New(ish) discussion paper by Bianco et al - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,243 members166,489 posts

New(ish) discussion paper by Bianco et al

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering
10 Replies

An editorial type paper has been issued by Orgiazzi J, Peterson SJ , McAninch EA, Bianco AC. for open access till November 30. Title: Does normal TSH mean euthyroidism in L-T4 treatment? Source Clinical Thyroidology, 2016: 28 (11) 325-328. though it is 1 year old, it does raise questions re the value of TSH in T4 treatment. And also does include a paper of ours as reference.

Written by
diogenes profile image
diogenes
Remembering
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
10 Replies
Nanaedake profile image
Nanaedake

Have you got a link to the paper?

RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator in reply toNanaedake

I think this is it online.liebertpub.com/doi/f...

linda96 profile image
linda96

Not sure about this paper Diogenes. Despite the Dio2 gene polymorphism being known about since the late 1970's its not mentioned once in this paper. I cannot believe they didn't check their patient cohort to see if they were converts or non-converters, surely all the data gathered is meaningless if no account is made of this gene polymorphism? I won't be adding it to my collection of other thyroid clinical papers. Dr Bianco has published widely about DIO2, and not to mention it seems almost a step backwards... I take particular offence to the phrase "Several possible reasons for the persistence of symptoms include thyroid autoimmunity itself, the possible presence of associated autoimmune diseases, and ...awareness of a chronic disease (3) !!! Somatatisation again! I'm sure I've read that line almost word for word somewhere else?

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply tolinda96

How you manage to translate 'awareness of a chronic disease' into 'somatisation'? 'Awareness' isn't the same as 'imagination', surely? Or, am I being thick?

linda96 profile image
linda96 in reply togreygoose

Hi, Greygoose,

I have come across 'awareness of a chronic disease' before in another medical context and it was explained to me that it meant 'knowing you were ill, could make you sicker'. I agree with you that 'awareness' is not the same as 'imagination' although I think imagination might be the wrong word to have used here. I have argued elsewhere recently that we need to be aware of how our bodies perform under stress situations so that we can be ready to alert those around us to possible changes of plans, needing to visit a Dr urgently, etc and that being 'aware' is generally a good thing. I think 'awareness of a chronic disease' is itself worded badly as it could be interpreted differently depending on who is reading it.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply tolinda96

I have a raging fever. 'Imagination' was the best word I could come up with. It didn't please me, either.

But, I really do think you're reading too much into this. I don't think somatisation is at all what they were talking about.

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering in reply tolinda96

There are all sorts of reasons why some patients need T3 to attain a good QoL. Not just D102 mutation. There are three interlocking problems; 1) how sensitive are the tissues to T3 - that is what level of FT3 does a patient need when healthy to maintain health? There is a factor of 2 from one extreme to the other. 2) how well does T4 get converted to T3 by the tissue enzymes? This is mutational probably. 3) How does direct supply of T3 by the thyroid interact with 1) and 2); in health how much thyroid T3 is needed to help the other processes, and if it is lost, how does the body respond to T4 only? Bianco's article only touchesd on this but it is the problem that needs solving.

linda96 profile image
linda96 in reply todiogenes

I would agree with you that Dr AC Bianco has only touched on it. Perhaps I am a little disappointed because having read some of his articles I want so much more from these clinical papers having spent a lifetime of being ill, (but not just with hypothyroidism) although it is very high on my list of priorities. I am a great admirer of Dr AC Bianco and I must say I like his apparent dogged determination to get to the bottom of our thyroid problems. I have re-read the paper again and he does make a passing nod to T4 - T3 conversion problems, in the Background paragraph. As he says towards the end of Analysis and Commentary " The present study in itself does not appear to help dissect the mechanisms involved in the deviation from normalcy that persists in L-T4 treated subjects despite normal TSH. ...lack of information on the previous values of the thyroid function tests and the cause of the hypothyroidism".

If you add in the extra parameters of converters and non-converters, thyroid transport problems, methylation polymorphisms, the individual's H-T-P axis points, and as he said, not having access to previous test results, I'm not sure that he will find an answer. Not yet anyway. I hope he does. I like Prof Hoermann's papers too, they both seem to be working very hard to find the answers.

Nanaedake profile image
Nanaedake in reply tolinda96

I'm sure Dio2 is mentioned towards the end of the document isn't it?

SilverAvocado profile image
SilverAvocado

There is a tiny mention at the end, almost the final line: "Finally, further work is needed to better identify and characterize the patients with poor T4-to-T3 conversion efficiency, including studies of the impact of genetic variation in the deiodinase"

This is part of a brief discussion saying this paper isn't addressing these mechanisms.

For patients this is a bit of a strange paper, as it's kind of repeating what we already know - T4-only patients feel worse than other people, and you can find that on some biological and self-report measures when you look at a large population. But its useful because it's formalising and putting into the right language what we are always saying ;)

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Reply to queries on paper by Bianco et al

This is a reply to a group querying the validity of Bianco et al's paper on T4/T3 prefrence by some...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

Bianco et al paper on DTE (NDT) and comibnation therapy

This recent paper discusses the use of DTE (NDT) and T4/T3 comibnation therapy Thyroid© ...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

New paper - encouraging progress

Here is a short paper by Bianco and coworkers where our group is also mentioned. It questions the...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

New Paper

Still seem to have a problem posting but to repeat: we now have our paper on T4-T3 conversion and...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

New paper

We've had another paper accepted by the European Thyroid Journal which will be published shortly....
diogenes profile image
Remembering

Moderation team

See all
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.