfulToad profile image
Ambassador

How much protein and fat

How much protein and fat should I aim to eat
basten profile image

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.