Liothyronine prescribing in England: costs vers... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,824 members161,646 posts

Liothyronine prescribing in England: costs versus need (and petition)

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK
11 Replies

A short but pertinent comment in The Lancet about costs of Liothyronine - note petition organiser Dr Peter Taylor is one of the signatories.

Liothyronine prescribing in England: costs versus need

Adrian Heald

Mike Stedman

Buchi Okosieme

Lakdasa Premawardhana

Peter Taylor

Colin Dayan

Published:November 14, 2023DOI:doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(...

Data for 1·7 million patients are reported in the 2022 primary care Quality and Outcomes Framework hypothyroidism register in England.1

In most cases these patients are treated with levothyroxine. However, some patients report benefit from adjunctive liothyronine or natural desiccated thyroid (NDT).

In 2021, we reported how large price increases for liothyronine over 2012–20 had caused a reduction in the prescription of liothyronine and suggested that NDT could be a cost-effective alternative treatment.2

An investigation was opened by the UK Competition and Market Authority (CMA) in October, 2016, into prices for liothyronine tablets. The investigation showed that from January, 2009, to July, 2017, the price paid by the UK National Health Service rose from £15 to £258 per prescription, a rise of 1605%. The outcome of the CMA investigation was made public on Dec 15, 2020, and the suppliers were fined over £101 million.3

The British Thyroid Association (BTA) recognises that a proportion of individuals have substantial dissatisfaction with levothyroxine and have published guidance on use of liothyronine.4

The guidance suggests that liothyronine can be prescribed if symptoms persist on levothyroxine, at a daily dose of 5–10 μg split twice a day.

We examined monthly primary care prescribing data for levothyroxine, NDT, and liothyronine by dose from 2016 to 2022 (appendix). The cost of levothyroxine fell from £2·74 per prescription in 2016 to £1·47 in 2022, a 48% reduction. Total annual prescriptions for levothyroxine increased by 9% from 30·8 million in 2016 to 33·4 million in 2022. The total primary care spending amount fell by 42% to £52 million per year from 2016 to 2022. The average cost of NDT in 2016 was £207 per prescription, and increased by 220% to £440 in 2022. Total annual prescriptions fell by 48% from 4257 in 2016 to 2384 in 2022, with total costs increasing to £1 million per year. Regarding liothyronine, in 2016, 94% of the total 74 500 prescriptions were the 20 μg dose. In 2020, the percentage of prescriptions written for 5 μg and 10 μg doses started to increase so that in 2022 each reached 27% of total liothyronine. The average cost of the 20 μg dose in 2016 was £404 per prescription and fell by 80% to £101 in 2022; the cost of the 10 μg dose was £348 per prescription in 2016 and fell by 35% to £255 in 2022. The 5 μg dose cost was £355 per prescription in 2016 and fell by 38% to £242 per prescription in 2022. 74 605 total prescriptions were issued for liothyronine in 2016—this figure fell 30% to 51 958 prescriptions in 2019, but has since risen 17% to 60 990 prescriptions in 2022. During this 7-year period, total costs have fallen by 70% to £9 million per year.

Liothyronine costs fell after the CMA ruling, but remain orders of magnitude higher than levothyroxine and the pre-increase levels of liothyronine. In 2022, liothyronine prescriptions made up only 0·2% of all hypothyroid medication prescriptions, but accounted for 14% of the total hypothyroid medication costs. Lower-dose liothyronine, as recommended by the BTA, is 240% higher than the cost of the 20 μg dose, so following the latest BTA guidance incurs substantial additional costs. High drug prices continue to affect clinical decision making for a considerable number of patients.

Paper and link to graph available here:

thelancet.com/journals/lanc...

Now please sign the petition organised by Dr Pete Taylor.

Dr Pete Taylor’s Fund Thyroid Research Petition 📣🔔🔊💬

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

Written by
helvella profile image
helvella
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
JGBH profile image
JGBH

I have already signed this petition. Fingers crossed…

Having problems again to access HU …. Am asked to sign in each time..

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to JGBH

I'm not aware of any problems - could it be your machine or settings?

JGBH profile image
JGBH in reply to helvella

Thank you. Will need to ask an IT person to check.

flosslechops profile image
flosslechops in reply to JGBH

this happens to mine after I've cleared browsing history-perhaps something similar?

JGBH profile image
JGBH in reply to flosslechops

Thank you for the suggestion. How do you restore the settings ? I had problem with Microsoft … they blocked my account after asking me several times to sign in. An IT person came to solve the problem but it has interfered with HU and Amazon accounts…. Rather a technophobe but will contact the IT person again,

flosslechops profile image
flosslechops in reply to JGBH

according to husband ,signing in is the computer making sure its you but I never sign in either! all to do with account management apparently , my management is waiting for him to sort it out😂

JGBH profile image
JGBH in reply to flosslechops

Well I used to be able to access HU without having to sign in each time. So there is a problem that needs to be solved by an IT person…

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to JGBH

If you have (inadvertently) switched off accepting cookies from HealthUnlocked, your browser cannot store the 'token' that HU send you.

But not really something that is easy to talk someone through. And that is just one of many possibilities.

JGBH profile image
JGBH in reply to helvella

Thank you for reaching out. Yes I have refused cookies… am fed up of all companies using my email address to send me offers of all sorts… having to delete many emails every day… so I now refuse cookies from everyone with the exception of essential cookies.

Of course being technophobe doesn’t help. However, I have accepted cookies before replying to you but still had to sign in. Arrr! 🥺

flosslechops profile image
flosslechops in reply to JGBH

after I've used clear browsing data its google that asks for signing in which I don't do and then HU wants signing in and then stays signed in until I use clear browsing data again so as helvella says it could be to do with cookies

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame

"Need" doesn't seem to compute when it comes to those of us who need a supraphysiological dose of T3.

a daily dose of 5–10 μg split twice a day....wouldn't even touch the sides!

Panic seems to be the default setting when medics are faced with this problem....

Let's not forget that thyroid disease is a life threatening condition - one that was almost dismissed by the GP who diagnosed me, after being pushed to test me - as just needing "this little white pill taken daily to make me feel well again". The wretched woman didn't know any better!

To treat us would cost the NHS a lot of money that appears to be needed instead for less "hidden" conditions....so patients who need this treatment, in extremis to survive, often remain hidden and suffering in silence with nowhere to go.

This forum helps provide that place but how many are fortunate enough to find it?

When I started my T3 journey over 6 years ago (and after 20 years on levo) there was a link to this TUK forum on the NHS Hypothyroidism page which led me here. Without that I would never have learned about T3....which has in all likelihood saved my life. That link has gone!

I've signed (and shared) the petition....we desperately need more research that medics might just pay attention to, because currently there seems to an epidemic of "closed minds and closed ears to T3" syndrome that has to change

PLEASE SIGN AND SHARE FOLKS!

You may also like...

Problem with the cost of Liothyronine.

charging £20 more per box than she can reclaim from the Government. Is this a result of the cost...

NOT a win after all? Changes to liothyronine (T3) prescribing...

scribed-in-primary-care-patient-leaflets/3747-patient-information-changes-to-liothyronine-prescribin

Response from my MP regarding prescribing of Liothyronine.

and unfair prices for supplying liothyronine tablets. The CMA fined the firms involved a total of...

Prescribing of Liothyronine.

and wondered if that is happening too as I suffer from chronic stress and have done pretty much all...

Liothyronine Costs 2012

nhs.uk/publications/prescribing/primary/pres-cost-anal-eng-2012/pres-cost-anal-eng-2012-apx.pdf...