Xtandi already failing? How is this p... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,056 members26,262 posts

Xtandi already failing? How is this possible

Mw921000000 profile image
13 Replies

hi everyone. My dad met with his new oncologist today. He consented to genetic testing so his bloodwork will be sent out in 6 weeks. His new PSA reading came back at 2.84. On February 7th, it was 1.94. He also got another lupron shot today and it’s been over three months since he received one, maybe that’s why his psa increased? I don’t know. This isn’t good though and my anxiety is starting to get the best of me. Any advice?

Written by
Mw921000000 profile image
Mw921000000
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
13 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

Timely Lupron shots are important. Consider combining Xtandi+ docetaxel:

prostatecancer.news/2022/10...

Mw921000000 profile image
Mw921000000 in reply to Tall_Allen

he had a 15 day delay, would this matter? Also, new doctor at MSK said chemo is jumping ahead too quickly and she tends to do it when there’s absolutely nothing else left

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Mw921000000

Yes, it matters.

All recent evidence is that early use of docetaxel is better.

Mw921000000 profile image
Mw921000000 in reply to Tall_Allen

I trust the evidence. Should we have gone with a doctor who is pushing more towards chemo? Being that this is a top hospital, I would have thought they would have been more suggestive of the option, but they’ve been the opposite. I cannot begin to guess why

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Mw921000000

I've found that the specific doctor matters more than the hospital. Now that Michael Morris is no longer accepting patients at MSK, I think that Dana Rathkopf is excellent.

But an empowered patient can make a big difference. I always send emails with links to peer-reviewed journal articles that I want to discuss at the visit. This gives the doctor time to think about issues of importance to you. Doctors are busy, so a "heads up" is always appreciated rather then putting them on the spot.

Here's what I know about timing of docetaxel:

prostatecancer.news/2019/02...

Mw921000000 profile image
Mw921000000 in reply to Tall_Allen

Thanks so much for this. Is she at NYC location?

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Mw921000000

Yes.

Gl448 profile image
Gl448

He also got another lupron shot today and it’s been over three months since he received one, maybe that’s why his psa increased?”

When was his last Lupron shot and what was the dosage of it? Lupron comes in multiple different dosages anywhere from 1 to 6 months.

Did he intentionally decide to not get his last shot timely, or did his medical team not schedule or remind him? If the latter, time to find a new doc in my opinion.

Mw921000000 profile image
Mw921000000 in reply to Gl448

December 14th was his last one. March 15 was supposed to be his next injection but his doctor at MSK, a “top cancer hospital” decided to cancel his appointment the week of and not even contact us. If I didn’t check his portal we would have been on our way to the city. I doubt the 15 day delay would matter too much, would it?

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n in reply to Mw921000000

Who's his M.O. at MSK? Where is your Dear Dad located?

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Thursday 03/30/2023 7:09 PM DST

Mw921000000 profile image
Mw921000000 in reply to j-o-h-n

MSK in nyc, his old doctor was Lewis Kempel, he was the one who cancelled lupron appointment and didn’t notify us, he just retired (I think this is why he was slacking off for the last 6 months), but we just were assigned to Susan Slovin. So far we like her. Who do you see at MSK?

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n in reply to Mw921000000

I see Dr. Michael Morris...... (for many years)........I've seen Dr. Slovin's name here many times, with all good comments (reviews). Give My Regards to Your Dad...

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Thursday 03/30/2023 10:37 PM DST

Teacherdude72 profile image
Teacherdude72 in reply to Gl448

Personally I choose monthly Lupron. With the linger dose I have fewer side effects the weeks before the next dose. Monthly never seems to wear off.

You may also like...

Xtandi fail chemo next

off Xtandi though his PSA is low (3.7) they suspect his PC is not producing PSA. His ALP is 135 up...

Possible castrate resistance already?

father just has his first follow up appointment. He started Lupron and casodex in May. His bone...

xtandi failing?

In September last year my PSA was 0.06. Three months later PSA was 0.09. I asked my doctor if...

What's next after Xtandi fails?

other's ideas as I sense his 16 month run with Xtandi will be ending soon. His is PSA is...

XTANDI beginning to fail

2012, when PSA rose again, Lupron for 4 years by itself was effective, Then in 2016 Lupron + ADT...