We are all individuals and must be diagnosed as... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,246 members166,490 posts

We are all individuals and must be diagnosed as such

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering
12 Replies

This describes a finding from an as yet unpublished paper. For copyright's sake I will not disclose it until formal publication. It's findings are: For any individual you can plot changes of TSH and FT4 to get curves for each on a graph where they cross over. This crossover point is called the diagnosing sensitivity of FT4 and TSH responses to each other. However the work shows that thyroid and pituitary sensitivities are linked together in individuals in a non-random pattern. This linkage shows one cannot obtain the curves describing these sensitivities from population data and complicates their derivation by physiological experimentation. This limitation could be evolutionally important by minimising the variation inexpression by individuals in a population to facilitate better survival chances of the species.

In short you cannot use population data to describe an individual's response to T4 therapy and diagnose thereby. Even shorter, therefore it is the individual response that should be used in diagnosis, and NOT by reference to so-called population-derived ranges.

Written by
diogenes profile image
diogenes
Remembering
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
12 Replies
LindaC profile image
LindaC

Without doubt! Human variation is huge, which includes even within our own chemistry.

Musicmonkey profile image
Musicmonkey

So in that case, we each need to know where we are on the curve where our TSH meets our FT4? But what if we have a disjoint between these no's? On diagnosis my TSH was 2.9, but my T4 was below range. Presumably I would be given Levo according to this. But I have conversion issues, so how does this new information deal with that? Doesn't T3 come into the equation?

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering in reply toMusicmonkey

No, what's been found is that here is no way to diagnose patients by using the whole population range for FT4 and TSH. This goes for FT3 too. I wrote in another reply that high FT4 giving low FT3, as in conversion problems, should not result in doctors trying to get you to raise T4 so as to try to normalise FT3. It's got future health problems to do this, so combination therapy must be used to keep FT4 properly placed.

Humph. NICE: "Of course we support patient-centred medicine, but we can't be having all that individual nonsense, there has to be RULES - for everyone to obey!"

TSH110 profile image
TSH110

Excellent news - thanks for posting

Gingernut44 profile image
Gingernut44

Very interesting, thanks for posting - we’ll have to wait for the publication.

Lotika profile image
Lotika

That gives me hope… I keep telling friends and family - and anyone else who can’t get out of the way quick enough - that one day they will look back on this and realise that the treatment of thyroid patients at this moment in time is the equivalent to treating a fever with leaches. Maybe not in my lifetime, but one day…

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator in reply toLotika

Which treatment has had a bit of a comeback! Not necessarily for fevers, of course, but ...

10 stomachs, 32 brains and 18 testicles – a day inside the UK's only leech farm

They were once used to treat everything from headaches to strangulation, and leeches are still a vital part of surgery. But how are they farmed?

theguardian.com/lifeandstyl...

1tuppence profile image
1tuppence

Isn't that how they used to do things? My mother was diagnosed hypothyroid from her symptoms alone....and she was treated immediately.

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering in reply to1tuppence

Happy days!

Aurealis profile image
Aurealis

Wow, far reaching implications. Turns current practice on its head.

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR

linda96 MikeM46 a very interesting future publication.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

We have (mostly) supporters

This is a letter from Australian authors who have shown evidence that thyroid hormones are better...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

Another paper acknowledging deficiencies in using reference ranges as fixed for all patients

Here is another paper with interesting conclusions for those who don't get on ell using diagnosis...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

How much do TSH, FT3, and FT4 values change in healthy subjects?

This paper (behind a paywall) shows the ongoing biological variation in thyroid hormone...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

Short-term biological variation of serum thyroid hormones concentrations in clinically healthy cats.

As with humans, so with cats. At least as regards reference ranges for populations versus...
helvella profile image
Administrator

Abstract of New Paper - about optimizing diagnosis and treatment

We've just received notice that our review paper, which summarises the work we have been doing for...
diogenes profile image
Remembering