Parkinson’s vs MSA-P: I posted before that... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,504 members27,915 posts

Parkinson’s vs MSA-P

Kevinbg profile image
11 Replies

I posted before that I tested positive for alpha-synuclein in all three sites of my cutting-edge skin biopsy. I tested positive for autonomic abnormalities, as well. My MDS diagnosed me with either Parkinson’s or MSA-P.

I can’t have an MRI because I have a pacemaker. My CT shows no atrophy of my brain.

Is there any other test which might give my MDS the ability to narrow down my diagnosis?

It would be nice to know if my autonomic symptoms are MSA-P. Or,if this is a diagnosis of Parkinson’s.

Written by
Kevinbg profile image
Kevinbg
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
gaggs8 profile image
gaggs8

The test for Parkinson's is non invasive mostly looking at how you walk etc, could you have that first? Good Luck

SilentEchoes profile image
SilentEchoes

Neurophthalmology testing can rule in or out MSA. I was dxed with Parkinsonism that I thought was MSA; testing ruled out MSA, my probable diagnosis was ALS, it was validated by a neuromuscular disease specialist. I went to the University of Iowa.

I know much more about this; a simple test is to check your reflexes - normal is PD, hyper is neuromuscular. Has Multiple Sclerosis been ruled out?

Kevinbg profile image
Kevinbg in reply toSilentEchoes

MS has not been discussed. I have two cousins with MS. I will check on neuropthomology and neuromuscular doctors.

SilentEchoes profile image
SilentEchoes in reply toKevinbg

*Neuro-ophthalmology

medicine.uiowa.edu/eye/path...

My mfERG was negative - this definitively ruled out MSA.

My OCT was abnormal, showed retinal thinning specific for ALS.

MS has specific visual disturbances and U Iowa or other neuro-ophthalmologist can help narrow the differential.

Can't get the comprehensive testing outside of the universities, U Iowa is top notch.

None of this was necessary, my reflexes are pathologic for neuromuscular disease; a reflex test is subjective when a doc doesn't want to validate an inconvenient patient's diagnosis. I've seen the ugly underbelly of the US medical system.

SE

Parkie- profile image
Parkie- in reply toSilentEchoes

Hi SilentEchoes,

Thanks for this info on Neurophthalmology. It helps with my previous post:

healthunlocked.com/parkinso...

I've been wondering if I have PD or MSA-P for a while...

SilentEchoes profile image
SilentEchoes in reply toParkie-

I looked at your link, were you previously diagnosed with PD? 25% of the time the PD diagnosis is changed. I would get a second opinion and/or request a referral to a specialist, like a neuor-ophthalmologist.

See my reply to Jeeves19 on this post - reflexes are the definitive indication of which direction your diagnosis is headed.

SE

Parkie- profile image
Parkie- in reply toSilentEchoes

''a simple test is to check your reflexes - normal is PD, hyper is neuromuscular'': I think mine might be hyper, but not sure. What do you mean ''neuromuscular''?

Diagnosed with PD by 3 different movement specialists.

No tremor at rest, awful rigidity, muscle weakeness (especially after exercising, or just upon walking more than 5 min), no loss sense of smell, fast progression, symptoms started abruptly, REM sleep disorder. Bad response to Sinemet:

30 min ''on's'' with 700 mg daily Sinemet but can't even take 300 mg daily without side effects worse than the disease (both on and off painful dystonia, relentessness, insomnia, total loss of appetite, total constipation).

SilentEchoes profile image
SilentEchoes in reply toParkie-

Parkie- when you say muscle "rigidity" do you mean spasticity?

You might feel spasticity either as stiffness that doesn't go away or as movements you can't control that come and go, especially at night. It can feel like a muscle tightening, or it can be very painful. Spasticity also can make you ache or feel tight in and around your joints and low back.

There is significant overlap in the symptoms of neurological disorders and they may share the same cytopathology.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Neuromuscular disorders can be inherited or caused by a spontaneous gene mutation; some also may be caused by immune system disorders. [Spontaneous (somatic) gene mutation and autoimmune reaction is triggered by an environmental exposure to a toxic substance.]

Neuromuscular disorders affect the nerves that control voluntary muscles and the nerves that communicate sensory information back to the brain. When the neurons become unhealthy or die, communication between the nervous system and muscles breaks down. As a result, muscles weaken and waste away (atrophy).

Types of neuromuscular disorders include:

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)

Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease

Multiple sclerosis

Muscular dystrophy

Myasthenia gravis

MyopathyMyositis, including polymyositis and dermatomyositis

Peripheral neuropathy

Spinal muscular atrophy

Some symptoms common to neuromuscular disorders include:

Muscle weakness that can lead to twitching, cramps, aches and pains

Muscle loss

Movement issues

Balance problems

Numbness, tingling or painful sensations

Droopy eyelids

Double vision

Trouble swallowing

Trouble breathing

PD and ALS (and dementia) can occur at the same time, it's not always a case of either/or.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/218...

Your diagnosis doesn't seem straight forward. Is it important for you to know more specifically what the degenerative process is? In all cases the conventional medical role is supportive. Are you content with this approach?

It's my opinion that our best hope for recovery is through nutritional intervention (Wahls protocol) and vitamin supplementation.

It is also my opinion that the cause of non-genetic neurodegenerative diseases is environmental toxin exposure. Acute exposure leads to acute neurodegeneration (ALS/MSA) and chronic exposure leads to a slower progression, PD and AD.

It is my opinion that the environmental toxin injury process is equivalent to cyanide poisoning. Google cyanide poisoning and Parkinson's disease. Cyanide is a chemical compound that can be formed by a multitude of chemical and thermal reactions and therefore is not restricted to a specific exposure, the most common is Glyphosate, an organophosphate chemical in Roundup. It is probable that ingesting contaminated food is a major contributor to the explosion in neurological disorders. Start with cleaning up your diet, you cannot supplement your way to good health.

SE

jeeves19 profile image
jeeves19

Kevin. When I was in the early stage of PD I was unsure of the diagnosis as Sinemet didn’t seem to work brilliantly. Docs weren’t awfully helpful so I researched hard. I found one nugget that showed a major difference between MSA males and PD: if you have MSA you always have erectile issues from the outset. I’ll leave that one with you buddy 🤔.

SilentEchoes profile image
SilentEchoes in reply tojeeves19

Yep, early autonomic dysfunction suggests something other than classic PD, but not necessarily the atypical forms and can be neuromuscular disease.

The free, easy, non-invasive way to distinguish between atypical Parkinson's and NMD is to check reflexes. Hyperreflexia is NMD. You know it when you see it, also as the condition advances the reflexes are lost - not so with PD. My mom had normal patellar tendon reflexes even after 20 years of PD and knee replacement surgery.

Kevinbg profile image
Kevinbg

I just had major dental work yesterday for one hour. My oral surgeon woke me up 4 times saying, “breathe Kevin. Breathe Kevin.” This re confirms that I’m stopping breathing.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Parkinson’s or MSA-P

Next week I see my neurologist to review my MRI results. I have a bad feeling that after we review...
Pilot108 profile image

MSA?

I am a 59 year old Chinese with balance disorders not attributable to middle ear disorder but...
Poss profile image

Anyone with Parkinson Plus Syndrome (MSA)? You can message me if you prefer.

I had a Datscan recently that said I was Positive for Parkinson's. Prior to the Datscan I had been...
tlongmire profile image

Repeating All Autonomic Studies as a Result of Out of Control Heart Rate and Labored Breathing - Any Thoughts?

I was in the ER today with a heart rate of 230 BPM. Breathing was labored. Everything checked out...
Kevinbg profile image

Parkinson’s Silver Linings

I am just so tired of all those forums with complaining and negative comments surrounding...
pinoka11 profile image

Moderation team

See all
CPT_Aleksandra profile image
CPT_AleksandraAdministrator
CPT_Anaya profile image
CPT_AnayaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.