Best alternative PET for PSMA negativ... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,397 members26,783 posts

Best alternative PET for PSMA negative PCa

Vynbal profile image
12 Replies

Asking for a friend. He was diagnosed 3 years ago with high risk high volume (Gleason 3+5) PCa. Treated with EBRT + LDRBT + ADT (18 months). His PSA was undetectable but is now rising (3+) but PSMA-PET was negative, even in the prostate - implying PSMA non-avid cancer. What would be the best non-PSMA PET scan for him?

Written by
Vynbal profile image
Vynbal
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
12 Replies
GP24 profile image
GP24

You could just wait until the PSA value reaches 5 or more ng/ml and repeat the PSMA PET/CT. Otherwise I would try a choline PET/CT, it is more sensitive than an FDG PET/CT. Another alternative is an Axumin scan.

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply to GP24

Is a choline PET known by another name? Thanks

GP24 profile image
GP24 in reply to dhccpa

In the US it is mainly offered by the Mayo clinic where it was developed:

mayoclinic.org/tests-proced...

Outside of the US it is offered by many clinics. However, the demand for scans detecting PSMA negative tumors is low, so usually a PSMA PET/CT is done which is more sensitive.

I had a PSMA PET/CT which did not detect anything and therefore wanted to check for PSMA negative tumor. The choline PET/CT did not detect anything as well. Three months later the PSMA PET/CT detected mets.

dhccpa profile image
dhccpa in reply to GP24

Thanks. Yes, I wondered if that was the one at Mayo. I didn't realize no one else in USA offered it.

I have had four Axumin scans, last on 1/3/2024, but have not had the PSMA scan yet.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

Instead of fishing for metastases, he may be better off with a short, intensive hormone therapy as in these trials:

prostatecancer.news/2023/05...

prostatecancer.news/2022/09...

Mascouche profile image
Mascouche in reply to Tall_Allen

Hi TA. I always prefer to read your own articles to those on PubMed as they are easier to understand. Did you ever write any about STOMP or about ORIOLE? If so, would you be so kind as to provide the link to those?

EDIT: Never mind, I have fixed my laziness and found how to search your articles. :)

Got this one for ORIOLE: prostatecancer.news/2019/09...

and this one for STOMP: prostatecancer.news/2017/12...

Thanks for having written them :)

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Mascouche

See also Section III of this:

prostatecancer.news/2020/07...

lokibear0803 profile image
lokibear0803

you might look into 64Cu-SAR-bisPSMA:

urologytimes.com/view/fda-a...

V10fanatic profile image
V10fanatic

I waS PSMA non-avid and an FDG-PET picked up the latest round of mets.

NanoMRI profile image
NanoMRI in reply to V10fanatic

At what PSA? I am learning even at very low PSA values one of available imaging methods may be successful - which one is the challenge.

V10fanatic profile image
V10fanatic in reply to NanoMRI

I was at 7.25

NanoMRI profile image
NanoMRI

I see great value in imaging (fishing) for mets at very low PSA values, with intent to reduce tumor burden - not just to affirm cancer remains. Over six years ago, after unsuccessful salvage RT, at 0.11, I traveled from US to Europe and had successful imaging. I chose surgery to remove identified pelvic mets as an alternative to STAMPEDE trial protocol. Today, with PSA holding very low stable 0.03X range, and with unsuccessful Ga68 and Pylarify PSMA PETs, I am considering either fluciclovine/Axumin or Mayo's Choline combined with mpMRI. Yes, well ahead of common practice, but I have learned to not give this beast time and obscurity. I would prefer the imaging I had in Europe, but currently it is not available; in my words it is tied up in bureaucracy.

You may also like...

Advanced recurrent PCa, rising PSA, 2 negative PSMA PET Scans

2020 my PSA was 2.5, so I had a Ga68 PSMA PET scan at UCLA which came back as negative, no PCa...

Failed RP & SRT; Negative PSMA PET

failed as well. A recent PSMA PET scan showed no signs of recurrent prostate cancer or metastases....

PSMA PET/CT is not very good; it's just the best that is widely available

for PSA to rise so that they can detect metastases with a PSMA PET/CT. The answer is \\"no.\\"...

Cost of PSMA pet scan

saw how much medicare was charged for my PSMA Pet scan. The scan was done in the Boston area. There...

Cost of PSMA PET scan?

varying costs of PSMA PET scans. At Duke, I have been informed that my share of the scan could...