Nay sayers: I am passionate about... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

32,396 members23,645 posts

Nay sayers

Ipsofacto01 profile image
48 Replies

I am passionate about spreading the word about B12 deficiency. Being diagnosed and treated has transformed my life.

I met with an old friend the other day who has recently been put on antidepressants. She also mentioned she is deficient in B12 amongst other things. I took my chance to bang on about B12 but her eyes glazed over and you could tell she thought I was talking twaddle.

I find this a lot, not only do Doctors not take it seriously but a lot of potential patients too. I find it so frustrating.

Anyone else?

Written by
Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
48 Replies

You really do see it everywhere! I had some old friends over last night, on their way through to see a specialist in another state. Husband was suffering from suspected POTS but didn’t quite fit all the symptoms.

So of course, I’m there like “B12!!!!!”

Thankfully his wife is putting it on their list to check - they normally live in Cambodia where health is a private system so you can request (and pay) for any test you want.

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to PlatypusProfit8077

One really hopes that if they mention B12, that it is taken seriously. I was in. Neurology appointment with one of my children recently and asked if B12 may be a factor. He said no not at all, B12 deficiency just makes you a bit tired. She was diagnosed with hemiplegic migraine and put on long term meds. I have since found out that B12 deficiency is a major cause of migraine. My daughter won't listen either 😔

PlatypusProfit8077 profile image
PlatypusProfit8077 in reply to Ipsofacto01

What is with neurology and dismissing B12??? I asked mine about it and he scoffed and said “B12?? Why would I know about B12? I look at very serious things.”

Needless to say, I have changed neuros and meet with my new one on Monday (I’m very excited - I contacted him at his university email asking about brain lesions and B12, quoting some recent studies. He replied and later offered to take me on as a patient. !!!! Worlds apart!

Lin602 profile image
Lin602 in reply to Ipsofacto01

I suffered from migraines for 20 years, during that time I was taking oral B12. When I started B12 injections they miraculously stopped. Haven't had one since.

topazrat profile image
topazrat

Yep, My Mum and Dad both also had P.A. My eldest brother is showing symptoms, but no matter what I say, he's not having it. He'd rather take the antidepressant sweeties that the Doctor doles out and sit in his chair and slowly die 😢

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to topazrat

Oh no,that must be so hard for you to watch. I'm sorry 😔

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan

Yes its very frustrating. My neighbours saw how ill I was.

Well saw me recovering on practising walking in the garden.

Apart entry it will never affect them ad they have s good diet !!!

No words after lengthy explanation.

I'd given them my low dose B12 tablets as no good for me .

They were returned after initially accepting them.

Both 50+ + 60+

No not everything is B12 .

We are aware if that

Best to get tested though if symptoms thete or even better .

'Nip it in the bud '

If absorbtiin slowed !

I've a horrible feeling so many have and will suffer with a wrong diagnosis .

Let's keep banging the drum.

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to Nackapan

Yes Nackapan definitely keep banging the drum but do demoralising at the number of people who want to hear it. I have to admit, sometimes I do just bite my lip and keep quiet now but my friend isn't being treated for her B12 deficiency and has a little one so I really wanted her to try and see.

Dandelions profile image
Dandelions in reply to Ipsofacto01

When your ill, you get so much unsolicited advice. And a lot of it can be along the lines of ‘I just did this and now I feel great; it even treats cancer. ‘ It gets really tiresome.

B12 would have sounded to me exactly like one of those quack treatments someone is making money off, taking advantage of the desperation of patients.

It might even sound as dismissive to her depressive feelings.

But at least she knows now about B12 and maybe she’ll come to talk to you about it later in her life.

Narwhal10 profile image
Narwhal10

Yes, Ipsofacto01,

You can wear or carry merchandise such as a bag or T-Shirt to Advertise as a conversation starter. So, people ask. They initiate the conversation. You only speak for a maximum of 2 minutes and use weasel words.*

We have to accept that it is similar to preaching a religion or wanting people to join our political party. Try not to take it personally, Door to Door Sales people do not. Other ideas to Sell an idea or product is by giving a leaflet.

David Mackenzie Ogilvy stated, I prefer the discipline of knowledge to the anarchy of ignorance. Mr Ogilvy was known as the ‘Father of Advertising’.

Granny would tease me for being a Saucebox when she heard me talking on the phone for business. It’s a Welsh colloquialism meaning Silver-tongued.

I obtained the Gift of the Gab from her and my father. Now, HE was an amazing orator, enchanted large audiences and he would practice his speeches at home. If I accidentally caught him in the act, he would become embarrassed. Bowing my head, I would quietly retreat closing the door, lingering by sitting on the bottom step. Then listen to his passionate delivery. Afterwards, sneaking upstairs to finish my homework.

😘

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to Narwhal10

I am very familiar Narwhal10 with the Ogilvy's as my older brother left Newcastle Polytechnic many years ago and had his first job in Advertising with them. He worked for them for over 20 yeayand then was headhunted by Saatchi ! How strange that you should mention them and your nond to Wales too. We both went to boarding school in Colwyn Bay. Your post made me both smile and feel a bit emotional strangely. Lots of memories!

I shall keep trying - what are weasle words please. I confess I have become more selective with who I try to 'convert' I am actually much more successful with arousing interest in HRT, why is that I wonder?

Lovely story about your father 🥰

Narwhal10 profile image
Narwhal10 in reply to Ipsofacto01

I adore nostalgia. It is Your Story, Ipsofacto01.

Weasel words are to entice people. In my reply, I used amazing, enchanted, passionate, retreat, linger, sneak. These emotionally draw a person in and capture their minds and imagination.

P.S. This heat in the U.K. makes my body more weird than normal. 🤪😘

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to Narwhal10

Ah interesting. I shall try a new weasle word a week 😊

Yes, it's too hot. I was secretly enjoying the washout summer!

I just read your bio, what an amazing life lived! 💕

Carrie234 profile image
Carrie234 in reply to Narwhal10

I love that your Granny called you a Saucebox, Narwhal10, that is charming 😄

GracePV profile image
GracePV

Yes. I have friends that have B12 def. symptoms but they are very resistant to try it out. And they can't really give me convincing reasons as to why not. Its infuriating!

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to GracePV

It's strange isn't it? My theory is the word Vitamin in front of B12! A lot of people just don't take it seriously. I have to admit, I had never heard of B12 before I was diagnosed just under 10 years ago.

PlatypusProfit8077 profile image
PlatypusProfit8077 in reply to Ipsofacto01

Yes! Let’s change it to cobalamin deficiency! Or something equally grandiose and important sounding!

KBird01 profile image
KBird01 in reply to PlatypusProfit8077

I think that's a great idea! 👍

Treesong2023 profile image
Treesong2023

I am with you! I get very frustrated about it ...as I feel its so prevelent...and largely ignored...its a Pernicious Plague

I have got my sisters, brother, close cousins all to check.. I am now a B12 Zealot ! My sister is confirmed borderline B12 too. She get what she calls the tinglies..thought it was the menopause!

The sore point in all of my health detecting is the falling out with the GPs. They go all cold and distant on you when you dont go with their "directions"...

Initially, they were good as gold, and did a sweep of tests, and I did loads of diagnostic tests privately ...but when my GP saw my serum B12 was in the 400's...it was a done deal...

I was literally called in and told ."..look dear..the tests show you are in good health for your age ...and... "..we think this is all about ...Health Anxiety....and there is a lot of it about..." I cried because I was happy if it actually WAS nothing...

But my fatigue continued, the tongue get redder, my anaemia resisted treatment..my MCV hit a 101 ..stll no action...then the nerve damage happened. Thanks to help in here...I acted.

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to Treesong2023

It's good that you have had some luck with your family, I have been unsuccessful there.Thank goodness for this group. I have signposted people here, hoping they will read even if they don't post.

I was lucky that my GP knew about B12 and it was them who suggested I was tested after me saying I just wanted to lay down and die I was so tired.

My current GP just lets me get on with SI. I do confess to enjoying the baulk reaction when I tell other medical professionals I self inject. I tell them I'm never going back there again, so they know not to mess with me on it.

It just feels a bit hopeless sometimes. Attitudes may change but it feels like such a slow process. A few high profile people banging the drums would make such a huge difference to people's views I think.

I live in hope!

Narwhal10 profile image
Narwhal10 in reply to Treesong2023

Great you Acted. A couple of years ago, I met a new doctor to me. He announced a diagnosis which the computer had told him I had. So, me being me shrugged and said quietly, If you say so.

You see doctors are programmed in their thinking by their studies, their peers, their CCG’s algorithms, the cut-off levels and ranges are decided. around a table.

The problem is according to my medical records, I studied I.T. No, I didn’t, I studied the maths and science behind it. To create something that happens in a blink of an eye (which is approximately 100 to 150 milliseconds.) Of course, I am adept at the Art of illusion and magic.

The Time is 14:41

😜

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to Narwhal10

Haha you do have a way with words Narwhal10 😄 you have really made me smile.

Treesong2023 profile image
Treesong2023 in reply to Narwhal10

Narwhal, I imagine you to be both deft and astute in all you do.. handling truth and artifice (when needed) with equal skill... :-)

grumpyold profile image
grumpyold in reply to Treesong2023

Your story is so similar to mine, even had the same patronising speech from the medics beginning "look dear......."🤬

I am at the stage of taking matters into my own hands, having been fobbed off by my GP re "within range" serum B12 levels and my MCV of 101 (24/11/18) and 102.9 (23/8/23) being "nothing to worry about".

I have SO many symptoms that are totally ignored.

Hence, I have an appointment with the doctor in Cambridge for mid August. Thanks to this forum, I know how to go about helping myself.

Treesong2023 profile image
Treesong2023 in reply to grumpyold

As soon as i got my nerve damage confirmed and MCV at 100, i decided not to take any further chances with my health. Good luck at Cambridge !

grumpyold profile image
grumpyold in reply to Treesong2023

Thankyou.I hate needles, but needs must, as they say.

Sorry state of affairs though, isn't it. Whatever happened to the old NHS care pledge "from the cradle to the grave"😩.

Now it's just " computer says NO ". At my surgery, you could substitute a robot and no-one would spot the difference.

🫂

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot

Hi Ipsofacto

Sadly we have been brainwashed to accept being sick as we get old.

We have been taught to revere medics.

We have been taught to be passive in our health journey.

We are overwhelmed with social media twaddle that it’s hard to see the wood for the trees

Some of us have woken up - but we are a joyous and more healthy minority.

Almost 2 years post diagnosis and friends and family are finally noticing that I have overtaken them in the health stakes - now they are starting to take notice and ask questions.

Row your own boat and lead by example.

🤗🤗🤗

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to Wwwdot

Yes, we are joyous and more healthy. I have lived through that 'fog' my whole life. I am so grateful for my renewed vigor. I just want to share that knowledge. I was told by a colleague a couple of weeks ago it's the placebo effect.

Love that row your own boat 🥰🥰 it will have to be one armed though as I've just had shoulder surgery 😅😅

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot in reply to Ipsofacto01

Hi Ipsofacto

No way is it a placebo effect.

I posted a podcast this morning by a NHS GP and he absolutely dismisses placebo effect. Well worth a listen - several times - on my third listen today - packed full of info.

🤗🤗🤗

Ipsofacto01 profile image
Ipsofacto01 in reply to Wwwdot

Thank you I will have a listen 🤗🤗🤗

Treesong2023 profile image
Treesong2023 in reply to Wwwdot

Sad but true....but really good for you Wwwdot. :-)

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot in reply to Treesong2023

Treesong

Thank you for your well wishes.

🤗🤗🤗

Sleepybunny profile image
Sleepybunny

Hi,

My family have got fed up of me talking about B12.

I don't think they realise just how many symptoms it can cause.

I sent a copy of Martyn Hooper's book " What You Need to Know about Vitamin B12 deficiency and Pernicious Anaemia" to some of my relatives. If they choose to leave it on the shelf or stick it in the bin at least I've tried to help.

Maybe you could give your friend a copy or a copy of these books.

"Could it be B12" by Sally Pacholok and J.J, Stuart

"Vitamin B12 Deficiency in Clinical Practice: "Doctor, you gave me my life back!"

Dr Joseph Chandy Kayyalackakom MD and Hugo Minney PhD

Or watch a film/video

pernicious-anaemia-society....

b12info.com/films/

I often end up talking to random strangers about B12 deficiency.

Other ways to raise awareness

Put a poster in window/notice board

b12info.com/posters/

pernicious-anaemia-society....

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot in reply to Sleepybunny

Hi Sleepybunny

You were one of my saviours with your abundance and generosity of information. There are many on here who listen and recover because of our willingness to share our experiences.

It is a hard line to walk between caring at all and caring too much. I don’t always get it right!

🤗🤗🤗

Baklava22 profile image
Baklava22

My daughter in law rolls her eyes if I mention it. Her look insinuates I’m a hypochondriac just making it up.

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot in reply to Baklava22

Hi Baklava

Our lovely friend Narwhal10 calls that looking for their brain! Whenever that happens to me I think of that and inwardly smile!

🤗🤗🤗

Sleepybunny profile image
Sleepybunny in reply to Baklava22

That's rather sad, many of us here get treated as hypochondriacs by our doctors...I even got diagnosed with hypochondria along with other labels eg MUPs (medically unexplained symptoms), psychosomatic symptoms, functional neurological disorder despite me suffering many typical B12 deficiency symptoms.

Sometimes the only way people understand is if they suffer the same symptoms and I can't bear the thought of other people going through what I went through.

MindfulSquirrel profile image
MindfulSquirrel

Tbf there are a LOT of people talking twaddle about certain health conditions, particularly ones that medicine doesn’t yet fully understand and/or have minimal focus in training. I’m sure you were talking anything but twaddle Ipsofactor01 🙂, but I also don’t think it’s a bad thing for people to be initially thoughtful and selecting when being told new information.

As part of my health journey I’ve dipped my toe into the whole MTHFR thing and there are people who talk some right cr*p about that. You’ve got to be careful about your sources, which is hard when there’s not much peer reviewed literature out there. My first introduction to a B12 group was also completely ridiculous - I left within a couple of days after someone told me my life long neurodivergence was all B12 related. 😒

Persuading cautious people falls into two camps IME. There are those, like how I’ve mostly been, who are generally open minded but want to see the evidence. Some of the recent excellent journal articles can solve that. Then there’s the people who firmly believe something contradictory and become cognitively dissonant when given information, becoming more entrenched in their views when presented with evidence. This is much more tricky but things like empathising with their views and clever questioning are more likely to be helpful.

E2A: and of course it is still important to check in with yourself and your own views from time to time, to check you haven’t become too entrenched to one possibility and therefore are equally dissonant about differing scenarios.

PlatypusProfit8077 profile image
PlatypusProfit8077 in reply to MindfulSquirrel

This!!! And it’s so freaking hard to be discerning and careful when you feel so awful and there’s someone promising you that everything wrong will get better if you do XYZ strictly.

Especially with the cognitive/mental health impact that B12 often has.

My MIL is a huge conspiracy…ummm…fan and believes the most random and wild things. But regularly says “oh don’t trust everything on the internet!” and then turns around to share this random cure-all that Random123 she found on a deep dark corner website in XYZ country and then paid money to access. Sigh.

Orchard33 profile image
Orchard33

Yes. I know the feeling. I don't bang on these days. Takes too much energy.

Cherylclaire profile image
CherylclaireForum Support in reply to Orchard33

Energy is so precious when you have to eke it out daily, isn't it ?

When young people who have abused nitrous oxide (now alarmingly used in large canisters rather than the silver capsules) end up in wheelchairs through nerve damage, it is still rarely mentioned publicly that this is caused by vitamin B12 deficiency. Nitrous oxide depletes B12, so regular use of a lot of nitrous oxide will deplete B12 rapidly and massively.

Sadly, those neurologists mentioned earlier by Ipsofacto01 and PlatypusProfit8077 will finally understand that B12 deficiency can go way beyond tiredness, as they become increasingly familiar with these cases and their common cause.

Even those close to us can have trouble with what is/isn't B12 deficiency. Even we are not always sure ! Such a relief to have people on the forum to check with.

MrsTuft profile image
MrsTuft

'You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink'. My MIL is severely folate deficient - it was treated once by the GP and then she was put on heavy medication when it fell again. I tried to tell her to take folate but she went berserk and we now no longer speak. I think the difficulty is that some people take their doctor's word as gospel and most don't believe nutrient deficiencies can make you that ill.

Sleepybunny profile image
Sleepybunny in reply to MrsTuft

That's a sad story MrsTuft.

If people I think have B12 deficiency dismiss what I'm saying, I try to remember that B12 deficiency can affect people's moods and ability to make good judgements.

B12 deficiency and mental health

b12info.com/mental-health/

stichtingb12tekort.nl/engli...

pernicious-anaemia-society....

Folate deficiency can also cause neuropychiatric symptoms.

If interested, search online for "folate deficiency neuropsychiatric symptoms"

I think these UK documents mention neuropsychiatric effects of folate deficiency

NICE CKS Anaemia - B12 and Folate deficiency

cks.nice.org.uk/topics/anae...

BSH Cobalamin and Folate guidelines

b-s-h.org.uk/guidelines/gui...

MrsTuft profile image
MrsTuft in reply to Sleepybunny

Thank you yes I already know that, but I cannot force her and must let it go. x

Rexz profile image
Rexz

Always!

Hectorsmum2 profile image
Hectorsmum2

I have noticed that people are very wary of any kind of persaution. I experimented with my children with this. I never once tried to encourage them to eat fruit or veg. I just put it on their plates or ate it infront of them. They are both teenagers now and eat tons of vegitable matter every week. I think it can be more helpful to drop a morsal of information into a conversation that to say to much and start sounding like you are trying to persaude.n I suggested that somebody take a look at the perncious aneamia society website the other day and they seemed pleased with the information.

MoKayD profile image
MoKayD

Everyone I know laughs when they hear me get up on my B12 soap box. I will talk about it to anyone at anytime. I have successfully convinced 5 friends/relatives to get their B12 tested and all were found to be deficient and are now on monthly shots. My sister was very resistant, probably because she's my older sister and feels advice from her little sister is silly. She tells me all of the time now how good she feels after her shots. What I really don't understand is the lack of curiosity about B12 these individuals have. They are happy to receive B12 injections but don't seem to want to explore further knowledge on the subject.

JonHU profile image
JonHU

My blood tests showed low b12 and anemia for several years before my doctor took it at all seriously, and even then... And by the time I started noticing encroaching neuropathic symptoms (in addition to the numbness I had following an auto accident), it was probably a bit late to avoid additional permanent nerve injury. It was about 10 years after the first blood tests that showed low B12 and ferritin that I was able to get my doctor to actually test specifically for pernicious anemia. And this was because I reminded them that I had two family members who had been diagnosed with pernicious anemia.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Was thinking of Dr. Chandy yesterday, God bless him for having such courage

Long story but I have had a couple of head MRIs due to lesions that are perpendicular in nature. To...

Intrinsic Factor Negative

I’ve been feeling grotty for a couple of years and have thyroid antibodies. Started on...

MTHFR testing

I was wondering how one would test for MTHFR mutation. I'm in England and would like to know about...

Excess Folic Acid and Vitamin B12 Deficiency: Clinical Implications?

This is a very recent paper. Some of the areas covered are well-known. Such as not treating B12...

When will it end?

In the 1970s I had severe anxiety and panic attacks: in the 80s I developed ME which lasted into...