Knee aspiration.: My painful arthritic... - Arthritis Action

Arthritis Action

7,621 members2,151 posts

Knee aspiration.

kateanne profile image
9 Replies

My painful arthritic knees are getting much worse and are now very swollen which makes it feel very tight as well as painful when walking. I am thinking of enquiring about having the fluid removed. Has anyone had this procedure and if so, any information on what to expect would be welcome. Is it very painful? My gp told me its not worth it as the fluid only comes back but I'm willing to try it even if only for temporary relief.

Written by
kateanne profile image
kateanne
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
9 Replies

Hi kateanne,

I go along with your GP. The whole point is the fluid is caused by something - like arthritic inflammation. If you remove the fluid, and the inflammation remains as sure as night follows day it'll come back. I got to your stage and opted for a partial knee replacement. Best thing I ever did. The best!

Have you had either X-Rays or MRI to show what and where the problem really is ?

Trust me - in the end the pain will get ya and you'll beg for surgery.

John

kateanne profile image
kateanne in reply to

Hi John. Yes had xray a couple of years ago which , in simple terms showed wear and tear resulting in OA. i had a steroid injection which did nothing. The other knee is now the same. The swelling in both knees is worse than when I saw the GP. Thank you for your comments. Will have a think about it.

in reply to kateanne

Sounds very similar to my progress. I had my right knee cartilige removed, along with a clean up as there were signs of OA in 2000 and managed to survive till 2015. By then it was as you describe and surgery was the only answer.

Now, dammit, the same issue is emerging in my left shoulder. About to see a consultant next week on the options. I've had physio which has enhanced my freedom of movement but done nothing for pain. Sleeping at night now is virtually impossible.

😱 Anyway, good luck with whatever you decide.

John

kateanne profile image
kateanne in reply to

I know how you feel. Not just my knees that hurt. Bsck and hand problems also with me. I hate getting old!! Hope you get your shoulder sorted soon. Best wishes.

SusieSquirrel profile image
SusieSquirrel

Hi Kate Anne,My physio refused to drain mine as he said it just comes back. The fluid is there to try and protect your damaged knee cap. I've been prescribed a new type of knee brace for walking which has springs at each side. Costs the NHS £250 so hope it works. Especially seen as I need a one for my left too! My dad has one and he says its brilliant.

Its called a thuasne action knee reliever

kateanne profile image
kateanne in reply to SusieSquirrel

Hi SusieSquirrel.Thanks for your reply. I hadn't heard of that knee brace but will look into it.

Seems like my GP is right and I'm stuck with this fluid unless I have surgery. My GP told me he suffers with knee problems so he understands the pain.

LizPod profile image
LizPod in reply to kateanne

Hi Kateanne, I came across your thread when SS mentioned the action reliever knee brace. I actually work at Thuasne so I wanted to point you in the right direction. If you look at actionreliever.co.uk you'll find all the information and can request an information pack to take to your GP if you think it might help you. Whatever you end up doing, I hope you find a solution to helping with your knee pain. All the best, Liz

kateanne profile image
kateanne in reply to LizPod

Thank you for your helpful reply. Just wondering how comfortable they are as the word brace suggests to me something that constricts movement as opposed to a support.

kateanne profile image
kateanne in reply to LizPod

Just read the link you sent and it has answered my question. Thank you.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

knee replacement

hi had a meniscus op repair for torn cartlidge 2007 and have all sorts of problems since, with by...

Total Knee Replacement

Hi Hope everyone is well. I need a bit of advice.- I've been given a date for my knee...

Knee Pain

Hi, I'm new here too. I have suffered knee pain for nearly 5 years and it's getting to the point...

TOTAL KNEE REPLACEMENT

Hi, Just had total knee replacement 8th Nov. I really wonder if I would have this done again. I had...

Knee surgery update

Hello everyone, this is an update on my knee surgery which I had on 23 March. In the end my partial...