Fitbit distance vs Treadmill distance - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

134,190 membersβ€’159,536 posts

Fitbit distance vs Treadmill distance

clairer6873 profile image
clairer6873Graduate
β€’12 Replies

Today I've been on the treadmill, where I've done all my runs so far and I've now completed week 11! But I've been wondering the whole way through the c25k and now bridge to 10k why my Fitbit distance is so inaccurate? Today, the treadmill says I ran 8.03km, my Fitbit says 8.65km!! Its a huge difference! I'm starting and stopping my Fitbit at pretty much the same time I start (give or take a couple of seconds!)

I'm worried about the accuracy of distance using my Fitbit for when I start some outdoor runs...

Does anybody else find this? πŸƒβ€β™€οΈ

Written by
clairer6873 profile image
clairer6873
Graduate
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
12 Replies
β€’
backintime profile image
backintimeGraduate

My phone has a tracking app (LG G3). And it's completely useless. Sometimes it doesn't recognise tbat I'm running and sometimes it says I did cycling...I haven't been on a bike in years.

I had heard good things about Fitbit though. Maybe you could do some benchmarking outside ? Run a distance that you know to be accurate and see what your fit bit says ?

clairer6873 profile image
clairer6873Graduateβ€’ in reply tobackintime

It's weird because with Fitbit, you can tell it what exercise you're going to do, and in the case of running you can tell it whether it's a free run (outdoor) or whether it's a treadmill run. So I really don't understand how it's so inaccurate.

Good idea to try an outdoor run where I know the distance though! Thanks for that πŸ‘πŸΌπŸ˜Š

LeeU profile image
LeeUGraduate

Go with the treadmill distance, the Fitbit/Garmin or whatever you choose to use won't know how far you have truly gone, it can estimate it depending on how far it thinks you have gone depending on, mainly, arm movement.

Where-as the treadmill is made with known tolerances of gears, rollers, number of revolutions, etc, from their is it really simple maths.

My Garmin is out but I always go by the treadmill for the reason above.

clairer6873 profile image
clairer6873Graduateβ€’ in reply toLeeU

Yes I always go by the treadmill distance, I just was unsure as to why the treadmill is so different, but now I see why thanks to yours and others comments, so thank you 😊

Tasha99 profile image
Tasha99Graduate

Fitbit doesn’t know your stride length. Get yourself outside! Dreadmills suck!

HeavyFoot profile image
HeavyFootGraduateβ€’ in reply toTasha99

Yup. Wake up and smell the cow poo!

clairer6873 profile image
clairer6873Graduateβ€’ in reply toTasha99

Ahh okay, that explains why then! Thank you. I do need to get outside, and I told myself I would once I completed the c25k. However now I've moved on to 5 to 10k, I've carried on doing it using a treadmill! I have a 5k race for life in a few weeks so I'll have no choice but to run outside then! πŸƒβ€β™€οΈ

IannodaTruffe profile image
IannodaTruffeMentor

Your device has to be calibrated to your personal stride length, otherwise it is just guessing.

Outdoors you can use a GPS device, which is more likely to be accurate, as, especially outdoors, nobodies stride remains totally constant throughout a run.

clairer6873 profile image
clairer6873Graduateβ€’ in reply toIannodaTruffe

Any idea how to calibrate it?! I use the GPS on my Fitbit when I go for walks and when I did the parkrun a few years back, I've just not done any outdoor runs since starting the c25k πŸƒβ€β™€οΈ

IannodaTruffe profile image
IannodaTruffeMentorβ€’ in reply toclairer6873

Sorry, never used one.

2718281 profile image
2718281Graduateβ€’ in reply toclairer6873

Go to the advanced seeing in the Fitbit app (to right icon and then almost at the bottom), you can manually calibrate your stride (treadmill) or let Fitbit use the GPS (only works outside)

clairer6873 profile image
clairer6873Graduateβ€’ in reply to2718281

Thank you 😊

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Fitbit or treadmill more accurate?

I just completed my W8, D3 run. I was using an 8 week program, so I did 30 minutes today. I...
JJAnBan profile image
Graduateβ€’

Fitbit app vs. Charge vs. others

Hi, this is a follow-up post to a run a few days ago where I used my Fitbit Charge (watch) to track...
sarah469 profile image
Graduateβ€’

Fitbit tracking gone wonky

Since the recent C25K app update on my phone (where it asked for permission to use my location), my...
NetballKitty profile image
Graduateβ€’

Fitbit or Treadmill?

What do I believe? the mileage on the Fitbit? or the mileage on the treadmill? It's not like...
RuNananana profile image
Graduateβ€’

Treadmill or not to Treadmill

So how is it that last night I ran 3 x 5.5 mins 1 x 3.5 mins on a treadmill, felt exhausted but...
VikkiHigg profile image
Graduateβ€’

Moderation team

See all
Annieapple profile image
AnnieappleAdministrator
MissUnderstanding profile image
MissUnderstandingAdministrator
Oldfloss profile image
OldflossAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.