benfotiamine vs thiamine hcl: My initial... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,504 members27,915 posts

benfotiamine vs thiamine hcl

19 Replies

My initial symptoms improvement (before switching to thiamin HCL) is credited to 500mg/day of benfotiamine. I must now reconsider choices. HCL is reported to be effective in one to two months from starting. I will continue with thiamin HCL for the remaining 5 weeks and after two months total if I do not see greater improvement w/ HCL, I will return to Benfotiamine.

Ref: member "sunvox" posts

Read more about...
19 Replies
aspergerian profile image
aspergerian

Has anyone found a primary finding\study reporting that benfotiamine cross or is transported across the BBB in humans?

Is the use of benfotiamine for Alzheimer's based on improving sugar control and insulin resistancey in the periphery?

in reply toaspergerian

Ref: member "sunvox" posts

"The murky waters of thiamine"

whatadrama profile image
whatadrama in reply toaspergerian

I would also like to know the answer to whether benfotiamine crosses bb. It has been suggested that Dr c thinks it does not. Studies seem to say fat soluble b1 is better absorbed than water based. But fat soluble (benfotiamine) is

Man made.,.any thoughts or info

Gioc profile image
Gioc in reply towhatadrama

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Syncletica profile image
Syncletica

RoyProp, As a result of your encouraging reviews, in addition to studying Dr. Constantini's reports, I have today started taking 4,000 mg of Solgar's Thiamine HCL 500 mg. I would appreciate clarification as to the following:

1. Do you take the Thiamine on an empty stomach or "preferably with a meal" per Solgar's directions?

2. Do you supplement with a complete B-complex vitamin, and if so, do you take it at the same time as the Thiamine?

I am grateful that you would take time to respond. I am not on any PD meds--though, from a clinical perspective, I most certainly should be. I prefer to explore all credible natural therapeutic interventions.

Thank you.

in reply toSyncletica

Break the pills in half to swallow

Syncletica profile image
Syncletica in reply to

RoyProp: I have no problem swallowing the tablets. What led you to believe this was an issue?

in reply toSyncletica

My issue. They catch half way down, nearly choking to death.

My initial symptoms improvement (before switching to thiamin HCL) is credited to 500mg/day of benfotiamine. I must now reconsider choices. HCL is reported to be effective in one to two months from starting. I will continue with thiamin HCL for the remaining 5 weeks and after two months total if I do not see greater improvement w/ HCL, I will return to Benfotiamine.

Ref: member "sunvox" posts

Empty stomach.

B-Complex 2 hours before or after C/L.

You should be on C/L.

Syncletica profile image
Syncletica in reply to

I just saw your response to my query. Thank you.

Yes, I "should be on C/L" ; however, I witnessed two acquaintances experience horrible side effects.

I'll keep you updated regarding effects of high dose Thiamine HCL.

Greenday profile image
Greenday in reply toSyncletica

What side effects and at what dosage?

Syncletica profile image
Syncletica in reply toGreenday

Side effects as noted in research data germane to C/L.

134A profile image
134A in reply to

hi Roy i see in a previous post that you considered switching from Bentotiamine to HCL. did you switch and if so to what effect.?i can't seem to get HCL here i Canada (out of stock everywhere) but Bento is available.

i appreciate your expert advice.

thanks

in reply to134A

We only use thiamine hcl capsules

134A profile image
134A in reply to

Thanks Roy

in reply to

Hi there Roy, Just wondering, did you ever return to Benfotiamine? May I ask why or why not? Dr. C believed it does not cross the BBB but I have read that it does. ? Thank you.

in reply to

Dr Costantini is right

Dajudge profile image
Dajudge

What is the proper dosage of Vitamin B 1 (THIAMIN) daily and when should it be taken---------with food ----what dosage (how many grams or mgs per dose.

I HAVE PURCHASED from AMAZON VITAMIN B 1 SUPER POTENCY (THIAMIN 500 MG CAPSULES) How often should I take a capsule and are there any food concerns or side effects to be concerned about?

I really appreciate your posts and helpful info.

dajudge

in reply toDajudge

Solgar Thiamin HCL 500mg from Amazon or special order from lifeextension.com

You will need to order several bottles to get you by for several weeks at 8 tablets a day.

With of with out food.

No concerns.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Vitamin B1 : Thiamine vs. Benfotiamine

Why is it that the HDT of B1 is with Thiamine instead of Benfotiamine? Thiamine is water soluble...

B1 HCL or Allithiamine or benfotiamine?

Hi all, I think I got a link from HU that led me to this:...
TL500 profile image

constipation and thiamin HCL

I had improvement in constipation issue soon after starting T-HCL. If it is not transient, I will...

Thiamine HCL vs MonoNitrate?

Any opinions on which of these two water soluble forms of Thiamine is best for oral HDT. I’ve read...
reedboat2 profile image

Thiamine Derivatives

Why is Thiamine HCL recommended when it does (as far as I know) not pass through the BBB, when...
Dwest022 profile image

Moderation team

See all
CPT_Aleksandra profile image
CPT_AleksandraAdministrator
CPT_Anaya profile image
CPT_AnayaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.