Pet VS CT: Hello pretty ladies ๐ŸŒบ I... - SHARE Metastatic ...

SHARE Metastatic Breast Cancer

6,808 membersโ€ข8,425 posts

Pet VS CT

Maludagui profile image
Maludagui
โ€ข18 Replies

Hello pretty ladies ๐ŸŒบ I hope you are well. Thank God I have felt fine, only with some momentary pains in different parts of the body but not limiting. In October I have to do a control PET scan as I have done since my diagnosis every 6 months. Well now my insurance says verbatim: that they DO NOT approve this procedure as it is considered unnecessary. My doctor now says: ok, we'll do a CT scan and a BONE scan. This has made me very nervous since I thought that the PET scan was the best technology to know early if the cancer appears in a new place.

What is your experience ???

And, how is it possible that the insurance decides what is better for me than what the Dr. requests ??? I do not understand

Thank you for reading my post and clarifying my doubts

Written by
Maludagui profile image
Maludagui
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
18 Replies
โ€ข
Zebra2018 profile image
Zebra2018

I have MBC since July of 2018 and I have done pet scan only once on November of 2018!my onc says some times you get false result from pet scan. I did bone scan last week and I am scheduled to do MRI and CT next month

Maludagui profile image
Maludaguiโ€ข in reply toZebra2018

Ok thank you โค๏ธ

Maludagui profile image
Maludaguiโ€ข in reply toZebra2018

Oh one more question. The CT scan can see cancer in the organs ?

Zebra2018 profile image
Zebra2018โ€ข in reply toMaludagui

Yes

Gaily71 profile image
Gaily71

I get a ct scan every 3 months and a bone scan. Yes with contrast the ct can see the organs. The bone scan has less radiation so that is better for you.

Maludagui profile image
Maludaguiโ€ข in reply toGaily71

Wao. Thanks ๐Ÿ™

KMBL_ profile image
KMBL_

I have lobular in my stomach and throughout my whole spine from top to bottom. Multiple PET scans and CTs have not shown it anywhere. Only MRI works for me. I just wanted to let you know lobular does not show up in some types of scans.

Maludagui profile image
Maludaguiโ€ข in reply toKMBL_

Oh my God. ๐Ÿ™

diamags profile image
diamags

I've been on this journey for seven years and have never had a PET scan. Bone scan and CT every 4 months.

โ€ข in reply todiamags

Same with me . Bone Scan & CT Scan every 3-4 months

hopefulinadks profile image
hopefulinadks

My insurance denied my PET scan as well and I had a CT and bone scan. The CT scan with contrast showed organs . My concern is that it did not include my brain as the PET would have and the bone scan showed a lesion on my skull. The insurance companies do not care about your health and in my experience will deny everything that they can. I have appealed in the past and won the case one time and lost one time and had to foot the bill. One good thing that I have noticed about MSK in comparison to other doctors and hospitals is that they give you the tests that they deem necessary and appeal after. I find that they have in some instances absorbed the costs when they loose the appeal. Other hospitals seek approval first and in my experience most of the time ,the insurance company deems PET scans as medically unnecessary. It's not worth getting angry about because it's just business and insurance companies are in the business of making money not saving lives. Hard truth.

Maludagui profile image
Maludaguiโ€ข in reply tohopefulinadks

I agree โ˜๏ธ

SMPG profile image
SMPG

What doctor and hospital do you go to? I had the same experience. But I cannot have CT scan because I am allergic to the contrast substance. So, I insisted for the PET scan and my doctors insisted as well, we appealed, contested and they finally approved. Good luck to you!

Maludagui profile image
Maludaguiโ€ข in reply toSMPG

I am in Houston. I go to Memorial Hermann Cancer Center

hdhonda profile image
hdhonda

My doctors like cat scans for routine scans. PET are only used if they believe the cancer has moved somewhere else. They can get a better view on Cat Scans or MRI's. I see a doctor locally and I see one at a major cancer center twice a year. It is my understanding that they cannot get a good comparison between a CAT and a PET. Hope this helps. Wishing you the best. Blessings Hannah

mariootsi profile image
mariootsi

You are right about why is it possible for insurance companies to have a say. But with the CT and bone scan you should be covered in terms of its reliable results.

Kimr2081 profile image
Kimr2081

The insurance company denied my PET scan but approved a bone scan, CT scan of chest and MRI of abdomine Go figure. Makes no sense to me.

Maludagui profile image
Maludagui

Ok ๐Ÿ‘ thank you

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Bone scan vs. PET scan

Hi everyone, I was diagnosed with MBC a little over 2 years ago, and have been on...
michelangelina profile image
โ€ข

PET scans to CT scans

Hi! I moved recently which of course means new oncologist โ€” I have been NED with bone only Mets...
TwithBC profile image
โ€ข

How often should I do PET scan?

Hello everyone, I have stage 4 metastatic breast cancer (ER,PR+, HER2-). I have been taking...
hopeoflife profile image
โ€ข

Pet and bone scan results

Good morning pretty ladies. Today I received a bone scan result Says everything is stable and there...
Maludagui profile image
โ€ข

PET scan results :(

hi everyone- my dads pet scan results were just posted on the portal. Wasnโ€™t exactly what we wanted...
Jenniferp2122 profile image
โ€ข

Moderation team

See all
Jslanovich profile image
JslanovichAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.