Top Dr.s for LDR brachytherapy or SBRT - Prostate Cancer N...

Prostate Cancer Network

5,258 members3,324 posts

Top Dr.s for LDR brachytherapy or SBRT

MauiJef profile image
13 Replies

Hello everyone,

I got my results on 2/28/23 , 3+4 in 3 areas. I've consulted with Dr. Dorff at City of Hope and she recommended surgery over radiation, her preference with prostate cancer. She recommended Dr. Lau if I go the surgery route.

I met with Dr. Kishan at UCLA, when they had MRIdian, and he thought I'd be a good candidate with either SBRT or surgery. They all agreed I can do AS so that's what I've been doing, until this week. I had another PSA and I j umped from 3.97 to 6.2 and my Dr. thinks it's time to make a decision.

I'm leaning towards either LDR brachy or SBRT. I was hoping for help in finding the top Dr's in these areas. I'm in So Cal but can travel. Trying to find someone with a tremendous amount of work, and success, under their belt has been tough.

Beside Dr. Kishan, is there anyone else I should consider for SBRT?

For brachy, I've come across Dr. Steven Kurtzman and Dr. Ankit Agarwal from western radiation oncology, that look good, but can't find anyone to talk to that have used them.

Has anyone had brachy from UCLA or City of Hope and can recommend someone there?

I truly appreciate any and all suggestions.

Have a great day. Apologies for rambling, but I was hoping I could be on AS for longer than this and it's been a gut punch , again.

Written by
MauiJef profile image
MauiJef
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
13 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

I love Tanya Dorff but she has no specific expertise in either surgery or radiation.

Amar Kishan now has Viewray MRIdian operational again.

IDK why you prefer LDR Brachy to HDR Brachy? HDR has fewer side effects. Mitch Kamrava at Cedars-Sinai is my preference if you want HDR-BT.

Tim Wilson at St. Johns would be my choice for prostatectomy.

leach234 profile image
leach234 in reply toTall_Allen

Dr. Thomas Ahlering and Dr. David Lee at UCI (if you live in Orange County) and Dr. Robert Reiter at UCLA are excellent robotic surgeons. Dr. Tim Wilson is good too.

MauiJef profile image
MauiJef in reply toleach234

Thank you

Seat15c profile image
Seat15c in reply toTall_Allen

I thought HDBT was for high risk and had more side effects? Source was interview from PCRI

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply toSeat15c

Nope. Don't believe everything you hear at PCRI- when their peers aren't there to challenge them, doctors will say anything to patients.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/147...

prostatecancer.news/2016/08...

Seat15c profile image
Seat15c in reply toTall_Allen

Thank you wow HDRBT sounds like a great option!

MauiJef profile image
MauiJef in reply toTall_Allen

Tall_Allen appreciate your feedback. I thought HDR was for advanced PC, so I need to look into that as well. Thank you

mchale profile image
mchale

my two cents go with Dr. Kishan Mridian MRI guided radiation, real time Imaging and gating that shuts down radiation when the target goes out of margin set points. The target area +2 mm margin MRI guided versus CT guided is +4 mm margin much less side effects. Look up the MIRAGE trial WITH DR. KISHAN

MauiJef profile image
MauiJef in reply tomchale

Appreciate your input....

PopCubby profile image
PopCubby

I had somewhat similar diagnosis as you, but was 70 when first diagnosed, and am on the East coast. I was on AS for 3 years when my PSA jumped from just over 4 to close to 7. Had another biopsy and was initially Gleeson 8, and seriously considered surgery. Went to Hopkins, Penn, and Fox Chase in Philly. Hopkins and Fox Chase reread my slides and concluded I was really Gleeson 7, not 8 so I started looking into radiation.

I decided on 2 treatments of HDR Brachytherapy a week apart at Fox Chase. It's coming up on 3 years and my last PSA was undetectable. I did not do any ADT.

I am happy with my decision. Side effects are minimal. Fox Chase no longer does LDR Brachytherapy. Not sure why that is. My Dr. was Eric Horwitz. He suggested SBRT as an alternate, but said he favored the HDR Brachytherapy so I went with it.

Good luck on your decision.

MauiJef profile image
MauiJef in reply toPopCubby

Pop, thank you for your advice and I'm glad that you're doing well...

SonomaGuy profile image
SonomaGuy

I"m curious about your rate of increase on the PSA? Was it a year? 2, 3, 4? That is something to consider. 6.2 is not that high. Also, I've been on AS for 4 years and the lead PC doctor at UCSF said to me he doesn't worry about PSA until it hits 10. Before radical treatment, I would have another MRI and/or biopsy.

MauiJef profile image
MauiJef

Sonoma,

My PSA rise

9/2020 3.4

9/2022 4.91

10/2022 5.7

7/2023. 5.28

2/2024 4.91

9/2024 6.2

I have another PSA this Friday as my last one I didn't refrain from cycling or sex prior to the test so we are retesting Friday just to see if that last one was a blip.....

My Dr. isn't saying I need to do something ASAP but he is concerned....

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

New to this forum: SBRT or Brachy to minimize chance of ED?

I recently entered the realm of unfavorable intermediate risk PCa after nearly 3 years on Active...
golfbiker profile image

UCLA/UCSF Doctors for initial treatment – SBRT or Surgery

I have a consult scheduled with Dr Amar Kishan for SBRT and looking for other RO recommendations...
climb4blue profile image

hernia surgery & SBRT

2023 just keeps getting better… May have to have hernia surgery. I have Sbrt at Ucla scheduled...
BL2023 profile image

RALP or Radiation????

Hello everyone, I've been visiting this site and others trying to figure out what treatment I want,...
MauiJef profile image

How reliable is the MiraDX prostox test?

My MiraDX test came back high risk after taking for possible sbrt treatment at UCLA. Dr. Kishan...
Riku100 profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.