Hi Neil

I had a look on-line and found the same article distributed and plagiarized across the net but no link to the referencing study. When I accessed the journal mentioned in the article There is a pay-wall so cannot locate the specific paper they refer too?

Even the BBC bastardized the report and named the Daily Mail health article as their source.

I am struggling to make sense of it?

Sample of the final passage:

"Part of the survey involved questions designed to assess how much the participants suppressed their emotions.

This involved agreeing or disagreeing, on a scale of one to five, with statements such as ‘When I’m angry I let people know’ or ‘I try to be pleasant so that others won’t get upset’.

The survey was repeated 12 years later, during which time 111 subjects had died – mostly from heart disease or cancer.

When researchers analysed the emotion scores, they found that death rates were highest among those most likely to bottle up their anger rather than let people know what they were thinking.

It is not clear exactly how suppressed emotions cause premature death.

One theory is that people turn to alcohol, cigarettes or junk food to help them cope with their hidden feelings.

Another is that the stress of keeping the lid on negative thoughts disrupts the hormone balance in the body, raising the risk of diseases linked with cellular damage, such as heart complaints and cancer.

The researchers stressed that the number of deaths in the study was small and that further investigations are needed.

‘These findings reveal significant associations between higher levels of emotional suppression and mortality,’ they reported.

‘The results suggest emotion suppression warrants more detailed investigation as a possible mortality risk.’

A previous study suggested that getting angry was good for you because it actually reduced the negative impact of stress.

Scientists at the University of Valencia in Spain found that getting angry increased blood flow to the left frontal region of the brain, which is involved in experiencing positive emotions and also triggers ‘closeness’.

The right side is more related to negative emotions and can provoke withdrawal, fear and sadness.

London-based business psychologist Voula Grand said: ‘It has long been thought that cancers are partly the result of suppressed emotions.

Past research has shown bottling up anger can impair the immune system.

‘But although people learn to hide their feelings at a very early age, they can still be taught to express them later in life. It takes a lot of energy and effort but it can be done.’

THIS IS JUST MAKING ME ANGRY CAN ANYONE TELL ME WHAT THIS MEANS?

Do we die early if we get angry or do we die early if we bottle it up? Did I get heart disease or cancer because I bottled up negative feelings or did I get cancer because I was always angry ? If I stay angry will I live longer ?

Just thought I would share this rather than bottle it up

Hi Hairbear, I'm glad you shared your feelings on this artlcle rather than bottling it up!

At first the article looked like it was about sharing feelings generally, in a positive way, but the final passage that you quote just seems to be about anger, and becomes more confusing/debatable.

There's a lot more that could be discussed on this - I hope I (and others) have time to get back to it tomorrow.

Paula

Conclusions

Emotion suppression may convey risk for earlier death, including death from cancer. Further work is needed to better understand the biopsychosocial mechanisms for this risk, as well as the nature of associations between suppression and different forms of mortality.

tinyurl.com/ompuhq8

Hardly definitive...

I'm still mulling over this "sharing feelings" stuff. It surely depends on how and when we do it. Sharing emotions - including anger, with people who will understand and be accepting of us, is surely positive. Helps us calm down - defuses the anger. But in the wrong environment, too much expressed anger can make others upset and angry too, and end up with a lot more stress all round. Not good.

Maybe we can focus on the positives... Neil called his original post "Share your feelings and live longer", rather than "Bottle up feelings and you'll get cancer".

Happy days....

Before you can share your feelings you need someone to share them with. People who are in the same boat as yourself are often the most understanding and that is why self help groups exsist. Getting angry and then being unable to express that anger (telling your boss he's an idiot will get you fired even if he is) that produces distress. There are jobs where keeping your temper is essential such as a policemen. But the hormones that are produced have to go somewhere. Best wishes

I have always thought that there is a connection between stress/anxiety/depression and cancer/heart problems. It seems from reading the above that there might be some truth in the idea I had. I have always suffered from stress/anxiety and now suffer with CLL. I wonder if the connection is direct and all my worrying has brought me something to really worry about! interestedly now that I have got something to seriously Panic about, I have finally got my act together...strange that!

HANG ON!!

This is the Daily Mail (who have a habit of making things up to suit their point of view or just fill their paper) and the end of the silly season......!!! As their source is mysterious, I suspect we should treat this with a massive vat of salt! [obviously from the salt we no longer take in our healthy diets!]

More worrying is that BBC is now taking Daily Mail stuff without verifying......the BBC cuts have really gone too far! THAT REALLY MAKES ME ANGRY!!!