Methotrexate GCA not effective unless started early - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

21,320 members40,426 posts

Methotrexate GCA not effective unless started early

gtate1914 profile image
18 Replies

Can anyone tell me where Dr. Baskhar Dasgupta, gives his opinion on this subject that methotrexate is not effective for GCA unless started in first month? Am searching for it but have not found it yet. Thanks.

Written by
gtate1914 profile image
gtate1914
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
18 Replies
HeronNS profile image
HeronNS

I can't find it either, but he suggests early introduction of mtx to enable a faster reduction from the very high dose of pred GCA requires. Found that opinion in a number of places.

rheumatology.org/Portals/0/...

gtate1914 profile image
gtate1914 in reply toHeronNS

I stopped because of numerous side effects, don't want to go back on it. Rheumy is not happy, wants me back on it. I think I would rather take my chances without it.

I was trying to find where Dr. Baskhar Dasgupta felt it was not useful for gca unless started early.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply togtate1914

What's your pred dose now? I got the impression from what I did find the reason for the early introduction was to try to avoid staying too long at the very high doses because the pred side effects are quite serious at that level. I expect the experts will know.

gtate1914 profile image
gtate1914 in reply toHeronNS

45mg. Been too long at high dose because I did not understand how to tell difference between withdrawal symptoms and flare symptoms. Pred has taken hard toll on me. But I’m still not convinced mtx is for me. Hard decisions.

Sallyaches profile image
Sallyaches in reply togtate1914

I took methotrexate for about 18 months asa steroid sparer. I am now taking Azothiopine which for me is a better drug as it has fewer side effects and is in tablet form. Do you feel able to suggest that it’s not the steroid sparer you are opposed to but Methotrexate? You could say you had heard of someone taking Azathiopine instead. I am now down to 3mg but it has been a long struggle, also I have PMR and not GCA.

Best wishes

bunnymom profile image
bunnymom in reply togtate1914

I don't think medical community does a good job educating about steroid withdraw.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply tobunnymom

It's because they don't know about it - they can't tell the difference and tell the patient to go back up unnecessarily...

Mstiles profile image
Mstiles in reply togtate1914

Hi gtate,

That was my experience too, (too long on the high dose because of not being able to tell the difference and a rheumy that didn’t listen). It’s so disheartening to have to struggle with your doctor.

Hope things get better for you soon!

gtate1914 profile image
gtate1914 in reply toMstiles

I agree. And also I think another drug added is not always a good idea, especially if its value is questionable and not to mention the horrid side effects. Maybe they work ok for some, but I try to find a more natural way .... example, instead of PPIs I drink kefir, homemade, protects my stomach. And has calcium and vitamins to boot.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toHeronNS

I don't think that there is significant evidence that methotrexate actually makes much difference in the early days in particular - it can take months to start to take effect so it isn't going to make a difference at the point you would want to reduce high doses. But it does seem to work better (and all things are relative after all) when it is introduced right from the start - and no, I can't find the reference either!

gtate1914 profile image
gtate1914 in reply toPMRpro

That’s the same conclusion I’ve come to.

Telian profile image
Telian in reply toPMRpro

Professor says he prefers Leflunomide to mtx as, in his opinion, mtx doesn't always work. He does use both as it works for some but whichever he uses he says it has to be started early in the illness.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toTelian

I wish I could find where Prof D says that - there is a video somewhere on the forum where it is quoted but I have no idea where. He used leflunomide in a study and it looked really promising. My rheumy sees it the other way round, says he has had good experiences with mtx...

gtate1914 profile image
gtate1914 in reply toPMRpro

So much conflicting information. I will continue to look for the video also. I'm 5 1/2 months into my treatment for GCA and PMR, had it a couple months without knowing. Tapering has been so difficult. Did not know how to do so in the beginning and it was too fast. Still learning. Currently day 5 AGAIN at 45mg. and going down by 2.5mg. Feels like I'm having some pred withdrawals last couple of days. So discouraging. I did not feel MTX was helping, only giving more side effects.

Thanks

Telian profile image
Telian in reply toPMRpro

I haven't seen a video, he told us at the Rettondon Meet earlier this year. I'll see if I can find it...

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

If mtx causes side effects for you - then it isn't for you.

The current evidence is that mtx has only modest benefits - so if it makes you feel worse, what is the point?

gtate1914 profile image
gtate1914 in reply toPMRpro

Agree. I'm glad it works for some.

Linny3 profile image
Linny3 in reply togtate1914

I am not sure if the Methotrexate worked for me. I was able to get down to 6mg pred. from 20mg in about a 1yr. time. I started the methotrexate from the day I was diagnosed. Unfortunately, I had a major flare and have been struggling ever since, that was in 2017. This year I took myself off of the methotrexate. I decided enough was enough. When I finally told my dr. she said ok but wanted to put me on another drug, Plaquenil. Not sure I am going on that as it can cause problem with the eyes. I decided to try taking my meds differently and try to taper the pred. myself with the help of all the info on this site. Thank God for this site. I have learned so much. I am going to give myself 6 months and see how it goes. If I can't seem to get anywhere with tapering, I might go on the other drug. This is the best I have felt since being diagnosed in 2016. So that gives me hope.

Take Care

Lin

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

GCA early signs , not sure

Hi all Have PMR 6 months now on prednisone 6 mg.. still have some pain on 6 mg but it’s manageable....
Leilagirl profile image

Methotrexate for GCA

Does anyone take methotrexate for GCA? I was on prednisone for 2 1/2 years. My new Dr. wanted me...
bonnielm1 profile image

Started Methotrexate

I feel like I'm in limbo. I had my first appointment with a rheumatologist mid-January. She's...
testadura profile image

GCA- Methotrexate

Hi I’ve been on prednisone since October 2023 for GCA. The last four weeks I’ve been prescribed...
Qscrabble8 profile image

Early GCA symptoms?

Hi all, first post on here but have watched from a distance for last couple of years and have...
Ccuf profile image

Moderation team

SophieMB profile image
SophieMBPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.