Did you have the scans on the same machine? There are discrepancies between readings from different machines, but even if using the same one there's a margin of error, however well done it is. Arthritis in your spine or a healed fracture could give a higher reading, but any vertebrae affected this way should be onitted. , Add to that potential operator error.... However, having said all that, those are very good scores, only on the cusp of osteoporosis and below average loss of density for your hip, scarcely even osteopenia for your spine.
Thanks Met00. The scans were at the same hospital and the individual references etc seem to indicate it's still the same machine.
The Renal doctor wants me to either go on Adcal D3 or Alendronate depending whether my doctor determines me to have osteopenia or osteoporosis. Given that only one reading is at -2.5 then I would not want the Alendronate. However my Vitamin D and calcium levels are both fine so I'm not sure what good Adcal D3 would be.
Have you had a fragility fracture or some other reason to be at high fracture risk? Otherwise I don't understand why you need meds. Make sure you get enough calcium in your diet. A vitamin D supplement is a good idea unless you have high Vit D blood levels, as this helps with calcium absorption, plus Vit K2 to help direct calcium to the bones. Eat healthily and get plenty of weight bearing exercise with impact.
Perhaps I should have said that as a kidney transplant patent, I am on steroids for life which of course reduces bone density - I'm only on a relatively low dose of 5mg prednisolone.
I have had breaks etc but not due to fragility - usually due to instability!
It depends whether the fractures happened unexpectedly, eg just falling from standing height - fragility fractures, without impact, that wouldn't happen to someone with normal bone density. That is a significant factor in determining whether medication is recommended. If you've fallen over and broken a wrist, for example, then there's a good chance you'll have more fractures and the medication aims to reduce the risk of these. Opinion, however, is divided over how effective the medication is. Also bear in mind that 19% risk of fracture (probably calculated for the next 10 years) is still 81% chance of not fracturing. It depends how you view risk, and what you think of the medication.
Thanks Met00. Any fractures I've had have been bad falls etc. I've had many more falls without fractures so I feel pretty certain that historically no fractures have been due to low b bone density
Hi Haptalon, long-term use of prednisone is indeed associated with increased risk of fractures.
We invite you to take an assessment via the American Bone Health Fracture Risk Calculator. By entering all your various medical conditions and medications etc., you'll get a fuller picture of your fracture risk. Bone density score is only one factor -- and often not the most important factor. americanbonehealth.org/calc...
Do you have arthritis in your spine? That can sometimes skew the readings and make the bones appear more dense.
Also, wasa the scan done on the same machine by the same technician. Not getting the proper alignment and the exact same frame will change the results. (A certified densiometrist is skilled at getting the right placement. Not all techncians have those credentials.)
They show 10 year fracture risks as: Major Osteoporotic Fracture 19% and Hip fracture 7.3%. These compare to the levels 7 years ago of 13% and 4.6% respectively.
No one has mentioned anything about bone turnover.
Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.
Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.