EVIDENCE NEEDED PLEASE! In the past year, have ... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

139,804 members164,291 posts

EVIDENCE NEEDED PLEASE! In the past year, have you been told your T3 will be removed, or you can't start T3 due to national/local policies?

TaraJR profile image
22 Replies

I co-lead ITT Improve Thyroid Treatment group (currently on Facebook, but hopefully a website soon) We work on certain pieces of work with Thyroid UK and The Thyroid Trust.

In August 2023 NHSE issued 2 pieces of guidance related to T3 prescribing - They contradicted each other, but one said all patients should be de-prescribed T3.

We need evidence to show if this is still happening, so we can feed back to NHSE.

Has anyone been told they can't keep their T3, or they can't start T3, because of national or local guidance/ policy? If so, please can you give details, and say which area you're in? Many thanks.

Written by
TaraJR profile image
TaraJR
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
22 Replies
annnsandell profile image
annnsandell

I would be interested in what the other document says, you say contradictory, does it say prescribe T3?

I had my Thyroid removed in 2009 and was at suppression levels, now stopped. I have always been a low converter and have asked my doctor about T2, he is coming back to me at the end of the month. Mind you getting a T3 test is hard enough, it used to be automatic for Thyroid cancer as part of a yearly test. Almost a conspiracy not to test T3 which would show up low conversion.

tattybogle profile image
tattybogle in reply to annnsandell

for details see this post : healthunlocked.com/thyroidu... joint-thyroid-groups-letter-to-nhse-regarding-t3-guidance HealthStarDust

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust in reply to tattybogle

Thank you.

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR in reply to tattybogle

tattybogle thaks for adding the links. I'm in deepest Wales at the moment, and wifi is not exactly reliable! I've just managed to get back on tonight!

mstp profile image
mstp

Yes my GP refused to prescribe it so I have been buying it fir tge last 13 years. When I recently asked him again he still won't prescribe it.

Jgoodwin977 profile image
Jgoodwin977 in reply to mstp

What is fir tge?

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Jgoodwin977

...for the...

mstp profile image
mstp in reply to Jgoodwin977

Sorry.. for the...

Jgoodwin977 profile image
Jgoodwin977 in reply to mstp

oh thanks for clarifying, thought it was a brand name!

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to mstp

helvella - Editing HealthUnlocked Posts/Replies

Having read a post or reply you have made, I wonder if you realise that you can edit (or delete) any posts or responses you have made here. That means the title, the text or images.

This is not to say you have done anything wrong. This is meant to help you by pointing out this option, and help to do so, not to criticise.

There is no need to reply to this! If it was helpful, ticking the "Like" button lets me know.

Follow the link below for details

helvella.blogspot.com/p/hel...

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR in reply to mstp

What reason did he give you recently? Did he say the local or national policy was not to prescribe T3?

In fact a UK GP is not supposed to initiate T3 - it has to be started off by an NHS endo.

HealthStarDust profile image
HealthStarDust

Which two pieces of guidance please?

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR in reply to HealthStarDust

See comment from tattybogle - the 2 links are there

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

My liothyronine prescription was discontinued. My normal GP retired and nowadays we see a different one each time. It was a game of annual Russian Roulette as to when I'd get the wrong GP. The younger GPs don't have the confidence to make decisions and so follow 'guidance'. My GPs are now too scared to prescribe.

I was given a referral to my local hospital endocrinologist but as I live in NW London the referral was intercepted and I was passed onto a 'liothyronine clinic'. This turned out to be an endocrinologist with poor thyroid knowledge who is being rewarded for discontinuing patients' liothyronine prescriptions. This problem is now with the GMC. See my previous posts for details.

Another issue is that NHS England and NICE give lip service to patients' concerns and draft guidelines that have some degree of reasonableness. After an interval they then do an 'update' (without patient involvement) which sabotages patients' input into the initial guidance.

A further strategy is that anti-T3 doctors offer 'training' that goes against the spirit of the guidelines. This has a deep long-term effect on new doctors. An example is the MIMS video on Hypothyroidism mimslearning.co.uk/learn/co... (you have to register and pretend to be a doctor to view it). Although the NICE guideline is a consensus document this training video takes an extreme anti-T3 view, there is no attempt to present a consensus view. Studies from the USA are used to suggest there is over diagnosis in the UK (USA doctors diagnose more than twice as often as UK doctors).

The persistent problem we have is that these extremists have control of the guideline process and seek to change guidelines once patient groups have left the meeting.

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR in reply to jimh111

jimh111 yes I'm aware of the awful saga you're going through :-(

What reason have you been given in the last 12 months? Have you been told that the local or national policy is not to prescribe T3?

jimh111 profile image
jimh111 in reply to TaraJR

The GPs say they have no knowledge of prescribing liothyronine and so can't take responsibility for prescribing. I was told by one GP that she would continue my private prescriptions if I got an endocrinologist to monitor me she would prescribe.The issue I have is I need around 45 mcg daily and I don't know if an endocrinologist would prescribe this. My TSH remains low if I come off hormone, I don't know if this is because it was suppressed for a long time or pituitary damage from a major car accident we had in 1999. That's why I accepted a referral to a local NHS endocrinologist, I hoped they would check this out, he said he would. He was lying, hence it's with the GMC

The impression I get is the GPs have been got at, a mix of scare stories and intimidation. I think my GPs want to help but are fearful. I feel I should go for the head of the snake.

SmallBlueThing profile image
SmallBlueThing in reply to jimh111

When I stopped adding one grain of Thiroyd desiccated thyroid extract to 100 mcg levothyroxine, my TSH was still suppressed after three months, and responding when tested after 5.5 months. Despite increasing my dose of levothyroxine, my TSH was over range at 5.8 miu/L [0.3 - 5.0] within nine months of ceasing the source of T3. The range for fT4 is quite wide at 9.0 - 25.0 pmol/L, which poses its own problems, and the lower limit of the TSH range has been increased to 0.55 miu/L.

Jgoodwin977 profile image
Jgoodwin977

I told my GP in Croydon that I’m in this forum and that members are getting T3 and wanted him to refer me to an endocrinologist recommended that would prescribe it. He said it’s not possible to get t3 and I wouldn’t be successful in getting it. What’s happening to get this resolved?

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR in reply to Jgoodwin977

Jgoodwin977 what reason have you been given given in the last 12 months? Has a doctor said that the local or national policy is not to prescribe T3?

In fact, all national guidance does say a consultant can initiate a trial of T3 if you're still symptomatic on thyroxine and other causes have been ruled out, so it IS possible to get T3 on the NHS (albeit often not as easy as it should be)

Thyroid patient charities and groups have been fighting this hard since 2017 - it's extremely difficult, but we have made progress!

Jgoodwin977 profile image
Jgoodwin977 in reply to TaraJR

That’s what my GP said to me on Monday as he’d struggled to get it himself for another patient. He didn’t say why, he just said it’s impossible to get. So pleased you’ve made progress and can’t believe the amount of ignorance involved. What’s the plan next?

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR in reply to Jgoodwin977

I wonder if you could ask him the reason for it? As national guidance does say you can have a trial from an endo, if you're still symptomatic on thyroxine and other causes have been ruled out.

Jgoodwin977 profile image
Jgoodwin977 in reply to TaraJR

good to know, thank you. I will book in next week and ask and tell him. Unfortunately the criteria doesn’t apply to me, so I guess I’ll have to get it privately, but it may help his other patients.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Walking

Morning all,I'm just looking to see if anyone is or has been in the same boat regards walking....

Would love some advice

In the last 12 months I have been diagnosed with vitamin D ,iron and b12 deficiency and been...

To increase or not yet?

Morning,Just want to check what you all think. I'm trying to get from 75mcg levo - 100. Went...

Post TT blood results

This is my first tests since TT 7 weeks ago.I'm on 150mg levothyroxine Endo nurse will probably...

Eyebrows have started growing again : )

haven't posted in ages because of health issues but do read posts. Seeing private endo at the...