BMI???: BMI? I take it with a pinch of... - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

115,084 members61,312 posts

BMI???

5 Replies

BMI? I take it with a pinch of salt! My usual BMI over most of my life was in the Normal range, but now is in the Overweight range? Why? As is usual at my age I have shrunk a little in height which pushes me into the higher range! I shrunk by one inch! A little change in height makes a HUGE difference in BMI! Have a play with one of the online calculators. My weight is exactly the same as it has been over the last 50 years (I am 72).

I used fat calipers to get a more meaningful result.

5 Replies
Zest profile image
ZestHealthy BMI

Hi Kjt239,

Well done for keeping your weight at a stable and healthy rate for the last 50 years, that is really great!

I think that BMI is helpful as an indicator, but clearly there are lots of healthy indicators that are probably more meaningful and certainly I know that many medical people go by waist measurements.

I think this article is quite good:

livinghealthy.com/articles/...

I still go by BMI as an indicator though, as I do find it helpful personally - although I use the 'new BMI' - which is more relevant to taller people.

I hope you're enjoying your weekend.

Lowcal :-)

in reply toZest

Hi Lowcal!

I had never heard of NewBMI. When I tried it it dumped me solidly into the normal range!

I like you!!

kjt239

Zest profile image
ZestHealthy BMI in reply to

I'm so glad you liked that result! :-)

RobLandsdown91 profile image
RobLandsdown91

Zest makes a point. I do use the BMI calculator to gague where I am - it was 49 when I started out and it is 35.2 now. It does give you a lift when it goes down, that little bit closer to being 'healthy' :)

That is fantastic keeping your weight stable over 50 years I wish I could say the same alas I've been gaining and losing the same stone for about 40 years. BMI is a far from perfect instrument (especially if you are very sporty) but it is useful to at least gauge where a healthy range lies for your height...I like to see my weight in the healthy range even if it's at the top end at the moment ;)

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

1lbs off BMI??

I don't understand what BMI is? two weeks ago my Bmi was 25.7 and now it's 25.3 according to the...
Kerry82 profile image

Question about the NHS BMI calculator

Hi all, I'm sure someone will know the answer to this, When you put in your height, weight, and...
Fran182716 profile image

What's the "Healthy BMI" badge for?

I got this badge last week (happily gone now), and I just saw @[1274895] turning it down. I don't...

BMI achieved

15 months ago to the day my BMI WAS 40.1. With a weight of over 21 stone. This morning the scales...
Andyt2120 profile image

BMI 25 or BMI 22

Every time I go on the WiiFit it tells me that my ideal weight is around 10 stone 5 pounds (BMI...

Moderation team

See all
moreless profile image
morelessAdministrator
TheTabbyCat profile image
TheTabbyCatAdministrator
TeamAdmin profile image
TeamAdminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.