Why thyroid function tests are in such a mess! - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

144,087 members169,533 posts

Why thyroid function tests are in such a mess!

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering
3 Replies

This is an excerpt from an Italian scientist replying to me on the reasons why the various tests are not properly controlled by the companies selling them:

He describes the way the various groups don't communicate with each other and therefor have no interest in getting the tests harmonised:

Basing on my daily activity with both “pure” laboratory medicine specialists and “pure” clinicians I realized this “disinterest” comes from different and rarely communicating cultures and practices;

(1) some (or many) clinicians are not aware of laboratory problems and criticisms. They take results and reference ranges provided by laboratories and, in general, consider as “true” those results fitting their clinical impression/suspicious. In case of clinically unexpected results, however, they frequently label them as “laboratory errors” and retest (frequently in another laboratory).

(2) some (or many) laboratory medicine specialists embark, in front to inconsistent results, in time-consuming procedures when a phone call with the attending physician, asking some focused details, may frequently solve the conundrum reinforcing the relevant role of laboratory specialist in patients’ management, well beyond “numbers” production. (3) Rarely, clinical guidelines’ panels include laboratory medicinespecialistsand viceversa.I’malways concerned when clinical guidelines recommend a fixed cutoff as clinical yard-stick, without considering inter-assay variability and other analytical problems. On the other hand laboratory guidelines focus on analytical problems and emphasize limitations of available test but rarely provide practical input on how to survive with tests’ “imperfections” when faced with patients in daily practice.

Such issues are all relevant in the context of ongoing standardization initiatives but waiting for better and more consistent analytical results we need to optimize the, admittedly not so bad, currently available laboratory outputs to better survive and well serve our patients now. From the clinical point of view, using appropriate criteria when selecting clinical test is certainly useful to avoid most inconsistent “in vitro” results without clinical relevance. When multiple test (as thyrotropin and free-thyroid hormones) is required in the absence of relevant history and clinical picture, the first question is not “why this strange result?” but “why this inappropriate request?”.

Written by
diogenes profile image
diogenes
Remembering
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
3 Replies
LindaC profile image
LindaC

Exactly - Thank You - not only do 'they' not know, they don't even care to find out. 👀

vocalEK profile image
vocalEK

The phrase "confirmation bias" popped into my head when I read this.

LindaC profile image
LindaC in reply tovocalEK

For sure + inappropriate use of prejudicial heuristics + sheer ignorance. 👽

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

T4 works, I have it in writing, it must be true.....

Had this in writing on an email via a friend, who has asked advice (without my asking him to) from...
turquoisea7 profile image

Thyroid-Stimulating Hormone

Why Efforts to Harmonize Testing Are Critical to Patient Care I had added this to another post...
PR4NOW profile image

Medichecks ferritin results and ranges

Hi all. I don't have a thyroid issue (this has been ruled out), but someone on the PAS forum...
KBird01 profile image

Thyroid cancer, hypothyroidism and kidney function

Hello, I’m usually on the pernicious anaemia forum but I’ve been recovering from a diagnostic...

Was i Hypothyroid or did i have euthyroid sick syndrome.

Hi again still trying to work out this thyroid stuff. This article...
Angelic69 profile image

Moderation team

See all
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
Buddy195 profile image
Buddy195Administrator
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.