It might sound silly but ... - Pernicious Anaemi...

Pernicious Anaemia Society

32,628 members23,990 posts

It might sound silly but ...

specialk16 profile image
6 Replies

Hi lovely people,

I have a question please.

If your intrinsic factor is not working and you have PA would it not still show up on tests even if you are having b12 injections? I know it skews the results I just wondered if it was possible to test positive at all.

Just had a haemotologist apt and test came back negative for PA yet the haemotologist said you have b12 in your tissue because last injected 4 weeks previously though he says it's highly likely you have PA. obviously he said we would need to be off all treatment for 6 months then retest. Not prepared to do that.

My sons original test he had low b12 (164.4) low folate, vit D etc but no blood cell changes. I had the same b12 of 95 yet I had increased variety of red shaped blood cells - anisocytosis. (I have IBS aswell - no found cause when investigated). Does this indicate he may not have PA yet I might? Or bares no relevance at all?

Just mulling things over trying to understand how this all works!

On another note how do you get PA on your medical records if your never diagnosed but haemotologist says you do. Feel a bit of a fraud saying might have PA yet no definitive answer.

Many thanks

SpecialK

Written by
specialk16 profile image
specialk16
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
6 Replies
fbirder profile image
fbirder

There is no definitive test for PA. the anti-IF test can show that you almost certainly do have PA if the result is positive. But a negative result doesn't mean that you don't have it.

There is a test for anti-GPC (Gastric Parietal Cell) antibodies. If that's negative then you probably dont have PA, but a positive result doesn't mean that you do have PA.

The modern anti-IF test doesn't suffer interference from B12, so supplementation shouldn't affect it. The old test did suffer interference, but even that didn't need to stop B12 for 6 months.

I persuaded my haematologist that I did have PA. on our one meeting he started off by saying - categorically - that I didn't have pernicious anaemia. This was purely on the fact that I hadn't had an anti-IF test. I asked what other expiation he had for the set of following facts - low serum B12, metaplastic gastric atrophy, positive anti-GPC antibodies, symptoms reducing with B12 treatment. He reluctantly admitted I might have it.

I don't know if I have PA on my records, and I'm not at all worried about it. All I care about is getting treatment that works.

The way I see it (and the recommendations of the BCSH) is that low B12 should be assumed to be a permanent problem unless some definite temporary cause can be determined. I don't take PPIs, I don't abuse nitrous oxide, I'm not pregnant, I'm not vegan and I haven't had GI tract surgery. Whatever causes my low B12 isn't temporary. It doesn't matter if they call it PA or a bad dose of slithy toves - the treatment is the same.

specialk16 profile image
specialk16 in reply tofbirder

So dammed if you do and dammed if you don't on the testing front then!

Do the NHS have modern testing methods?

The haemotologist was lovely, the first NHS doctor to actually listen yet he wouldn't go any further than 1 injection every 4 weeks. He felt he didn't have evidence that more was required. I just feel like I have treated both my son and myself for b12 without doctors help and it's tough to know the right thing to do. Neither of us feel particularly well most of the time yet we are vastly improved since starting b12. It's quite an odd situation. My son doesn't want to self inject as I do twice a week. Still trying to get rid of the dam pins and needles. I just worry about his future and not having that GP support is an issue.

Thank you for your time and knowledge fbirder a wealth of knowledge as usual xx

fbirder profile image
fbirder in reply tospecialk16

Yes, the NHS does, on the whole, have modern testing methods. The assay that is not affected by high concentrations of B12 was developed about 10 years ago. The older assay dates from the late 1980s. But I'll bet that's still used in some places.

The old assay gave false positives with very high levels of B12 (more than 2000). The new one doesn't.

accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_doc...

I inject once a week to keep the crippling fatigue at bay. I was worried that my neuropathy was getting worse so I saw a neurologist. It turns out my problem isn't B12 related, so I'm stuck with it.

Might be worth seeing a neurologist to get an expert opinion.

specialk16 profile image
specialk16 in reply tofbirder

Ah, yes, my son saw 4 neurologist- none picked up on b12.

My gp said he wouldn't extend the curtesy to me of seeing a specialist when he finally made apt to see haemotologist for my son. He is a real charmer this gp!

I have little faith in all doctors at the moment, maybe in time. I am loads better just every now and then the fatigue hits and pins and needles usually after 8 hour shift at work!

Many thanks for your info, I shall have a good read.

Thank you xx

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator

Don't know where needing to stop for six months comes from in testing for PA, a week to 10 days should be sufficient time to stop. If the test is done to soon after supplementation then there is a chance of a false positive

IFA is prone to false negatives 40% - 60% of the time depending on the exact method used so a negative is a long way from ruling out PA as a possibility, and it still remains the most likely explanation for a B12 deficiency that isn't caused by diet.

PA is sometimes used as a short hand for deficiency caused by any absorption problem - rather than a specific auto-immune condition, so it may be that haemo was a being a bit loose with his terminology and talking about confirming a B12 absorption problem - which would mean laying off supplements for six months.

Like fbirder I don't have a diagnosis of B12 but I do know that I have an absorption problem and need to find non-dietary ways of getting my B12 as a result .... and I manage to sort out the treatment that I need.

B12 deficiency causes macrocytosis because of the part B12 plays in reproduction of DNA and hence the part it plays in the production of normal shaped red blood cells. It would appear that anisocytosis is also more prevalent in B12 deficient patients.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

specialk16 profile image
specialk16 in reply toGambit62

Hi Gambit62,

Haemo did start the conversation with I only know a little bit about b12! He said it was prone to false negatives also but I was hoping for more b12 injections say 2 a month but he wouldn't budge. We will find a way round it I am sure.

Thank you xx

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Below range b12 - advice needed

Hello all, I'm posting on behalf of my brother who had some private blood tests done to look at...
foxrabbit profile image

This might be a silly question...

I couldn't get my GP to test for PA so I started supplementing with B12 tablets regardless. When I...

Halo test.

Ok, my 18 year old son has Gastritis diagnosed in Nov 16. His last B12 test was 174 (within range...

Have your doctor got a right to stop your B12 injection for 6 months with pernicious anaemia.

Hi everyone, I have had PA for the past 7 years and having my B12 injections every 10 weeks....
salsadancer profile image

Can 2 + 2 ever make anything but 4

20 years ago my then GP diagnosed PA, and started me with injections. One of the symptoms I had at...
Lilian15 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62Administrator
Foggyme profile image
FoggymeAdministrator
taka profile image
takaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.