BBC experiment on twins avoiding sugar and fat - Diabetes India

Diabetes India

61,870 members12,104 posts

BBC experiment on twins avoiding sugar and fat

krishnang profile image
9 Replies

This is only from the point of an interesting read since the study has many loopholes.

But it does highlight some issues that are discussed by people.

dailymail.co.uk/health/arti...

Written by
krishnang profile image
krishnang
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
9 Replies
patliputra profile image
patliputra

It confirms my belief that low carb.diets do not work for every body.As every individual is different from other body also responds in its own way which may not be the same (response).Human body is not physics, it is biology.

shrisamarth profile image
shrisamarthVolunteer in reply topatliputra

Though not for everybody but it works for most of the people. And studies have confirmed that the failure in most of the cases is because the diet is not maintained after initial benefits. (ref. from Jenny Ruhl's book "The truth about low carb diet")

patliputra profile image
patliputra in reply toshrisamarth

Jenny ruhl is not type 2 diabetic.she is a commercial writer.She may have her views and she is entitled to it,but it is not universal truth.

shrisamarth profile image
shrisamarthVolunteer in reply topatliputra

How you concluded that she is not type 2 diabetic? She doesn't write anything of her own. Everything is backed by research.

Quote ---"She may have her views and she is entitled to it,but it is not universal truth." ---This applies to you also.

Aiyaraj profile image
Aiyaraj in reply topatliputra

Carbohydrate cannot be different for different people. Fat also like wise. The metabolism rates can differ. The chemistry is not different. I have tested LCHF and it works well. I had advised many of my friends to follow. It didn't work since they did not follow. That's it.

kcpl profile image
kcpl in reply toAiyaraj

Aiyaraj are you following LCHF diet for managing diabetes?

What has been your experience as you said you recommended it to others who did not follow so I am presuming that it worked great for you. Any idea why others did not follow?

How has your sugar levels improved and is there any reduction in drugs?

Aiyaraj profile image
Aiyaraj in reply tokcpl

I am taking Long wheat ( Emmer Wheat) But still within the limit of 100 gms Carbs.

I take Ghee , eggs, Meat Fish Lots of vegetables. As I had posted earlier My HbA1C was 8 and now It is 5.6. ( I also consume alcohol which does not affect the sugar levels) I have seen when I do not follow the diet the sugar shoots up

and as soon as I shift back to diet It comes under control. More than that the overall improvement in health is unbelievable. I have reduced the medicines by 50% and soon will stop medication totally.When I suggested this to many of my friends there are many reasons why they did not follow. One main reason is that when they discuss with their physician, they are advised to follow a different diet mostly carrying Biscuits along with them. Then there are few who lack the motivation to try any change. This also answers Patliputra.

kcpl profile image
kcpl in reply toAiyaraj

Thank you for confirming.

So great to hear that LCHF works for you. It is one of the best ways to control not just diabetes but overall health. There are Indian doctors in the US who are prescribing LCHF even to patients with 3,4,5 stents. I will talk about this someday later :)

Indian doctors here are still clueless about LCHF, so it is finally the patient that suffers. One biscuit is 4 grams (maybe more) with 70% carbs. (maybe more). Eat 4 and 10+ grams carbs eaten in the name of High Carb Low Fat atrocity.

patliputra profile image
patliputra

Can you please explain what do mean by you have tested lchf?

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Which is greater evil, FAT or SUGAR ?

It will be interesting to know, what forum members think.
patliputra profile image

The sugar conspiracy ( SUGAR AND NOT FATS IS THE CULPRIT)

Robert Lustig is a paediatric endocrinologist at the University of California who specialises in...

Blood Sugar and high blood pressure

Hi All, My Fasting Sugar was 117 and 2 hours after it was 257 and HA1C was 5.9 in November 2016. My...
MayankSharma profile image

Fasting blood sugar and random blood sugar

There r so much persons suffering that FBs is beyond the normal figure If u eat heavy then also...

high sugar and triglyceride

If one is diabetic and also has high triglycerides, is it safe to do the LCHF diet? It may control...
supadhye profile image

Moderation team

See all
Activity2004 profile image
Activity2004Administrator
barani19 profile image
barani19Administrator
namaha profile image
namahaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.