Elderly relative ignoring my advice r... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

32,679 members24,077 posts

Elderly relative ignoring my advice re B12.

charks profile image
31 Replies

I wonder if others on this forum have a similar problem and can help.

My MIL is 91 and has some symptoms of B12D, Which could be put down to 'old age' but I'm beginning to wonder if a lot of 'old age' is really B12D.

We have repeatedly told her about the importance of B12 and how many older people have a deficiency. Despite buying her pills she isn't taking them. It doesn't help that her other son ( she thinks the sun shines out his a****) tells her that we are talking rubbish and she doesn't need them .

Today she was complaining that she has started to misspell. She knows that a word is wrong but she just can't remember how it should be spelt. I told her that I had a similar problem when I had low levels of B12 but it just goes over her head.

We can't understand why she won't take B12. It's only one little pill a day. Any advice on how to persuade to her to take them would be welcome.

Written by
charks profile image
charks
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
31 Replies
wedgewood profile image
wedgewood

You are absolutely right about many old people lacking in Vitamin B12 , because it is a known fact that as we grow older we produce less stomach acid . Stomach acid is needed to help break down food and prepare it for being absorbed. B12 is especially difficult to absorb . We all know what it’s like to have B12 deficiency l We also know that B12 cannot be overdosed. …

Lots of older people hate taking pills . , and I can understand that . I think she might well be prepared to use a B12 mouth spray , B12 drops Or one of those very small B12 sub-lingual lozenges , which dissolve in the mouth - no swallowing . ( all obtainable on Amazon .)

Show your mother in law and her son an article about older people producing less stomach acid, which leads to B12 deficiency, and all which that entails . Just Google and you will find one .

Best of luck . You are very kind to your MIL .

charks profile image
charks in reply towedgewood

We have tried to get them to read articles on B12. The problem is that they aren't readers. My MIL doesn't have a single book in the house. She just watches TV. The complete opposite of mine who wouldn't have a TV and read all day long.

Another problem is that the other son's partner heard how B12 made my sight much better. Without consulting me she tried B12 expecting it to do the same for her. When it didn't she told my MIL that taking it was a waste of time.

So we are up against a prejudice re B12 as well.

wedgewood profile image
wedgewood in reply tocharks

Well you have done everything possible . How disheartening for you .

FancyPants54 profile image
FancyPants54 in reply tocharks

You are up against wilful ignorance I'm afraid. Nothing you can do about that. Leave them to it. Don't get yourself stressed.

I can't imagine not having a book in the house! I instantly disliked this woman when I read that 😆. I have a house full of books but we don't own a single TV. Never have.

charks profile image
charks in reply toFancyPants54

I'm sorry to say I feel the same way about my MIL. Years ago ( 47 years) when I first start living with my partner we decided not to have a TV as we thought they were conversation killers. We lasted until the world cup!!!

bookish profile image
bookish in reply toFancyPants54

Same here....(books, no TV)

tomdickharry profile image
tomdickharry in reply tocharks

Could you persuade her to see a doctor? If GP not sympathetic towards B12 or PA, then a private one. It might not just be age, acid, or diet, but malabsorption or PA.

charks profile image
charks in reply totomdickharry

Her GP is useless. She complained that she was really unsteady on her feet and he just told her it was old age and nothing could be done. She is of that age group who totally believe what their doctor tells them.

tomdickharry profile image
tomdickharry in reply tocharks

That's very sad. Unless there is a social worker or similar involved I can't see what else you could do for her. If you're religious, maybe pray?

Jillymo profile image
Jillymo

As well meaning that your concern is it's her choice. You have made her aware that she could have an issue with her B12 you can do no more.

Wish I had a neighbour like yourself looking out for me. 💐

MrsTuft profile image
MrsTuft

You can lead a horse to water but you can’t make it drink! My MIL had diagnosed severe folate deficiency - she had awful psychiatric and physical symptoms - but refused to take the pills and our nagging her to take them (when the rest of her ignorant family told her a vitamin can’t make you that ill- she must be mentally ill - and to take antidepressants) caused such a huge bust up that now we now longer see or speak to her as she was so vile. You are kind to try to help but you might have to let it go. Sadly they can’t think straight and don’t want any advice. Their choice.

Singoutloud profile image
Singoutloud

If she prefers to watch TV rather than read, perhaps the Sally Pacholok movie might be a better way to go. My PA had a massive effect on my love of reading for years and only recently have I been able to tackle a whole book.

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan in reply toSingoutloud

That's reassuring for me.I'm able to ow watch TV.

( 3 years couldn't)

Bug still unable to read a book however short .

Will hope for the future

Wheat profile image
Wheat in reply toNackapan

🥰

FancyPants54 profile image
FancyPants54 in reply toNackapan

Sometimes we look at the thing we are most familiar with and blame it for everything. A life-long avid reader I suddenly couldn't concentrate on a book at all. I went for a period of a few years not reading more than a few short articles about hypothyroidism, which I also have.

The thing that got me back reading again was HRT. Low oestrogen literally dulled my brain to mush. Have you got that area covered? If not, it's worth trying it to see if that might help you.

Nackapan profile image
Nackapan in reply toFancyPants54

I had a trial of HRT . Not good .Weaned off after 10 days.

I was an emotional mess then s 6 day migraine

Yhd menopause was my trigger though.

Thanks anyhow fof your thoughts

Cherylclaire profile image
CherylclaireForum Support in reply toNackapan

Still improving, though ! Noticeably- although seems slow to you probably.

I can tell when I'm having a bit of a bad day. It takes a really long time to untangle the words I'm typing here: right letters, completely the wrong order. Like my fingers trying to outpace my irritatingly slow brain.

Even with TV, I look forward to watching something good, only to find that, by the time it comes on, I can't concentrate that hard for that length of time and need to find an excuse not to stay on the sofa. Like watching sport - sometimes, I end up more exhausted than the athletes. Football or rugby especially depleting - let's hope today's 6 Nations worth the effort !

Cherylclaire profile image
CherylclaireForum Support in reply toSingoutloud

Yes, me too !

I started back by reading graphic novels - the visual clues helped my cognitive confusion and memory issues.

Enjoying catching up now by reading aloud to partner: short chapters, not too many characters and not too convoluted a plot. All of that helps.

Currently enjoying Sheila Hancock's Old Rage.

Mixteca profile image
Mixteca in reply toCherylclaire

I've always been an avid reader but have gotten so ill I can't any more and can only manage audiobooks. I'd love to hear Old Rage but there's no audio in my library's catalogue 😢 Don't want to pay for Audible.

Cherylclaire profile image
CherylclaireForum Support in reply toMixteca

It would be lovely to hear her speaking her own words, wouldn't it ? Let's hope that happens soon.

Incidentally, she has an autoimmune condition - rheumatoid arthritis.

charks profile image
charks in reply toSingoutloud

I'm afraid she only watches rubbish TV. She would never watch anything that needs thinking about.

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot

Hi Charks

Be naughty! Look for foods she likes and see if you can sneak in B12 - ie a cake and pop the B12 in the icing. Got to confess I have had to resort to similar tactics! Or get a B12 complex and a few drops in a favourite tipple? She’s doing well at 91 so she is a wily old fox! 🦊 you need to quietly outwit! Best of luck and remember you can only try and care!

🤗🤗🤗

alchemilla12 profile image
alchemilla12 in reply toWwwdot

Hmm, Im really not sure that is a good suggestion! Medicating someone without their consent however well intentioned is wrong in my opinion

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot in reply toalchemilla12

Totally agree. I am sure Charks is wise enough to sort wheat from chaff on the forum. But point taken and apologies if I caused offence.

🤗🤗🤗

alchemilla12 profile image
alchemilla12 in reply toWwwdot

Im sure no offence has been taken -I certainly havent but just wanted to give my tuppence worth. It's a dodgy path to take but Im sure it was not a completely serious suggestion however tempting!😄

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot in reply toalchemilla12

Yes we all have worn similar tee-shirts at one time of the other!

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot in reply toalchemilla12

What about chicken liver pate? Yum!

charks profile image
charks in reply toWwwdot

Shame B12 liquid is such a vibrant red. Very difficult to disguise. Unless you like red wine!!!

Wwwdot profile image
Wwwdot in reply tocharks

Ha ha!! Yes if only life was so easy! The B12 drops and powder are a lurid yellow! Does she like liver? Most people that age love liver a perhaps liver pate? Oh the joys of family and loved ones!

🤗🤗🤗

Fluffyfloo profile image
Fluffyfloo

I wouldn't give up trying. It's very easy for anyone to attribute B12 problems to something else. Giving up on her now might cause more problems for you in the long run if you stop trying on her behalf because you're probably right, and they all just don't know it.

Sleepybunny profile image
Sleepybunny

Hi,

If your MIL is starting to struggle cognitively, might be worth her considering making a Power of Attorney. There are two types, one for health matters and one for financial matters.

gov.uk/power-of-attorney

Tactics

I liked     Singoutloud 's suggestion of watching the Sally Pacholok movie.

Films/videos PA/B12 deficiency

b12info.com/films/

pernicious-anaemia-society....

If you search online for "Sally Pacholok slide show anti-ageing conference" it should show a link to a presentation Sally Pacholok, author of Could it Be b12? book, gave some years ago.

What about a food hamper with B12 rich foods?

    Wwwdot mentioned liver pate.

I found some ideas when I searched for "B12 foods" and "foods fortified with B12".

I thought     wedgewood 's suggestion of a b12 spray or sublingual tablets was a good one.

There are stories on Tracy Witty's blog and PAS website about elderly people with B12 deficiency. Maybe someone could read one of the shorter ones to her.

b12info.com/christine-begge...

b12info.com/a-year-to-the-d...

b12info.com/case-studies/paul/

pernicious-anaemia-society....

pernicious-anaemia-society....

pernicious-anaemia-society....

NHS link about B12 deficiency - Causes section says

"Both vitamin B12 deficiency and folate deficiency are more common in older people, affecting around 1 in 10 people aged 75 or over and 1 in 20 people aged 65 to 74."

nhs.uk/conditions/vitamin-b...

There might be some useful info in this thread

Elderly relative's B12 injections stopped by GP after 30years

healthunlocked.com/pasoc/po...

Articles from The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing (TILDA)

tcd.ie/news_events/articles...

tilda.tcd.ie/news-events/20...

I'm not medically trained.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

I'm back ;) Advice re mother & functional B12 deficiency

Hiya! So it's been a while since I've visited these forums! I was diagnosed B12 deficient last July...

B12, me and my family

Just thought that I'd update on the experiment with adenosyl B12 which I've now been using for a...
Gambit62 profile image
Administrator

Scientific paper needed re ignoring high serum B12 levels following loading doses

My daughter went back to her Gp as she relapsed back to being totally exhausted and unwell and mood...
LovesLuna profile image

Help my elderly mum - please

Hi there, my mum (79) is B12 deficient (like me and my sister and auntie) and when tested had a...
Colb53 profile image

Nitrofurantoin Antibiotics up date

I have been really frightened this last week. I thought I might be seriously ill. So many of my...

Moderation team

See all
Foggyme profile image
FoggymeAdministrator
Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator
taka profile image
takaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.