Cheat days - how often?: See, I'm on day... - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

114,596 members60,925 posts

Cheat days - how often?

19 Replies

See, I'm on day 4, and thinking of a cheat day already. :)

How often do you allow yourself to break your diet and eat your favorite foods guilt-free? Or, how often is it okay to do it? Does it do a lot of harm to your progress? Do you exercise more afterwards to burn it off?

19 Replies
Annde70 profile image
Annde70

I would endeavour to resist cheat days for at least the first month. This really is not a habit you want to get in to.  Once you see how your weight loss is going you will be better equipped to judge how often you can afford to go off plan without sabotaging your weight loss journey.  As with everything connected with losing weight we are all different and what one person can get away with will completely wreck another persons weight loss

TheHud profile image
TheHud

Never guilt free.  It's a slippy road to hell and the 'oh just the one and another and it was OK the other day'.  If you are going to cheat then aim for a special occasion and you have to lose this amount by then.  There has been the easter bunny challenge and I am going to be 2lb short of target because I re-set it, but it means no bunny! ;(

in reply to TheHud

Don't worry, no bunny, grilled sausage and sour rye soup for me too this weekend. But that's only for the better! :)

elliebath profile image
elliebathMaintainer

Don't think of Cheat Days, it is a negative term.

 But in my opinion, a Treat Day or Meal can be manageable without ruining your progress . You can have some pieces of easter egg ( sharing is good ! ) and count it into your days calories.

Or if you really dont trust yourself , don't have any at all ever, but in my experience denying yourself completely means you never learn the principle of moderation , which we all need to learn  going forward, if we are to keep the weight off longterm.

 I speak from personal experience.  I lost my excess 30 lbs on 1400cals of assorted foods,  including small amounts of wine and chocolate. That was in 2014 / 15 , and I've since maintained my goal weight since april 2015.   

kantara71 profile image
kantara71

Don't do it!! Analyse what are your "favourite" foods do these include sugar laden biscuits, cakes, chocolate, pizza, take aways etc? if so then those are what brought you to here in the first place! 

You will start to discover new, healthy favourites as your taste changes and you see the benefits of the eating plan. 

You have hardly started so you still have cravings for the "foods" that put the weight on in the first place, as has been suggested, keep going for at least a month or set a target of losing half a stone and then have a non food treat to celebrate :-)

Do not go there ! :-) John

in reply to kantara71

It was just a question, i'm not going to give up for a cheat day after a week :) I came here to change my life so that's what I'm going to do :) 

kantara71 profile image
kantara71 in reply to

I think everyone has given you the answer to your question mamiyou :-) The thing is we have all had these evil thoughts and paid for it after ha ha!! Good luck :-) John

I think  you should think about what is that you really want. For example, I have to attend a leaving party tonight and my colleague wanted to buy me a drink all week, so I decided: I allow myself a bottle of Koppaberg which is 211 from my daily intake. You can do this with a dessert, cake etc.  That is a treat. A celebration. This is why you can have everything in MODERATION.  Having a lighter lunch to balance work really well. 

 If you have an actual cheat DAY, that will easily end up above 2000 even 2500 calories. It is fine if you have strong self control and can work very hard after. But in all honestly, that will take you some time to do right. Really sit down and calculate how many exercise slots it will cost you to balance it. So just think about yourself and how you can control the situation. Maybe do some extra sport hangout with friend the following day. Do not let a 'cheat' day to be 'and I do not care' day.  

in reply to

Very well said, thank you :)

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27

I don't so much have a cheat day as a weekly treat - I have a bit of cake once a week - I go out for cake at the weekend, although if someone brings cakes in to the office, I have a bit of that instead and no cake at the weekend. It just means I don't feel like I'm missing out at work, but I can assess whether the cakes on offer look better than I'd get at the coffee shop, so it helps me restrain myself too. And you don't feel so deprived...

You can do something similar, but the treat doesn't have to be cake! An unhealthy side 1 meal a week for example (obviously don't go daft and have a lasagne as a side :p)

in reply to Cooper27

I want lasagne. :'(

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27 in reply to Cooper27

I just re-read my post and realised I wrote the word "cake" about a dozen times in one sentence! Something on the mind I think...

Two people are leaving work today, and I gave £10 to their going away gifts and neither brought in cakes to say thanks/goodbye! I feel duped...

TheHud profile image
TheHud in reply to Cooper27

A good thought about does it look worth it.  I do that 'is it really worth the calories' thing with everything.

tidirhin2548 profile image
tidirhin2548HostRestart April 2024

I'm going to have small treats every now and then, for example Coke Zero, and I've got white wine in fridge for tomorrow. When 12 weeks are over, I'm probably going to indulge in some high-calorie foods like pizza and ice cream, but not during these 12 weeks. 

IndigoBlue61 profile image
IndigoBlue61

I am hopeless at feeling deprived so I am not 'on a diet' 😕 If I really want something I have it but work it into the plan 😊  If it's very calorific I will just have half, but then my losses are slow so it wouldn't suit everyone 😊

Good luck! 

2bFabnfit profile image
2bFabnfit

I calorie cycled which means that I could plan ahead for celebration days without 'cheating'. In some ways it is a healthier way and also meant I never felt deprived when others were partaking of treats. 

Basically it works like this. My daily allowance was 1400. I multiplied x7 but shared them out  across the week. I never went below 1000 a day and never had a high exercise day the same day as a low calorie day. Eg Monday 1000, Tues 1400, Weds 1200, Thurs 1400, Friday (Out for drinks with friends and a meal out) 1800, Saturday1400, Sunday 1600.

I never failed to lose weight whilst in the weight loss phase and have maintained below my goal weight for 6 months. I never felt deprived. I was able to cope with the low days because I looked forward to the treat days knowing I would be able to pretty much eat what I wanted.

Worked for me, hope this helps!

Windswept1 profile image
Windswept1

Who are you cheating?

in reply to Windswept1

Myself, of course :)

GoogleMe profile image
GoogleMe

Cheat day is an alien concept to me. I just don't think of losing weight like that.

My question to myself is "Does this help me achieve something that is important to me?" (and there are more things that are important to me than merely losing weight, although it is important to me)

This does not mean I don't occasionally think "That wasn't worth the calories"

You may also like...

Are cheat days needed? Will there be any effect?

began to diet on saturday 1st July and I am asking to see if cheat days are okay? and whether you...

Snacks how often?

and having an issue knowing if I'm snacking too often or not, should I just have one scheduled...

Diet ‘cheating’

recommended daily to lose weight, how often can I have a ‘cheat’ day?

I Do Not Normally Have a 'CHEAT' Day...However, I Think This Tuesday Will Have To Be The Exception!!! :P

:P I hope you all enjoy your pancakes, if you celebrate it. If not, well I STILL hope you have a...

How many Calories per day?

what have others found? If you don't eat enough each day would this effect your metabolism and slow...