What do you think about gender bias on heal... - Women's Health

Women's Health

41,941 members3,961 posts

What do you think about gender bias on health research?

SimoneHU profile image
SimoneHUHealthUnlocked
3 Replies

Nowadays we see many studies with a equal slip of male and female participants. But, for many years that was not the case. Cardiovascular disease research in the 80s, for example, was mostly done in men. Now, although more women are being included on studies, men were still constantly the focus of much of the research on important causes of death for both genders.

Some would even say that the increase on female participants is also strongly related with having more studies exclusive to women. Which means that the number of female participants wouldn't be so fairly distributed if studies with only women were not considered!!

Looks like the cardiovascular disease red flag from the 80s is being addressed: I found a study (circ.ahajournals.org/conten... that shows how that last 10 years changed on the subject of cardiovascular disease research and prevention for women.

I also found this article by by Carolyn Thomas with many examples of what she calls Unconscious Bias: myheartsisters.org/2013/08/...

A few interesting points mentioned:

- Girls are 22 percent less likely to be placed on a kidney transplant list than boys

- Orthopedic surgeons were 22 times more likely to recommend knee-replacement to men than to women

- We are socialized to believe that women are more likely to have pain than men, or at least are more willing to complain of pain than men.

- Women under the age of 55 who are experiencing a heart attack are seven times more likely to be misdiagnosed and sent home from the E.R - misdiagnosed with indigestion, anxiety or menopause

- A 2005 American Heart Association study showed, in fact, that only 8% of family physicians and – even worse! – just 17% of cardiologists were aware that heart disease kills more women than men

What do you think about all that?

Do you ever feel like your healthcare was different due to your gender?

Where do you think it starts?

COMMENT BELOW PLEASE :)

Written by
SimoneHU profile image
SimoneHU
HealthUnlocked
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
3 Replies
Clutter profile image
Clutter

Gender bias is still happening in primary care. Women tend to be told their fatigue and ill health is due to stress, family responsibilities &/or menopause and are usually offered antidepressants rather than investigation of their symptoms.

Pre-teen girls fail to be diagnosed with autism as they are more likely to be withdrawn and depresssed than disruptive and disorderly. Having said that, boys who aren't disruptive may also find it difficult to get an autism diagnosis.

skybluepink profile image
skybluepink in reply to Clutter

The Swedes years ago thought prenatal ultrasounds could play a part in the problem of damage? Wonder what the statistics are in relation?

skybluepink profile image
skybluepink

Research should be patient orientated & be at core of practice from word go .This is not happening as the NHS appears to be corrupted by criteria, remits contracts policies & procedures ignoring your resulting underlying conditions, discriminating against age & disability with mercenary, unethical with illegal intent against the Vulnerable . To make matters worse you cannot get an independent second opinion or the law to back up the illegal bias & operation with no discretion.So the admin directs to rip off & continually cause no development for the patients .If you raise issues or protest you are then illegally libelled & maligned & set up to be stressed by closed groups on internet behind your back ignoring confidentiality with Information Commisioner , the Charities & MPs enabling too with no appropriate intervention for individuals .

You may also like...

Thinking about having a baby

with it. The thing is I like my best friend a lot and he doesn’t seem to like me the way I do, I...

what about surrogacy?Need ur advice

Dear women, I so need your advice. Is here someone who did surrogacy? On these days I heard about...

I'm new and need help. I don't know what to do or who can help

light, rhinitis and flu-like symptoms. I have more symptoms, but the former are more intense. When...