Doctor/Patient relations: PwP, don't be... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,511 members27,921 posts

Doctor/Patient relations

19 Replies

PwP, don't be jealous of me because I have a doctor that is not letting holidays get in the way. I have a new neurologist that I am "training".. She is better at connecting with her patients than my previous doctor. I and her do not agree on the ideal dose for my Parkinson’s treatment. She is skeptical regarding thiamine hcl, B12 and also skeptical regarding the use of medical marijuana. Maybe we can compromise.

I have been on a low dose (CR c/l 50/200) 400mg daily for about two years with good results until recently. There has been a noticeable change in my symptoms. I want to get ahead of them. Not expecting big relief from tremor. Doc thinks my lab work should check for neuropathy as I have reported to her that my toes are numb. I described to her how Mayo Clinic paper on B12 and Parkinson’s identified numbness as possible relationship.

Today I communicated (yes! New Year holiday) with my neurologist. She will order B12 blood work for tomorrow. Regarding levodopa she wants me to take 1 tab c/l (100mg) IR five times a day and c/l 200mg ER at bedtime. Quote the doctor: “I don’t think there is a benefit of taking two tablets of IR 25/100 four times a day as it can increase the chances of motor fluctuations. This means extreme highs and lows of function.”

Read more about...
19 Replies
Ajssister profile image
Ajssister

Thank you for posting Roy. Is your Dr. in central Fla? We are n I thought you might be also. Happy New Year

in reply toAjssister

New Mexico

jenniferdunstan profile image
jenniferdunstan in reply to

Hello pardner. I live in New Mexico too. I live in ABQ. Is

your dr Dr. Jill perchance?

in reply tojenniferdunstan

My doctor is Karen LeCompte, neurologist, Gerald Champion Regional Medical Center, Alamogordo, N.M.

Grumpy77 profile image
Grumpy77

Hi Roy, are you a neurologist! I extract that from your post as you say you are training a neurologist (doesn't read like a joke either)

in reply toGrumpy77

I wrote “training” in quotes to indicate alternative meaning.

LindaP50 profile image
LindaP50 in reply toGrumpy77

You misread and or misunderstood Roy.

Am I wrong in thinking that at one time or another you believed that B1 stopped PD progression?

If I'm not, do you still believe that?

in reply to

It reversed my Parkinson's. Thiamine hcl is not a cure. It is a treatment that brings much relief to many. No one to my knowledge is using thiamine hcl as a product to sell. I learned about it from a newspaper article. I started B1. Having good results I communicated with Doctor Costantini to thank him and asked his advice on my dose. He adjusted my protocol. He did not ask for money. He did not try to sell a workshop or treatment at his clinic. He did not try to sell supplements or medicine. In his own words he has compassion and desire to help PwP and their caregivers. This FaceBook group's sole purpose is to spread knowledge and good news.

in reply to

Did you mean to respond to another post, Roy? You don't seem to have answered either of my questions.

Gioc profile image
Gioc in reply to

How does Roy know if "you are wrong in thinking," and then if you want Roy to answer only what you want, why don't you write the answer yourself.

Excuse me, Horace, how long have you been diagnosed with Parkinson, if you don't mind me asking?

in reply toGioc

Surely Roy knows whether or not he thought/thinks B1 stopped progression?

I'm not sure if English is your first language, but I don't think there was anything wrong with my syntax or my question. The phrasing was used in order to reflect the fact that I cant remember whether he thought it stopped progression.

Gioc profile image
Gioc in reply to

I have nothing to say about the syntax of the question, but rather on the merit. Of course he knows, as each of us Pwps knows.

Maybe you miss the obviousness of the question.

Every single post written here by us PWPS on medicines, supplements, protocol or research is written with the thought on our part that it can stop the sad consequences of the PD.

It is perfectly legitimate to think so.

We Pwps always hope for a cure, you know the impulse to survive is innate in man and is very strong 😂.

I don't agree when you don't accept his answer and then forget mine.

in reply toGioc

There's a pretty clear distinction between "provides therapeutic benefit" and "stops progression". It is probably the most important distinction in the PD sphere.

Gioc profile image
Gioc in reply to

Roy, take note!

for next time! This IS the right answer!

ddmagee1 profile image
ddmagee1

I’m glad you have a neurologist you can communicate with! PWP need all the help and understanding they can get, when dealing with this disease, that can affect just about every body system, in some way or the other, especially those of us,where the disease has advanced, and it causes many problems!

justjohn46 profile image
justjohn46

sounds like we all wasted a lot of time and money roy on buying thiamine and taking it.my feelings anyway.it never helped me.regards just john.

parkie13 profile image
parkie13 in reply tojustjohn46

For whatever reason it does not help everybody. It's made a tremendous difference in my physical response since I have been taking it. By posting that negative comments you might stop somebody from trying it. I'm very sorry I did not help you.

LindaP50 profile image
LindaP50

You are So lucky! With your posts, perhaps we'll each learn something new. Thank you and Happy New Year!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Any guidance on how to switch from IR C/L to CR C/L during the day?

I would like to try switching my mom over from her immediate release (IR) carbidopa levadopa (C/L)...
TSonmez profile image

Sinamet CR providing no relief

My Mom has PD and has been taking C-L with relative stability, but would go through "off-times"...
filmor14 profile image

What steps to titrate down c/l safely?

I am going through dose adjustment. I lowered B1 to one gram daily. I need to determine the safe...

Has anyone been able to reduce their C/L dose once they started on High Dose Therapy B-1? If so, how and why did you decide to reduce C/L?

My mom has been on HDT B1 at 1000 mg for almost a year now. I had her take a week break since I was...
TSonmez profile image

Sudden Onset if Stiffness and Pain

I have Parkinson’s and see a movement disorder specialist in Scottsdale. I have had sudden onset of...
Kevinbg profile image

Moderation team

See all
CPT_Aleksandra profile image
CPT_AleksandraAdministrator
CPT_Anaya profile image
CPT_AnayaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.