we believed stars were permanent - Positive Wellbein...

Positive Wellbeing During Self-Isolation

9,738 posts

we believed stars were permanent

4woody profile image
8 Replies

Stars and blossoming fruit-trees: utter permanence and extreme fragility give an equal sense of eternity.

SIMONE WEIL

1909-1943

Written by
4woody profile image
4woody
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

8 Replies
pigeonCl-HU profile image
pigeonCl-HU

Only problem with this beautiful phrase is that stars are not permanent either: they are born, shine shine shine, then they explode in a glorious supernova, and die.

But to us, mere specks, they seem Eternal.

There is however beauty in this phrase, as trees will blossom again every Spring, and stars will be reborn, out of the dust and debris of supernovas.

This whole cycle of birth death and rebirth, is indeed, Eternal, and uplifting.

Sorry Woody...this shielding business tends to affect me this way....but thank you for that lovely quote.

Stay safe,

pigeon.

4woody profile image
4woody in reply to pigeonCl-HU

so I'm wondering if you read the title of the post. I'm glad you can appreciate the beauty of the thought. it just struck me when I read it that we can be so sure of our facts. Until time teaches us to change what we believe. That's why I added the year of the authors death to the post.

pigeonCl-HU profile image
pigeonCl-HU in reply to 4woody

Yes woody, of course I read the title, we "believed".....

And yes, time and experience, are sometimes cruel teachers.

We become jaded.

But then as I have noted, the cycle itself is, indeed, Eternal; therein lies the beauty of this phrase.

pigeon.

4woody profile image
4woody in reply to pigeonCl-HU

forgive me , your first sentence suggested that i was unaware that stars are not eternal. why do you characterize time and experience as ‘sometimes cruel teachers’?

pigeonCl-HU profile image
pigeonCl-HU in reply to 4woody

woody woody woody, I do not characterize time and experience as always being cruel teachers, where did you get this notion from?

I did say 'sometimes', didn't I?

Have you heard about the school of hard knocks?......

Some folks are graduates of this school. They have learned their lesson the hard way.

stay safe,

pigeon.

4woody profile image
4woody in reply to pigeonCl-HU

pigeon, pigeon, pigeon, I simply quoted you... I did not say always. So, hard knocks are sometimes cruel... I am also a graduate, so what?

I found it and google fr:

Etoiles et fruits en fleurs :

une permanence totale et une fragilite extreme

donnent un sens egual de l'eternite.

simone weil

I found it and google fr:

Etoiles et fruits en fleurs :

une permanence totale et une fragilite extreme

donnent un sens egual de l'eternite.

simone weil

Stars and blossoming fruit-trees: utter permanence and extreme fragility give an equal sense of eternity.

SIMONE WEIL

1909-1943t

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

You may also like...

Tuners (aka WBF Morning Star)

Thanks Jerry, They Were Delicious! :-)

We Are All In This Together

the ground on which we stand...

HAPPY EARTH DAY! Where were you on the very first Earth Day?

would listen, planting trees in Oregon and Washington (in fact I have planted a tree or two where...