Proscar vs. Propecia: Both of these... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,290 members27,988 posts

Proscar vs. Propecia

Frankenski profile image
4 Replies

Both of these drugs are Finasteride. 1mg. for male pattern baldness, and 5mg. for PCa.

Assuming you're a healthy man, can the Propecia, 1mg., affect your PSA enough to lower it to almost nil numbers?

F

Written by
Frankenski profile image
Frankenski
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
4 Replies
pjoshea13 profile image
pjoshea13

There is an old (1992) study that compared the two doses on men with BPH:

"During the first six months, the median size of the prostate decreased progressively in both finasteride-treated groups after which it did not change significantly, and it was significantly smaller in both finasteride-treated groups than in the placebo group at all times ... After 12 months of treatment, the prostate had shrunk by 19 percent from base line in the group given 5 mg of finasteride, by 18 percent in the group given 1 mg of finasteride, and by 3 percent in the group given placebo".

No mention of PSA, but, clearly, 1mg does have a significant effect.

& of course, both doses would have PCa screening implications.

nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/N...

In a later (2007) study that did look at PSA:

"Within 48 weeks of randomisation, men aged 40-49 years and 50-60 years who were assigned 1 mg/day finasteride had a median decrease in serum PSA concentration of 40% ... and 50% .., respectively. In men assigned placebo, the median changes were 0% ... and a median increase of 13% .., respectively."

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/171...

The men in the latter study presumably did not have suspected BPH (or PCa).

-Patrick

Frankenski profile image
Frankenski in reply topjoshea13

Thank You Patrick.

in reply topjoshea13

Interesting. I wonder if low dose finisteride would offer some benefit to PC patients who are still showing low PSA readings after treatment. Sort of like of statin use as general goodness preventative measure?

pjoshea13 profile image
pjoshea13 in reply to

Dr. Myers found that some men on ADT needed a 5alpha-reductase inhibitor [5ARI] to inhibit dihydrotestosterone [DHT]. He preferred Dutasteride [Avodart] to Finasteride.

The vlog where he discussed this was made before Avodart became generic. He spoke of monitoring DHT to find the minimum dose that would do the job. Cost is less of an issue these days, but why use more than you need? Some patients needed only one dose per week.

Myers said that it wasn't testosterone [T] that we should worry about while on ADT, but the far more potent DHT. Normally, our DHT is made only by the action of 5AR on T, but some men also produce DHT via another pathway. In fact, ADT sometimes selects for PCa cells that find that pathway.

Myers himself was a copious producer of DHT, so he was sensitive to the problem. He thought it crazy that doctors in the field would ignore DHT.

My concern is that DHT conversion happens privately within PCa cells. It's an intracrine process, so why would DHT be measurable in blood? I think it prudent to take Avodart anyway.

& I think that it's a good idea to use it while on an ADT vacation. T levels do not recover quickly, so this could be another low-dose scenario.

-Patrick

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

proscar and avodart

I know that these drugs are not part of NCCN guidelines, but since everyone holds that DHT is more...

Carbs vs. Fats vs. Protein

Has anyone come across research that speaks to what is the best diet strategy in terms of macros? I...
brilliant17 profile image

Zytiga vs. Xtandi vs. Radium 223 vs. Cannabis

Dx 9/2010 with agressive PCa. Failed RP, hormone injections every 3 months. Mets in pubic rami....
Gultch profile image

Xtandi vs. Abiraterone vs. Nubeqa

So… my recurrence treatment plan consists of RT and ADT & Xtandi for 2 years. I’m still working...
shueswim profile image

Car-t vs regeneron vs Lu177

I had a long conversation with Dr Drake today regarding my treatment options for mCRPC after having...

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.