Why Doesn’t My Endocrinologist Know All of This? - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,245 members166,504 posts

Why Doesn’t My Endocrinologist Know All of This?

greygoose profile image
17 Replies

nahypothyroidism.org/why-do...

An article about endo's attitudes.

Quite shocking, really, when you realise that their egos are more important to them than their patients!

Grey

Pinched the photo from a Mary Shomon article on about.com, it just seemed to fit.

Written by
greygoose profile image
greygoose
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
17 Replies
helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator

The inertia in the system is phenomenal.

I take one tiny topic that keeps buzzing around my head. Bed-time dosing with levothyroxine has been reported in several published papers. And, when mentioned here, it has flushed out several people who had been doing so for many years (i.e. before recent papers).

So it is clearly one option with the possibility that it will be better for some patients.

And yet, the Patient Information Leaflets, Summaries of Product Characteristics, textbooks, other guidance documents, seem resolutely stuck to taking it in the morning.

And I really cannot see where the mechanism is for these documents ever to get updated.

No pharmaceutical company is going to revise them with the latest information and patient experiences. They will do just enough to keep them the right side of the regulators and avoid censure.

No doctor is going to advise the pharmaceutical company to change the documents.

Anyone writing a textbook will refer back to the PIL and SPC and may even not mention bed-time because these documents do not.

And so it goes round to the next generation of doctors. To be perpetuated seemingly forever.

That is why I believe it is up to us to question, complain, make suggestions and, eventually we hope, get at least some things changed.

(I made this specific point the other day in a complaint about a PIL I put in to both Teva and MHRA. The main subject of the complaint was use of the word "beta-sympatholytics" in a PIL. That is a term which is not widely used anywhere. So how would a patient know if they were taking one or not?)

Rod

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply tohelvella

No Idea if I'm taking one! lol Shall have to look it up.

It's so sad that groups like this are necessary, but thank goodness they are here. Wonder how many lives they've saved (mine for a start) and how many endos have killed!

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply togreygoose

No, didn't think I would be. Here, for anyone else that is interested, is a link:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sympa...

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator in reply togreygoose

Which is where I too looked.

Interesting that in one of the lists there you can see propranolol. And in the PIL there is a specific, separate, entry for propranolol - which doubles the confusion.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply tohelvella

Ah, but do they really want us to understand???

headinjuryhypo profile image
headinjuryhypo in reply togreygoose

I tried your link but got a click and a yellow star, and stayed on this page. Is there anything I can google to get it?

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toheadinjuryhypo

Which link are you refering to? The Wiki link? Just google beta-sympatholytics. If it's the first link, then google the title : why doesnt my endocrinologist know all of this?

Hope that helps, Grey

Whippetlover profile image
Whippetlover in reply toheadinjuryhypo

The link worked for me also googling took me straight to the article. Hope you've found it now.

Christine

headinjuryhypo profile image
headinjuryhypo in reply toWhippetlover

Yes I went back and tried the link again and it worked perfectly! Don't know what went wrong before. A very good thought-provoking article, but it made me feel despairing!

Whippetlover profile image
Whippetlover in reply toheadinjuryhypo

Know what you mean. Unfortunately, Dr Holtorf is referred to as a 'quack' by some other doctors which gives our UK doctors the perfect excuse not to take him seriously! I despair too sometimes. x

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator

I think it is disgraceful but most GP's are following the advice given by the British Thyroid Association with regard to thyroid gland problems and do not appear to know any clinical symptoms whatsover or listen to the patient.

merissa profile image
merissa

mmm great post, thanks, ironic, may print some of for my g.p xx

carnation profile image
carnation

I have always taken my meds in the morning as that's what it said on the leaflet.

My daughter was diagnosed with Hashi and was referred to an endo 4-5 yrs ago. She takes her meds at night and always has, but I only discovered this since I joined this site.

I guess the endo told her to do this as we have the same GP surgery, so there are people out there willing to embrace change.

Whippetlover profile image
Whippetlover

Thanks for this greygoose! It is so true! I've just changed my GP from the older one to the younger one although he's probably at least 15 years out of medical school. He is still more 'teachable' than the older one who gets extremely defensive if questioned. I did manage a minor victory when I slapped a meta analysis of studies supporting adding T3 to the T4 I was already on. He prescribed me the T3 there and then so I'll stick with him.

I've been diagnosed with fibromyalgia and CFS amongst other conditions but I firmly believe that these problems are thyroid related as they appeared at the same time as my thyroid gland failed but haven't gone away with my current treatment although the T3 does help a bit.

This forum is the best one on HU (imho) and I get so much hope from the blogs on here. I won't - I can't give up on ME!

Christine

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toWhippetlover

I couldn't agree with you more about the fibro and CFS being 'related' to thyroid. In fact, I would go as far as to say that they ARE un/under-treated thyroid. They've been invented as a get-out clasue for lazy and/or ignorant doctors. The fact that they haven't gone away yet, although helped by T3, to me means that you're not on enough T3. But I'm not an 'educated' doctor! lol

Grey x

Whippetlover profile image
Whippetlover in reply togreygoose

I do think that under-treated thyroid IS the cause of the fibro and CFS. I've been trying to find a letter from the only endo I've ever seen in which he says I feel better when my levels are high (strangely my TSH remained high too!)

I know I kept it because my Mum went through the same thing and I didn't expect to get the same treatment elsewhere. Sending you a PM with a little more info but I might get my wrist slapped if I posted it here.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toWhippetlover

lol ok

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Why don’t Doctors know/Deal with this hypothyroid issue??

I found what I believe to be an informative and interesting article for people who suffer with...
Batty1 profile image

Why do endocrinologist know nothing about hypothyroidism?

I am trying to understand why is it that most doctors don’t really have a understanding of...

There is an article in the Mail: “Blood tests say my hypothyroidism is under control. So why do I feel so exhausted? Ask DR MARTIN SCURR”

There is an article in the Mail: “Blood tests say my hypothyroidism is under control. So why do I...
joiaz profile image

Why doesn’t t3 work for me

I have always known I was hypothyroid, finally dr M. checked my labs, my Rt3 was 21 and free t3...
8grand profile image

An Endocrinologist who doesn’t believe in T3 helping

I was diagnosed with Hashimotos a long time ago and have been treated with Levo in various amounts...