What caused my Parkinson's: My family... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,583 members27,899 posts

What caused my Parkinson's

bmakla54 profile image
30 Replies

My family Doctor gave me a test and found out I was positive for the C677T mutation and normal for the A1298C mutation in the MTHFR gene. This genotype occurs in 1.5-15% of the population and is associated with increased plasma homocysteine levels, a risk factor for arteriosclerotic coronary artery disease and venous thrombosis. In Parkinson's, oxidative stress plays a prominent role in the degeneration of the nerves that secrete dopamine. High

homocysteine levels cause oxidative stress......to summarize, my gene mutation has caused me to have high homocysteine levels which has caused oxidative stress which has caused my dopamine producing cells to die......I also have to watch out for heart disease....the good news is because I know this I can do what is necessary to lower my homocysteine levels.....it seems the # one treatment is vitamin b6, b12, and b3 .......

Written by
bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
30 Replies

That's a baaaad MTHFR.

Sounds like someone has a good Doctor.

lotl profile image
lotl

Are you sure?

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54 in reply tolotl

Yes

Pete-1 profile image
Pete-1

We are regularly told that a normal diet should result in ample quantities of all necessary vitamins. I may be wrong about this but I think a shortage of B12, if not caused by deficient diet is caused by a deficency of some chemical that facilitates the absorption of the B12 from the intestine. If this is the case then a B12 shortage must be corrected by injection rather than oral means. The injection has to be repeated once every 3 months.. If this is not applicable to B12 then it is for one of the others.

Pete-1 profile image
Pete-1 in reply toPete-1

I meant to add that sometimes or under some circumstances some vitamins must not be taken as supplements to that derived from a normal diet because too much of some vitamins may be toxic. If you are pregnant you need to take special care in this regard.Unless it has been found that you have a particular shortage then its probably best not to take supplements. More can be less.

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54 in reply toPete-1

I agree it is a balancing problem...but , I am careful not to take more than recommended and I take vit.B12 intravenously.....I take 1 mg once a week.

I take B6 at night because it can interfere with my sinement....I don't take sinement at night.

PatV profile image
PatV

That's very interesting. I joined the free PD 23andme but can't decipher the results. My neuro had me in a clinical trial that included genetic testing, but when I dropped out, the results were lost. I took B vitamins (a "stress" formula) together with E, glucosamine and chondroitin, calcium and magnesium for years. Only stopped in past year or so because I'm having problems with constipation.

PatV profile image
PatV

That's very interesting. I joined the free PD 23andme but can't decipher the results. My neuro had me in a clinical trial that included genetic testing, but when I dropped out, the results were lost. I took B vitamins (a "stress" formula) together with E, glucosamine and chondroitin, calcium and magnesium for years. Only stopped in past year or so because I'm having problems with constipation.

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54 in reply toPatV

when you stopped your vitamins, did you notice any difference?

PatV profile image
PatV in reply tobmakla54

No I think they stopped working for me for a while due to absorption problems in my poor gut. When I started taking them, I was so stressed that I noticed a boost in energy soon after starting. Had frequent sinus infections, etc. Absolute necessity during menopause especially the E and calcium. Now if I even look at calcium I cannot have a BM. :( And Calcium carbonate lands me in bed for a day in pain !!!! I have to read labels carefully because it's added to EVERYTHING!

tlongmire profile image
tlongmire

Interesting. I had read something about B vitamins and Parkinson's and since that timehave been taking B100's. I might check with my GP to see if I can have a B12 shot once a month.

Hugs, Terri

froggatt55 profile image
froggatt55

I take it bmakla65 tht you are in the US?

Iam unaware of GP' in the UK bring able to offer such tests but wuuld like to know if this is innaccurate = my oen GP when I asked for assistance with results of my 23andme report said doubted they would be able to interpret added to which any results coming to the surgery become"official" and could be used by Insurance companies

I must research some of very interesting comments on B vitamins - I hsve been told in the past that a normal diet (which is?)will provide all the vitains needed. i must say that codtipation is the bane of ny ife and almost reached the stage gf controlling it, would hate to go backwards!!

PatV profile image
PatV in reply tofroggatt55

Anything you have learned about constipation ! please pass along. Right now I am trying triphala. Movicol (from UK) gives me bad knee pain--I think too much sodium--and Miralax causes severe ab pain. Physical therapy helped but too expensive.

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54 in reply toPatV

Pat v I have read that prunes and figs are the best natural laxative. Also for quick relief drink a glass of water every 10 minutes for one half an hour. A 20 minute walk should relieve constipation and also Psyllium seed is helpful....this information per the book 'Prescription for Nutritional Healing' by Phyllis A. Balch

PatV profile image
PatV in reply tobmakla54

But did it help you? Thanks!

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54 in reply toPatV

I eat an organic apple every night and blackberries and blueberries all thru the day......I also eat alot of vegetables...I don't like prunes but if my apple stops working, I will go there

Pete-1 profile image
Pete-1 in reply toPatV

Try beer and probably more beer than you would like. Always works for me

shasha profile image
shasha in reply toPatV

acidopholus ? acidophilus ? is what i take plus lots of veggies and fruit

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54 in reply tofroggatt55

Yes Froggatt55, I am from the US....I think the issue with B vitamins is the absorption problem....some people don't absorb enough, thus the extra dosage. I am not familiar with the 23andme report.....

Lindylanka profile image
Lindylanka

Hi, all who are interested in the B12 thing. A deficiency in B12 can came as just that, a dietary deficiency, caused by not getting the right nutrition, or as Pernicious Anaemia, which is where you lose specialist cells in the gut that produce something called intrinsic factor which is essential for helping absorb vitamin B 12. The first condition can be treated with supplements and improving the diet. The second should be treated with B12 injections. You can find out more about it from the Pernicious Anaemia Society. Your Doctor can test for this, but make sure that you have not taken any iron or folic acid supplements before testing otherwise the deficiency will not show up. If you come low in the reference range for B12 then your doctor should test you again to see whether or not you are producing intrinsic factor. This will determine how you are treated. Usually the treatment for PA will be a set of 'loading doses' that come fairly close to each other, followed by either a monthly or a 3 monthly injection depending on which B12 preparation the doctor prescribes. You will also need to take folic acid which helps absorbtion of B12. There is a sub set of people with PA who need their injections more often because the PA has caused neurological damage. In this case the doctor may need some encouragement as awareness of PA isn't that great even in the medical community. As with Parkinsons you will need to educate yourself. The PAS site is very good for this. There are some very supportive and helpful people. They are also campaigning for better awareness, along with an expert in the subject Dr Chandy.

There are studies which show that people who have been on long term levodopa therapy may develop PA, and PD nutritionist Katherine Holden advises on PD and PA and what to do.

There are a wide range of symptoms some of which have a cross over with PD. If you are very tired all the time, get breathless a lot, and sigh all the time it is worth getting tested.

Sorry this is rather long, and hope this will be helpful to some.

Caregiver1 profile image
Caregiver1

to markla54 - are you located un the eastern US? are your doctors at a teaching hospital or are you simply working with a neuro who treats PD patients? I ask, because my husband had PD, works with a doctor at a very "prestigious" teaching hospital, and all this doctor does is ask how he feels and fidgets with his meds. My husband had DBS surgery in 2007, which helps with his tremors, but did nothing for his ability to take less meds/day. This is a great disappointment to me, having had my husband go through this surgery, and still having to take the amts of meds he takes every day. I never heard of 23andme - what is it? would you be willing to correspond with me off this sight? You seem to have lots of info about things about which we never received information. I look forward to your response. Thanks.

Caregiver1.

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54 in reply toCaregiver1

Caregiver1, I have left 2 comments below.....

BMakla54

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54

Caregiver1....I will be happy to help you anyway I can. I live in Florida and my neurologist is about the same as yours. I found an internist who specializes in vitamin therapy and wellness naturally......she agreed to prescribe my Low Dose naltrexone, my neurologist said he didn't want to rock the boat.......and she has been testing my body chemistry. The next thing we are going to do is test for heavy metals. She told me my neurologist was giving me a form of vit

b12 that was poison and she gave me a different one. So I think mainstream neurologists are not very experimental and in my opinion rather on the negative side as far as hope or recovery.

I decided to research treatments myself.....finding road to Recovery Talk Radio for Parkinson's and that lead me to LDN, which is why I have been able to reduce my meds. Let me know how I can help you.

BMakla54

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54

Caregiver1, Just to be clear, I still see my neurologist , but I also see my internist and combine their treatment.

BMakla54

themom profile image
themom

I was taking Effexor for 4 years. I started taking it when my husband was diagnosed with ALS (Lou Gehrigs Disease) for anxiety. I asked my doctor to help me stop taking it and he weaned me off of it. When I completely stopped taking it I noticed my left leg has tremors and then my left arm.

bmakla54 profile image
bmakla54 in reply tothemom

the mom, how is your sense of smell.......very first sign of my Parkinson's and it happened years before I was dx.......

Joealt profile image
Joealt

I think that my Parkinsons came as the result of blunt trauma.

tlane77 profile image
tlane77

Yes , it seems someone else is on the right track... :) Very good post!

keepsie profile image
keepsie

I am negative for C677T mutation and double-positive for A1298C. I am also positive on COMT. As a result I have poor absorption of B6, B9 (Folate), and B12. This makes my methylation a mess with all the consequences including PD. As PwP we must be very careful with vitamins, especially with vitamin B. B12 as cyanocobalamin, B9 as Folic Acid, and B6 as pyridoxine must be avoided. Instead the active coenzyme forms should be taken.

I am taking 1 of these lozenges first thing in the A.M. It helps me a lot. One very important

warning: if you are taking carbidopa then you should wait for 2 hours because B6 and carbidopa are incompatible. Mucuna is no problem. But I am not sure if you can take B6 if you are on Rytary, since it's a slow release medication and carbidopa's presence in your system is unpredictable.

amazon.com/gp/product/B003P...

I also took 23andme and I think it's available in most countries - just go to their website: 23andme.com. The offer 2 types of tests - basic and basic + health. The latter is twice as much as the former and I found it useless. I recommend getting the basic one and then run one of many free or inexpensive online analyses, which would give you much more useful information.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

The more homocysteine, the worse the Parkinson's?

"You don't discover new continents if you don't have the courage to lose sight of the old......

Niacin in the Central Nervous System: An Update of Biological Aspects and Clinical Applications

If I was smarter, I might not be so excited about Niacin. I am pretty excited. Niacin in the...

PD drugs accelerate disease progression

quotes - "All along PD progression brain produces less and less dopamine. Since l-dopa inhibits...