Interesting article that could possibly (?) und... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

140,280 members164,990 posts

Interesting article that could possibly (?) underline the fact why TSH isnt the best measure of thyroid function

Justiina profile image
4 Replies

I cant understand all scientific jibberjabber jargon, but reading this article and references , i get the idea that thyroglobulin can overcome TSH which would explain why TSH only is a poor marker of thyroid function. Correct me If i am wrong!

hindawi.com/journals/aen/20...

Written by
Justiina profile image
Justiina
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
4 Replies
helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK

It certainly suggests that thyroglobulin is a very powerful influence - but leaves it a bit open how the whole story runs. Thank you.

Good to remember that even TSH isn't all the same! There are different glycosylation states for it - but testing just measures "TSH". No-one really seems to care about this - but I am convinced it is important in some way.

If you really want to stir things up, have a read through some of these papers about thyrostimulin. (Please don't assume I have read them all! Just managed to get started on a couple and am having a mental storm trying to take in all the consequences. :-) )

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?te...

Justiina profile image
Justiina in reply to helvella

Thanks for the link, looks interesting indeed.

Yeah, more research is needed, but was interesting that TG has that type of role. But it shows how complex thyroid function can be it's not fully know or understood and still it's called easy to fix!

Justiina profile image
Justiina in reply to helvella

Been reading that stuff a bit and indeed it's interesting! In the end there are several factors affecting TSH levels making it very unreliable to measure the wellbeing of one.

From somewhere else I read that it's mistakenly considered the golden standard because it's one of those things you can measure that accurately so it has lead to false idea of it being good marker of thyroid status.

And as we know it tells how hypothalamus pituitary axis is functioning. If one's brain is satisfied with less T3 their TSH would never rise very high as the demand of brain tissue was achieved with less effort leaving the rest of the body very deficient?

And if in some cases high TSH causes swelling of pituitary wouldn't that compromise the function of pituitary same way than tumour and could result in similar situation than in secondary where other hormones could be compromised too? So that would partially explain low cortisol which would then bounce back when TSH is lowered as swelling of pituitary would reduce as well.

Lots of ifs and buts!

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Justiina

Certainly the technology that allowed us to measure TSH as accurately as we now can is pretty amazing. Yes - ability to measure something seems to grant it the role of being a good indicator - even if it is anything but.

The fact that we are still having to ask whether macro-TSH (TSH plus an antibody to TSH) has been checked when we see discordant high TSH results throws in a big question mark. As does the variability for uncertain reasons between the various assay techniques.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Why measure TSH when you have no thyroid.

Does anyone know what is the point of measuring TSH if you have no thyroid? (As a result of a...

Interesting article: mild TSH suppression gives closest to normal thyroid function in levothyroxine monotherapy for this group

Ito et al (2017) Biochemical Markers Reflecting Thyroid Function in Athyreotic Patients on...

Isn’t tsh the best indicator of thyroid hormone replacement due to TT

I am bit confused, as I see that most of people on this forum don’t rely on tsh alone, but my...

Another study on Thyroid function and Heart Failure that relies on TSH only

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33115640/ Relation Between Thyroid Function and Mortality in...

New Research Shows TSH Test an Unreliable Test of Thyroid Function - Press Release

Up to 15 percent of all hypothyroid patients on levothyroxine only treatment have a reduced quality...