Salt spray on roads: Am I being... - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

21,722 members24,486 posts

Salt spray on roads

runcyclexcski profile image
6 Replies

Am I being paranoid thinking that salt spray of road surfaces in the winter sets me off? I try to keep the car air intake shut, but one still needs the air to breathe. So I end up wearing a respirator while driving during winter months, particularly during snow storms.

Written by
runcyclexcski profile image
runcyclexcski
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
6 Replies
Bevvy profile image
Bevvy

Hmmm from all your posts it sounds like (unfortunately) you have more adverse reactions than most people will have. Hence your need to make various pieces of equipment to make life bearable.

Having said which I would be surprised if the salt used on roads would affect you. Indeed many people with respiratory issues use salt caves on a regular basis to alleviate symptoms.

I hope you get some answers soon for your current symptoms.

Patk1 profile image
Patk1

Perhaps it's what's already on the roads coming up in the saltspray + cold weather

runcyclexcski profile image
runcyclexcski

Thank you, Bevvy and Patk,

Indeed, it could be other things that just time-correlate with the salt-spraying and the cold weather. E.g. wood-burning and, maybe, they also put other things into the sprayed stuff.

The salt they put on the road is not necessarily NaCl, and, if it is, it's not pure NaCl. Table salt is NaCl, but they can also use KCl, MgCl2, CaCl2 and others. Every single one of these, when shipped to my science lab as powder, says "lung irritant" on the can. And there can be other anti-caking additives in the salt.

Scientific American is not a proper science reference, but for what it's worth:

scientificamerican.com/arti...

I looked up the benefits of salt caves for asthma in Google Scholar. There is some evidence that it may help, but most references I found were in low-ranked journals. This one is not too bad:

onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi...

four4 profile image
four4

I believe it may be true, as I used to have asthma attack immediately just after I used sodium chloride injection 0.9% to irrigate my nose. I tried this because it is recommended by some Dr for relieve of allergic rhinitis. However it is found not suitable to me.

Whatever the cause, I think if you find you react to the salt, it is best to avoid it.

Bilka profile image
Bilka

Hi , yes it possible to have adverse reaction to salt. I haven't had any of typical asthma attacks animal/dust related till i started being sensitive to chemicals-all sorts of airborne chemicals(air freshener , perfumes , cleaning products, smock, tree oils, grass, bleach..

... Only plain sea salt with no additives seems ok with me.

I have had a lots of allergy testing (under allergy consultant), surprisingly not try allergy. It could be more likely so called mast cell disorders , which is very complicated, under investigated and not fully understandable even by medics.

Bilka profile image
Bilka

Hi again ,could i ask what make of charcoal impregnated mask are you using and where you buy them from? Thank you in advance.

You may also like...

Salt cave

I visited a salt cave today and had a bad experience! I have mild asthma and decided to go with a...

Throat spray

a reply to someone and said they used a throat spray at the first sign of infection, I can’t find...

Steaming with salt

anybody on here tried steaming with Himalayan pink salt. I have been reading of various, benefits,...

Dymista nasal spray

seen told me to take 2 sprays morning and night into both nostril so 8 sprays in total(both...

Discrepancy between DEFRA data and perceived pollution due to wood burning

smoke which correlated with my asthma symptoms -- during cold evenings. I was puzzled that I never...