A good paper on the progress of T3-only patient... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,245 members166,495 posts

A good paper on the progress of T3-only patients and no extra AF or osteoporosis compared with normals.

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering
9 Replies

A paper by Dr G Leese has appeared in Clinical Endocrinology. This shows that for 400 patients on T3 only for 17 years followup there was no increase in AF or osteoporosis compared with normals and no increase in statin use. Louise Warvill has the paper in full if you want to download it. The paper's site if anyone can download direct is: Graham P Leese, Enrique Solo-Pedre, Louise A Donnelly

Clinical Endocrinology: Accepted manuscript online: 4 March 2016

DOI: 10.1111/cen.13052

Rather makes a nonsense of many other papers on the risks of AF and OP when T3 is used even in conjunction with T4.

Written by
diogenes profile image
diogenes
Remembering
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
9 Replies
HarryE profile image
HarryE

Is this the same Graham Leese that made a fool of himself in the Scottish Parliament recently?

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering in reply toHarryE

It most certainly is. I felt he behaved there like a "timid rebel". That is, he had this info which went against traditional beliefs but was too scared to bring it out in the open for fear of offending the great and good. So therefore, he came out very badly as a person who couldn't make a decisive answer to anything.

HarryE profile image
HarryE in reply todiogenes

That's exactly how he came out!

in reply toHarryE

Ammunition for Lorraine surely??!!

SmallBlueThing profile image
SmallBlueThing

Doesn't the risk of atrial fibrillation increase with free T4, giving another argument for substituting some T3?

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering in reply toSmallBlueThing

The studies on increased risks of AF and OP are all fatally compromised because 1) FT3 was often never done so we don't know if some were indeed overdosed, and 2) we now know that people have varying abilities to convert T4 to T3 from the really very good, through the average, to the poor. As all studies mixed these up, we don't know if the really good converters were those who were at greatest risk of overdosing and thus contributed overmuch to the overall outcome. I think all these studies can be tipped into the scientific dustbin as inadequate and unproven.

humanbean profile image
humanbean

Helvella wrote a post about this paper a few days ago :

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering in reply tohumanbean

I don't have anything on my site since the publication of this full paper on March 4th. Perhaps you are referring to an earlier precis paper he put out before this more formal effort.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

This is interesting. I haven't got the full paper yet. Some purely academic comments:-

One would expect L-T4 to be a little safer than L-T3 due to the regulatory role of deiodinase and more stable hormone levels.

It's reasonable to expect patients receiving L-T3 to be more severly hypothyroid (more difficult patients) and this might be why there was an increased incident use of antipsychotic medication. Also, L-T3 is known to help some patients who are refractory to anti-depressants and so may have been prescribed for this purpose.

My guess is that the lower hazard ratios for atrial fibrillation and fractures was because (presumably) more attention was paid to signs and symptoms rather than blood tests (the L-T3 patients had LOWER TSH values). This confirms that signs and symptoms are more relevant than blood tests.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Stomach churning UK paper

This paper might well stretch your digestive system. This paper by Leese encapsulates what is...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

The intellectual gulf between our work and the UK status quo merchants

This opinion by Leese is a shocker to me in how he remains completely bewildered by the fact that...
diogenes profile image
Remembering

Frontiers in Endocrinology paper: 'Higher Prevalence of “Low T3 Syndrome” in Patients With Chronic Fatigue Syndrome' advocates T3 trials

This is potentially a breakthrough paper, published in Frontiers in Endocrinology in March 2018....
AmandaK profile image

This paper shows no effect of low TSH on fractures, mortality or AF

I might have already posted this but if not, it's useful to publicise. This paper shows low TSH has...
diogenes profile image
Remembering